Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#6
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
ve2pid wrote:
Hi to all, Hope that my question has some sense...: If we double the power radiated by an antenna (+3 dB), how does it translate on the S-meter at a receiver 'far' away.. i.e. is the difference in dB on that meter has some mathematical relation to the 3 dB change at the transmitter? 73 de Pierre No, none at all. S-meters almost always just measure the AGC voltage, which is only approximately logarithmic. And manufacturers adjust the sensitivity of the meter to please the customers, who don't like "dead" meters. So the sensitivity of S-meters varies greatly from rig type to type and from one end of the scale to the other. I measured the sensitivity of the S-meter on my Icom 730 on one band. Here's how big an S-unit is on my rig: S1 - S2 1.4 dB S2 - S3 1.3 dB S3 - S4 1.6 dB S4 - S5 2.3 dB S5 - S6 1.8 dB S6 - S7 3.2 dB S7 - S8 3.1 dB S8 - S9 4.0 dB S9 - "S9 + 10 dB" 5.6 dB "S9 + 10 dB" - "S9 + 20 dB" 7.3 dB "S9 + 20 dB" - "S9 + 30 dB" 6.6 dB "S9 + 30 dB" - "S9 + 40 dB" 10.5 dB "S9 + 40 dB" - "S9 + 50 dB" 11.3 dB "S9 + 50 dB" - "S9 + 60 dB" 13.5 dB Now let's suppose that you built a new 5 element Yagi antenna and I honestly reported that your signal went from S2 to S6 when you switched to it from your dipole. The gain is really 7 dB, about par for the beam, but you read the postings on the Web and decide that an S-unit is "defined" as 6 dB, so the gain improvement must be 24 dB. Wow! Your modest beam has the same gain as a beam with a 25 WAVELENGTH boom and more than 50 elements! By making that incorrect assumption about the sensitivity of my S-meter, you've overestimated the gain by a factor of 63. S-meter sensitivities vary all over the map, so any assumption you make about how many dB in an S-unit is very likely wrong, and often grossly wrong. Roy Lewallen, W7EL |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Orthogonality relation between modes in Dielectric-Lined Circular Waveguide (or with concentric dielectric layers) | Antenna |