On 11 jun, 16:27, Cecil Moore wrote:
On Jun 11, 12:56*pm, Richard Fry wrote:

Followup: *Those denying the existence of reflected signals within an
antenna system may wish to view the measurement of such signals, at
the link below.

Or at this link. Scroll down to "Using Dielectric Beamsplitters to
find the "missing energy" in destructive interference".

http://www.teachspin.com/instruments...eriments.shtml

I guarantee that every optical physicist who is reading this thread is
laughing at the ignorance of the alleged RF gurus.
--
73, Cecil, w5dxp.com

Hello, here we are...! :)

At the risk of naïve and conciliatory I still thinking that to some
extent this is a problem of "same cat seen from different points of
view".

What if the question is formulated in terms apart, for example =
generator responses to load differences, and by what mechanism a
transmission line transforms impedances to presents to the generator
those different loads?
In that formulation I think there are room to simple, basic, and
understandable electrical laws to account for generator behaviour and
TL travelling waves interference phenomenom to account for Z
transformings.

From my perspective your main differences are reducible

73

Miguel Ghezzi - LU6ETJ