Cecil Moore wrote:
Gene Fuller wrote:
As shown, the FSU demonstration is physically impossible. There is no
way for two plane waves to be trucking along independently and then
suddenly decide to interfere.

They do NOT "truck along and then suddenly decide to
interfere". Such nonsense is just a strawman presented
for the purpose of obfuscating the technical facts.

The two independent waves are generated at a physical
impedance discontinuity, the Z0-match point, and are
immediately canceled at that point. The energy in the
canceled waves is redistributed in the only other
direction possible in a one-dimensional transmission
line.

Exactly the same thing happens when the external
reflection is canceled by the internal reflection
at a non-reflective 1/4WL thin-film coating on
glass. Quoting the Melles Groit web page:

"In the absence of absorption or scatter, the principle
of conservation of energy indicates all 'lost' reflected
intensity will appear as enhanced intensity in the
transmitted beam."

i.e. the energy re-reflected at the Z0-match joins the
forward wave toward the load. The conservation of energy
principle will not allow any other result. Dr. Best's
phantom waves continuing to flow toward the source with
zero energy is just a wet dream.

Nice. So you don't really want to refer to the FSU page at all. Why
bring it up? The topic was about free space interference and had nothing
to do with match points.

Same ol' Cecil; try to sneak in some irrelevancy and then get agitated
when you are called on it.

73,
Gene
W4SZ