"AK" wrote in message
news:flFxc.1843$2i5.155@attbi_s52...


That's one of those nonsense comments that sounds good, but doesn't work.
Once "the marketplace" gets tested, amateur radio and most of the other
users of HF and MF radio reception will be out of business - never to
bounce
back once destroyed.

NEVER to bounce back? Shortwave radio is that fragile? Must not be much
keeping it going right now.



Meanwhile, BPL will be "workable" for those areas that
never had good cable access and where people were too cheap to use
satellite
or telephone alternatives. BPL isn't "unworkable" - it's the
"unreasonable"
sacrifices that must be made to allow nationwide radio spectrum disruption
for some trivial gain to a few people and a few big businesses.

If there's more people who actually want BPL more than SW radio, then maybe
they should have it. However, I seem to have less faith than you that BPL
actually works. I do have faith that people won't spend money on a system
which is unreliable.



You must be that same guy that thought he had a God given right to dump
whatever he wanted into the Nashua river when I lived along it. His
corporate garbage killed all the fish and stunk-up the river for the rest
of
the world, but using the river for his personal dumping ground was his
"right"!

You assume wrong. I'm not the same guy. I've never dumped anything toxic
in the Nashua river, even when you weren't living along it. In fact, I've
never been anywhere around the Nashua river.


Some good ol' New England Yankee took on this
"my-rights-over-everyone-else" guy by paying a cement truck to dump a full
load of concrete in the guy's drainage canal to the river. The sheriff was
called, saw what was done, heard why it was done, and went home without
issuing any citation. Too bad that a load of concrete won't stop BPL.

ak



Stopping BPL is simple. It's a political numbers game. Unfortunately,
there's more potential customers for high speed internet access than there
are SW hobbyists. I'm sure you've noticed that no Democrat is taking an
anti-BPL stance. BPL has already been approved in a couple of areas.

Or, just maybe, the politicans expect BPL to fail or succeed on it's own
merits. If it fails on it's own, then nobody gets the blame for keeping it
away from the customers.

Frank Dresser