Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Antenna for Marine VHF
On 4/25/2017 4:24 PM, Rob wrote:
rickman wrote: I don't think this design would be a great choice for a kayak antenna, because the individual coax sections in the "stack" are a half-wavelength long (at the coax's velocity factor) and there are usually quarter-wave sections at the top and bottom. The shortest 2-meter collinear (one half-wave section and two quarter-wave) would be 2 meters in length - over six feet - and a marine VHF antenna wouldn't be much shorter. With a collinear of the type shown in the above link, you'd need to mast-mount it up some distance - the bottom quarter-wave tube is RF-hot, and if its bottom end is near water (or anything grounded) it would tend to de-tune the antenna. As others have noted, the OP really doesn't need a high-gain antenna. I think the real problem is this antenna for 2 meter operation is 20 feet long! For marine VHF it can't be used on shore, so hanging it from a tree would not work. When you say using a single half wave section wouldn't be much different from a marine VHF antenna, what type of antenna would a marine VHF antenna be? I thought they used a colinear design. I wonder, why is the "2 meter band" not called the "6 1/2 feet band" in the USA? This alternating between meters and feet is getting a bit funny. Why is the 70 cm band not the 700 mm band or the 0.07 meter band? Not sure what issue you have with feet other than it not being familiar perhaps. As much as I use metric, feet and inches are still ingrained in my soul. When I look at a flag pole I don't think, geeze, that's 10 meters high! I think 30 feet. It's that simple. -- Rick C |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Antenna for Marine VHF
rickman wrote:
On 4/25/2017 4:24 PM, Rob wrote: rickman wrote: I don't think this design would be a great choice for a kayak antenna, because the individual coax sections in the "stack" are a half-wavelength long (at the coax's velocity factor) and there are usually quarter-wave sections at the top and bottom. The shortest 2-meter collinear (one half-wave section and two quarter-wave) would be 2 meters in length - over six feet - and a marine VHF antenna wouldn't be much shorter. With a collinear of the type shown in the above link, you'd need to mast-mount it up some distance - the bottom quarter-wave tube is RF-hot, and if its bottom end is near water (or anything grounded) it would tend to de-tune the antenna. As others have noted, the OP really doesn't need a high-gain antenna. I think the real problem is this antenna for 2 meter operation is 20 feet long! For marine VHF it can't be used on shore, so hanging it from a tree would not work. When you say using a single half wave section wouldn't be much different from a marine VHF antenna, what type of antenna would a marine VHF antenna be? I thought they used a colinear design. I wonder, why is the "2 meter band" not called the "6 1/2 feet band" in the USA? This alternating between meters and feet is getting a bit funny. Why is the 70 cm band not the 700 mm band or the 0.07 meter band? Not sure what issue you have with feet other than it not being familiar perhaps. As much as I use metric, feet and inches are still ingrained in my soul. When I look at a flag pole I don't think, geeze, that's 10 meters high! I think 30 feet. It's that simple. Maybe yes, but it should be obvious that when you are discussing antennas for the "2 meter band" their dimensions will be nice multiples of those same 2 meters. When I think about a "halfwave dipole for 2 meters" I think "1 meter", not "3 1/4 feet" or "39 inches". So when you want to discuss antenna sizes I think it would be more convenient to use the same units all around. For me, that of course is meters. Scaling like "milli" or "centi" is natural in the metric system, I don't have to think about that. (contrary to converting feet to inches or meters to feet) |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Antenna for Marine VHF
On 4/26/2017 3:55 AM, Rob wrote:
rickman wrote: On 4/25/2017 4:24 PM, Rob wrote: rickman wrote: I don't think this design would be a great choice for a kayak antenna, because the individual coax sections in the "stack" are a half-wavelength long (at the coax's velocity factor) and there are usually quarter-wave sections at the top and bottom. The shortest 2-meter collinear (one half-wave section and two quarter-wave) would be 2 meters in length - over six feet - and a marine VHF antenna wouldn't be much shorter. With a collinear of the type shown in the above link, you'd need to mast-mount it up some distance - the bottom quarter-wave tube is RF-hot, and if its bottom end is near water (or anything grounded) it would tend to de-tune the antenna. As others have noted, the OP really doesn't need a high-gain antenna. I think the real problem is this antenna for 2 meter operation is 20 feet long! For marine VHF it can't be used on shore, so hanging it from a tree would not work. When you say using a single half wave section wouldn't be much different from a marine VHF antenna, what type of antenna would a marine VHF antenna be? I thought they used a colinear design. I wonder, why is the "2 meter band" not called the "6 1/2 feet band" in the USA? This alternating between meters and feet is getting a bit funny. Why is the 70 cm band not the 700 mm band or the 0.07 meter band? Not sure what issue you have with feet other than it not being familiar perhaps. As much as I use metric, feet and inches are still ingrained in my soul. When I look at a flag pole I don't think, geeze, that's 10 meters high! I think 30 feet. It's that simple. Maybe yes, but it should be obvious that when you are discussing antennas for the "2 meter band" their dimensions will be nice multiples of those same 2 meters. When I think about a "halfwave dipole for 2 meters" I think "1 meter", not "3 1/4 feet" or "39 inches". So when you want to discuss antenna sizes I think it would be more convenient to use the same units all around. For me, that of course is meters. Scaling like "milli" or "centi" is natural in the metric system, I don't have to think about that. (contrary to converting feet to inches or meters to feet) So what should I have said rather than 20 feet? -- Rick C |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Marine antenna ?? | Antenna | |||
Marine 2m Antenna wanted | Antenna | |||
help with a marine antenna | Antenna | |||
FA: CB ANTENNA M'CYLE-MARINE-BOAT>ANTENNA SPECIALIST MR306 | CB | |||
Is it a CB or VHF marine antenna? | Antenna |