On Jan 14, 7:36 am, "AI4QJ" wrote:
"Derek" wrote in message

...



On Jan 14, 2:02 am, "AI4QJ" wrote:
"Derek" wrote in message

...

On Jan 13, 2:55 pm, "AI4QJ" wrote:
"Derek" wrote in message

...

On Jan 13, 1:15 pm, "AI4QJ" wrote:

You made a positive statement, You called Art a "liar"

I absolutely did not! Show my a quote where I used thre word liar. I
called
him a fibber. Big difference.

semantics

Yes, it's semantics, that's precisely why you are getting confused. "Derek"
(or whomever you are).

Do you have a call sign or something else that shows us who you are? I'm
sure you're not hiding your personhood intentionally, "Derek".


I am a retiree like many on this group living in Perth Australia,
who after many years of following this group has a great belief that
Art can do as he claims.
I am also a great believer in fair play, and calling someone a
fibber (liar) on open message without proof is not fair play in my
book.

Derek

Derek wrote in
:


I am a retiree like many on this group living in Perth Australia,
who after many years of following this group has a great belief that
Art can do as he claims.

On what do you base that belief? Many of us have asked Art for some input
on building one of his antennas, and we don't get anything. Heck, I'd even
enjoy a picture, or a visit to the QTH to see something being used. But we
get nothing. I'm not a fan of faith based engineering.

- 73 d eMike N3LI -

On Jan 14, 12:13 pm, Mike Coslo wrote:
Derek wrote :

I am a retiree like many on this group living in Perth Australia,
who after many years of following this group has a great belief that
Art can do as he claims.

On what do you base that belief? Many of us have asked Art for some input
on building one of his antennas, and we don't get anything. Heck, I'd even
enjoy a picture, or a visit to the QTH to see something being used. But we
get nothing. I'm not a fan of faith based engineering.

- 73 d eMike N3LI -


I have put my money where my mouth is.

Derek

Derek wrote in
:

On what do you base that belief? Many of us have asked Art for some
input on building one of his antennas, and we don't get anything.
Heck, I'd even enjoy a picture, or a visit to the QTH to see
something being used. But we get nothing. I'm not a fan of faith
based engineering.

- 73 de Mike N3LI -


I have put my money where my mouth is.

Derek - placing of wagers is not an argument. I haven't partipated in
calling Art anything. It isn't a difficult thing to get a picture of this
antenna, I would even offer to post it on line.

It's simple really. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof.
show us the antennas, let us build them and test them. Let us compare them
to other antennas.

- 73 de Mike N3LI -

On Jan 14, 12:38 pm, Mike Coslo wrote:
Derek wrote :

On what do you base that belief? Many of us have asked Art for some
input on building one of his antennas, and we don't get anything.
Heck, I'd even enjoy a picture, or a visit to the QTH to see
something being used. But we get nothing. I'm not a fan of faith
based engineering.

- 73 de Mike N3LI -

I have put my money where my mouth is.

Derek - placing of wagers is not an argument. I haven't partipated in
calling Art anything.

- 73 de Mike N3LI -


I did not intend to infer that you had, I just pointed out I was ready
to back my words

Derek