"Kim W5TIT" wrote in message
...
"N2EY" wrote in message
...
In article , "Kim W5TIT"
writes:
Of course not. But I can accurately say that there is no need to roll
everyone who wants to see an end to the test element, into the "no CW
use"
minority (note I said minority), either.
Agreed! Point is, however, that the "no one" statement is simply not
correct.
Let's recall that you are far more into definition than I am, Jim. When I
say "no one" it may not mean *everyone* but it means enough to be counted
as
no one. I believe that the number of folks who wish to see an end to CW
in
the bands of the ARS are so miniscule that the projection of that ever
being
a reality is moot.
Anyone, *anyone* who allows theirself (bad English) to get all in a
huff
about CW use going away or being legislated out of ham radio is being
foolish.
Not necessarily. Not after seeing the mode (not just the test) attacked
the way
I have.
I've seen it attacked also. But I've never for a moment given it any kind
of merit--the mode simply would never be banned from the ARS. Has any
mode
ever been banned? Sure, rules have changed; rules pertaining to power
limits, rules pertaining to test requirements, rules pertaining even (I
believe) to *where* in the bands that different modes are allowed or not.
But I doubt a mode would ever be banned, once implemented and in place.
There are a few who have been proponents of seeing the end of CW;
and when I see those posts, I yawn and go on.
That's *you* - not everyone.
I can't imagine anyone giving merit to the thought that a mode would be
banned. Maybe I am being unrealistic. Using history as a perspective of
measurement; I don't see it ever happening.
There will never be an end to
CW use, and it would never be banned from use in the ham bands...it
just
wouldn't. I think it would be unrealistic to think it would.
I hope you are right about that. Some of us are not about to "trust to
the
kindness of strangers" however
I think I believe it enough that I'll eat my sock (the right foot sock) if
it ever happens.
And, if it
was based off a majority of users of the bands, I rest assured knowing
that
most would not support an end to CW use.
Not now, anyway.
My term "most" includes those people who now and in the future have any
kind
of romantic thought about the ARS. And, I think most do. There are the
few
who would see an end to something they don't like. But, given the desire
and will of most ARS folks, CW--nor any mode for that matter--will
disappear. Now, if I am wrong about history just let me know and I *may*
change my belief.
I think those who are in the
minority are there mostly for the shock value of it.
Perhaps.
But not too long ago, the mere suggestion of *any* class of ham license
with no
code test would have gathered almost no support. And the idea of the
total
abolition of code testing would have been discarded with the claim that
*no-one* wanted all code testing to end.
I can see requirements changing, etc. But, I cannot see the FCC ever
saying, "OK, no more ______ as a legal mode in the ARS."
They way to outlaw something is little by little. Remember your concerns
about
the restrictions on privacy brought about by 'homeland security'
responses?
Little by little....
I have never doubted that the government would do as they have done. I
daresay they were doing under different guises for many years now.
Nothing
different there. It's all about expectation. The expectation that the
FCC
would ever ban a mode is minimal for me.
There was a time when AM was king of the 'phone modes. Then SSB came a
long and
took center stage, while AM was relegated to niche status. Most folks
said
"No-one is against the *use* of AM"....
But, did the FCC ever get anywhere close to seeing its use banned? I am
not, remember, saying that a mode would become so unpopular or disliked on
a
scale such that it would be rare to find it openly being used. I am
saying,
however, that I believe the FCC would never regulate its ban.
But that was not good enough for some, and proposals have arisen every
so
often
to effectively outlaw AM from the ham bands. HF ham bands, anyway. So
far,
none
of them have been successful.
And, I don't think they ever would be.
Up until 20 years ago, the amateur power limit was 1 kW DC input to the
stages
delivering power to the antenna. Then the rules changed to 1.5 kW PEP
output.
For the AM folks, this was effectively a lowering of the power limit to
about
half of what it had been before the change. For SSB folks, it was
effectively
about a 50% raise of the power limit.
LIttle by little...
73 de Jim, N2EY
I do see things changing in the ARS, but not related to the outlawing of a
mode.
Kim W5TIT
Spark was banned. Wide band FM was banned from HF. For decades all we
could do was talk and do CW. It was years fighting to get SSTV allowed.
Then digital, other than RTTY was another long road.
Most of the time the FCC simply didn't bother to authorize a new mode.
Thats how it works Hug and Chalk.
Dan/W4NTI
|