Roy Lewallen wrote:
But any analysis which isn't valid when driven
by a perfect voltage source in series with a resistance (or current
source in parallel with a resistance) is fundamentally flawed.

Any model that violates the laws of physics is fundamentally
flawed. Your model has EM energy sloshing around like water.
Your model has EM energy neither flowing into the source
nor being reflected. That is a violation of the conservation
of energy principle.

The SPICE simulation of the circuit I analyzed was, of course, a
transient analysis. The source was a perfect voltage source which
produced a sine wave beginning at t = 0 and continuously after that,
just as in my analysis. For anyone having SPICE, here's the netlist:

What is it that you think you have proved? That there
is no energy in reflected waves? That EM waves don't
move at the speed of light? That the conservation of
energy principle is invalid? What?
--
73, Cecil http://www.w5dxp.com