Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#11
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Richard Clark wrote:
One inductance value (however it is wound) is not equivalent everywhere - hence the proposition of a coil having an equivalent length is rather preposterous. Nobody said one inductance value is equivalent everywhere. In fact, just the opposite is true. The equivalent length for different coils with the same inductance depends upon their physical configurations. For instance, w8ji's loading coil (100t, 10tpi, 2"dia) calculates to have a VF of 0.0328 while my 75m Texas Bugcatcher coil with approximately the same inductance calculates to have a VF of 0.0198, a 66% difference proving your above premise to be false. ************************************************** ***** THERE IS NO REQUIREMENT THAT TWO COILS WITH THE SAME INDUCTANCE OCCUPY THE SAME NUMBER OF DEGREES OF ANTENNA. ************************************************** ***** To understand the details, just compare the following 1/4WL resonant stubs: ---25.3 deg Z0=600 ohm---+---10 deg Z0=50 ohm---open ---70.6 deg Z0=100 ohm---+---10 deg Z0=50 ohm---open Both stubs are electrically 1/4WL = 90 degrees long. How can 35.3 physical degrees of stub perform a 90 degree stub function? Hint: There is a 54.7 degree phase shift at the '+' junction. Why does the second example require 80.6 physical degrees of feedline? Hint: There is only a 9.4 degree phase shift at the '+' junction. Why does it take 70.6 degrees of Z0=100 ohm feedline to perform exactly the same function as 25.3 degrees of Z0=600 ohm feedline? Both stub segments, Z0=600 and Z0=100, are providing the same inductance at the '+' junction point, yet one is 2.8 times longer than the other. Is "the proposition of a piece of transmission line having an equivalent length rather preposterous"? -- 73, Cecil, IEEE, OOTC, http://www.w5dxp.com |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Tee-antenna base loading coil? | Antenna | |||
Vertical Loading Coil | Antenna | |||
Current across the antenna loading coil - from scratch | Antenna | |||
top loading vertical antenna? | Antenna | |||
Question about toroid vs. air core coil. | Homebrew |