Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Trying to find out what Ferrite material this is.
Larry Benko wrote:
Look at the L/C meter from AADE (Almost All Digital Electronics) www.aade.com which a 1 hour kit for $99. It is quite accurate and uses a variable frequency oscillator so that smaller values of inductance and capacitance are measures at higher frequencies. I own an 8753 HP Network Analyzer and still use the L/C meter most of the time since it is so convenient. It easily can tell the differences between 73/43/31/61 materials. I usually wrap 2 turns thru the torroid to do the measurement. 73, Larry, W0QE That looks like a handy gadget. It wouldn't be very good for working with the kinds of ferrites often used for baluns, wideband transformers, or EMI suppression because of the very low Q encountered. Many of the ferrites I use have a Q of one or less over at least part of the frequency range of operation. And of course the L/C meter wouldn't be useful in assessing the loss or Q of inductors at all. One of the unique things about the HP unit is that it's able to resolve very small R in the presence of large X or vice-versa, which is very difficult to do. But then it costs a couple of orders of magnitude more. A network analyzer is poorly suited for making measurements of impedances which are a great deal higher or lower than 50 ohms. The problem with any of these instruments is that they'll all happily give you an answer, often to several decimal digits. But as Owen pointed out for the 259B, the answer can be anywhere from good to total garbage. The only way to know which is to understand the limitations of your test equipment and something about the nature of the component you're trying to measure. There just isn't any instrument which will do the thinking for you. Roy Lewallen, W7EL |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Trying to find out what Ferrite material this is.
Roy Lewallen wrote:
That looks like a handy gadget. It wouldn't be very good for working with the kinds of ferrites often used for baluns, wideband transformers, or EMI suppression because of the very low Q encountered. Many of the ferrites I use have a Q of one or less over at least part of the frequency range of operation. And of course the L/C meter wouldn't be useful in assessing the loss or Q of inductors at all. One of the unique things about the HP unit is that it's able to resolve very small R in the presence of large X or vice-versa, which is very difficult to do. But then it costs a couple of orders of magnitude more. A network analyzer is poorly suited for making measurements of impedances which are a great deal higher or lower than 50 ohms. The problem with any of these instruments is that they'll all happily give you an answer, often to several decimal digits. But as Owen pointed out for the 259B, the answer can be anywhere from good to total garbage. The only way to know which is to understand the limitations of your test equipment and something about the nature of the component you're trying to measure. There just isn't any instrument which will do the thinking for you. Roy Lewallen, W7EL That is what I thought also Roy but the little L/C meter seems to work pretty well with low Q inductors. It is not measuring impedance but measuring a frequency of an inductor and known capacitor in an oscillator. The Q does change the oscillating frequency but not that much. As I said before it is super easy to tell the difference between 77/31/43/61 type ferrites. Of course the permeability difference between those types is a factor of 2 or more so ultra accuracy is not important. The original question was how to determine what type an unknown core was and not what impedance it represented at a certain frequency. I just grabbed 3 FairRite 59XX003801 torroids (2.4" OD x 1.4" ID x .5") in 3 materials and measured a single turn with the L/C meter. Material 61 (u=125) calc. inductance = .173uH, measured = .177uH Material 43 (u=800) calc. inductance = 1.07uH, measured = .930uH Material 75 (u=5000) calc. inductance = 6.85uH, measured = 7.39uH The calculated inductances came from the FairRite catalog. I would say the "low Q" inductors measured pretty well and the materilas were very easy to distinguish. 73, Larry, W0QE |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Trying to find out what Ferrite material this is.
Larry Benko wrote:
That is what I thought also Roy but the little L/C meter seems to work pretty well with low Q inductors. It is not measuring impedance but measuring a frequency of an inductor and known capacitor in an oscillator. The Q does change the oscillating frequency but not that much. As I said before it is super easy to tell the difference between 77/31/43/61 type ferrites. Of course the permeability difference between those types is a factor of 2 or more so ultra accuracy is not important. The original question was how to determine what type an unknown core was and not what impedance it represented at a certain frequency. I just grabbed 3 FairRite 59XX003801 torroids (2.4" OD x 1.4" ID x .5") in 3 materials and measured a single turn with the L/C meter. Material 61 (u=125) calc. inductance = .173uH, measured = .177uH Material 43 (u=800) calc. inductance = 1.07uH, measured = .930uH Material 75 (u=5000) calc. inductance = 6.85uH, measured = 7.39uH The calculated inductances came from the FairRite catalog. I would say the "low Q" inductors measured pretty well and the materilas were very easy to distinguish. Yep, that's perfectly adequate to distinguish the types. You must have made the measurements at a pretty low frequency. Type 75 has a Q of 1 at about a MHz, and 43 at a few MHz, and they drop at higher frequencies. Will the circuit oscillate with Q that low? Roy Lewallen, W7EL |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Trying to find out what Ferrite material this is.
Roy Lewallen wrote:
Yep, that's perfectly adequate to distinguish the types. You must have made the measurements at a pretty low frequency. Type 75 has a Q of 1 at about a MHz, and 43 at a few MHz, and they drop at higher frequencies. Will the circuit oscillate with Q that low? Roy Lewallen, W7EL Referring to http://www.aade.com/lcm2binst/HP.html the measurement freq. was about 750KHz for the type 61 and 43 materials and about 70KHz for the 75 material based on the inductances that were displayed. 73, Larry W0QE |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Trying to find out what Ferrite material this is.
Larry Benko wrote:
Roy Lewallen wrote: Yep, that's perfectly adequate to distinguish the types. You must have made the measurements at a pretty low frequency. Type 75 has a Q of 1 at about a MHz, and 43 at a few MHz, and they drop at higher frequencies. Will the circuit oscillate with Q that low? Roy Lewallen, W7EL Referring to http://www.aade.com/lcm2binst/HP.html the measurement freq. was about 750KHz for the type 61 and 43 materials and about 70KHz for the 75 material based on the inductances that were displayed. 73, Larry W0QE Darn typo. That should be 750KHz for the type 61 and 43 and 700KHz for the type 75. Sorry. 73,Larry W0QE |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
TV type Ferrite Cores / Ferrite Cores / Magnetic Longwire Baluns (MLBs) and more | Shortwave | |||
aNTENNA MATERIAL | Antenna | |||
Anechoic Material | Homebrew | |||
Anechoic Material | Homebrew | |||
How good is ferrite 75 material for crystal AM radio? | Homebrew |