Jim Kelley wrote:
The truth is, the s-parameter analysis just says that the waves
cancel.

And you say the waves didn't cancel - that they don't
even exist during steady-state. Take your pick about
who is correct. If two waves cancel, as the s-parameter
analysis says they do, it implies that they must first
exist even if for only a dt of time.

HP never considered anyone dense enough to require an
assertion about the very existence of the s-parameter
equation components.

So in other words if you're wrong, then what you're saying violates
conservation of energy.

Exactly, and since the conservation of energy principle
cannot be violated, I must be right. :-)
--
73, Cecil http://www.w5dxp.com