Derek wrote in
:

On Dec 7, 10:13 am, Mike Coslo wrote

Doesn't work that way, sir.

If I say that antennas work by shooting little turds off the ends of
the wires, it isn't Roy's job to prove it, it's mine.

- 73 de Mike N3LI -

Hi Mike
What you say is very true, but, Art is not looking for
confirmation he has already stated that he is not going to hand his
findings to
this group on a plate.
What he is trying to do is guide others to find for themselves what
he already knows.

In my attempts to engage art, he's rebuffed my knowledge (more like lack
of it) I'm supposed to come back after I learn more. But learn what?
Theory that he declares is incorrect, or his theories which he won't
serve up? The others will share with me.

I'm just not much of a fan of faith based engineering! ;^)

To convince others of a new and radical departure from what exists and
what apparently works, one nust offer good proofs. The old
"extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof" chestnut applies. And
especially for people such as Roy, who has often been decried by Art. He
is under no obligation to prove Art either right or wrong.

- 73 de Mike N3LI -