RadioBanter

RadioBanter (https://www.radiobanter.com/)
-   Dx (https://www.radiobanter.com/dx/)
-   -   ARRL Walks Away From Bandwidth Restrictions (https://www.radiobanter.com/dx/9843-arrl-walks-away-bandwidth-restrictions.html)

Louis C. LeVine September 5th 04 08:30 AM

ARRL Walks Away From Bandwidth Restrictions
 
The Newsline says that ARRL will give up its bandwidth restriction
idea. This is in the current news.

RESTRUCTURING: REACTING TO THE ARRL BANDWIDTH PROPOSAL


An ARRL proposal to restructure Amateur Radio along bandwidth lines
has caused a lot of discussion in the nations ham community. And it
may cause the League to rethink its position. Amateur Radio
Newsline's Mark Abramowicz, NT3V, is in Philadelphia, and has the
rest of the story:


--


Shortly after the ARRL began circulating the proposal and posted it
on its website, the e-mails, phone calls, HF, VHF, and digital-mode
traffic took off.


And now, Amateur Radio Newsline has learned the bandwidth proposal
may be tabled for more study when the ARRL's executive committee
meets next month.


That confirmation comes from W6OBB in Nevada. If the call sign isn't
familiar, the name behind it might be. He's Art Bell, host of the
weekend edition of "Coast to Coast AM" heard on more than 500
commercial radio stations across the nation.


Bell, who joined the fight against Broadband Over Powerlines several
months ago, and featured the subject on his radio program, expressed
concern about what he called a Draconian proposal that would over-
regulate the ham bands. Bell tells me he relayed that concern in a
phone call to ARRL President Jim Haynie W5JBP.


Bell characterizes the discussion as cordial and at the end, he says
Haynie related he was re-evaluating the proposal based on many
comments he had received.


"He indicated to me and told me I could pass on to you that they're
looking into pulling this whole thing back and taking a harder look
at it," Bell says.


While Bell says he believes the ARRL had good intentions with the
proposal, it may have gone too far.


"What began as an examination by the League of how we could possibly
encourage the digital mode, it went a little too far and began to
over-regulate," Bell says. "I'd kind of like to see it go the other
way and I'd like to see our bands freed up."


Haynie says he's gotten a lot of feedback on the proposal. He says it
came from the League's desire to promote - not restrict - innovation
and experimentation. He says it was also a response the Federal
Communications Commission's desire to see more innovation from the
ham community.


"I think we rose to the challenge," Haynie says. "We have
demonstrated Software Defined Radio that just knocked their socks
off, in my view.


"We have come up with some other stuff - Joe Taylor and some of his
things for moon bounce. And I think the Amateur Radio community
needed a wake-up call is what they needed and I think that's what
we've gotten and were given."


Haynie says it's clear the digital modes like RTTY and PSK 31 need
attention.


"Where do we want to go to the future?" Haynie asks. "And, as I
mentioned a couple of years ago, I took my model 28ASR and took it
to the scrap man. But that's the standard that's used today is 850Hz
shift at 45 baud.


"Well, we don't do too much of that. I'm not saying there's not RTTY
enthusiasts out there, there are and I appreciate that and I know
that and I want to protect their rights to do those things."


Art Bell says he and others don't object to digital innovation. But
he doesn't think the proposal hits the mark.


"There are many with differing interests who are not too pleased with
the proposal and, on the face of it, it simply does not make sense,"
Bell says. "I agree that we should encourage the digital modes and
development, but we shouldn't try to push something into place that
is not techincally ready to happen yet."


Restricting bandwidth, Bell says, won't promote innovation.


"Why do we have to cut and slice and dice and regulate," Bell says.
Why not just let anybody virtually go anywhere and let all of us just
live together with some gentlemen's agreements which we have now and
which work very, very well on most bands?


"So with that in mind, look at the Canadians. The Canadians have a
6khz limit and they can go anywhere on the band they want from the
bottom to the top. And I don't see why that would not apply and work
well in America."


Haynie says he wants to hear more from hams and he's encouraging all
of us to get into the FCC's Part 97 rules and share input on the
proposal at the ARRL's website, that's ARRL-dot-org.


"Look at the rule book and see what's there now, "Haynie says. "And,
is there something that could be changed that would allow a new
technology to be developed, then that's what we want to know."


For the Amateur Radio Newsline, I'm Mark Abramowicz, NT3V, in
Philadelphia.


--


More on the ARRL proposal and reaction to it in upcoming Amateur
Radio Newsline reports. (ARNewsline(tm))

John Kasupski September 7th 04 12:29 AM

On Mon, 6 Sep 2004 10:43:43 -0400, "KWM442X" wrote:

ARRL, of by and for the former CB and now ham
appliance operator.

ARRL, a dying organization, whose officials will grab all
the money they can before ARRL finally goes belly up.

ARRL loves suckers who keep mailing in membership
dues to a do nothing orgainization to line the pockets of
ARRL officials.

ARRL, an organization that screws ham operators at
every turn, if it means putting another dime in the pocket
of ARRL officials.


Send your dues in suckers!


Since most of us in this newsgroup are fully aware that almost all of
the ARRL officials are volunteers and work for free, you have
succeeded only in exposing yourself as the ignorant troll that you
obviously are.

Nice try...and now it is my pleasure to cordially invite you to try
the rec.radio.cb newsgroup, where you will fit in much better and
might even become a respected regular, given enough time.

John Kasupski, Tonawanda, New York
Amateur Radio (KC2HMZ), SWL/Scanner Monitoring (KNY2VS)
ARRL WNY PIO
http://www.qsl.net/kc2fng
E-Mails Ignored, Please Post Replies In This Newsgroup


John Kasupski September 7th 04 12:29 AM

On Mon, 6 Sep 2004 10:43:43 -0400, "KWM442X" wrote:

ARRL, of by and for the former CB and now ham
appliance operator.

ARRL, a dying organization, whose officials will grab all
the money they can before ARRL finally goes belly up.

ARRL loves suckers who keep mailing in membership
dues to a do nothing orgainization to line the pockets of
ARRL officials.

ARRL, an organization that screws ham operators at
every turn, if it means putting another dime in the pocket
of ARRL officials.


Send your dues in suckers!


Since most of us in this newsgroup are fully aware that almost all of
the ARRL officials are volunteers and work for free, you have
succeeded only in exposing yourself as the ignorant troll that you
obviously are.

Nice try...and now it is my pleasure to cordially invite you to try
the rec.radio.cb newsgroup, where you will fit in much better and
might even become a respected regular, given enough time.

John Kasupski, Tonawanda, New York
Amateur Radio (KC2HMZ), SWL/Scanner Monitoring (KNY2VS)
ARRL WNY PIO
http://www.qsl.net/kc2fng
E-Mails Ignored, Please Post Replies In This Newsgroup


John Kasupski September 7th 04 06:52 PM

On Tue, 07 Sep 2004 05:29:24 -0700, Bill Turner
wrote:

On Mon, 6 Sep 2004 10:43:43 -0400, "KWM442X" wrote:

ARRL, of by and for the former CB and now ham
appliance operator.

ARRL, a dying organization, whose officials will grab all
the money they can before ARRL finally goes belly up.

ARRL loves suckers who keep mailing in membership
dues to a do nothing orgainization to line the pockets of
ARRL officials.

ARRL, an organization that screws ham operators at
every turn, if it means putting another dime in the pocket
of ARRL officials.


Send your dues in suckers!


_________________________________________________ ________

The quality of trolling on this newsgroup is getting worse every day.
What can be done to improve it? Troll schools? Troll certification?
Troll Elmers? What????


I agree. It's way too easy to become a troll these days. Back in the
old days, you had to learn DOS commands first. None of this
point-and-click crap that's so easy even a child could do it, you had
to learn how to type, you had to learn about filenames and extensions,
you had to learn how to use a keyboard. Today's trolls are spoiled
because all they have to do is click their little mouse. Windows is
going to be the end of trolling as we know it, mark my words. They
ought to bring back DOS. That's what separated the real McCoys from
the wanna-be's back in the good old days - DOS.

Besides, what happens in an emergency? Your computer crashes and
Windows won't boot, you need to know DOS in order to get in there and
fix it. These trolls of today don't know squat about DOS, and when
they end up trashing their Windows they have to haul their computer
off to a club meeting to get a REAL troll to fix it. DOS works when
nothing else will work, that's why they should never have gotten rid
of it. Windows just made the Apple and Commodore riffraff from years
ago think they are real computer users. Bring back DOS and let 'em all
go back to their Commode Door 64 where they belong.

73 de John, KC2HMZ, Tonawanda, NY

Disclaimer: Any apparent similarity to the code/no-code argument is
pure coincidence and is completely unintentional.


John Kasupski September 7th 04 06:52 PM

On Tue, 07 Sep 2004 05:29:24 -0700, Bill Turner
wrote:

On Mon, 6 Sep 2004 10:43:43 -0400, "KWM442X" wrote:

ARRL, of by and for the former CB and now ham
appliance operator.

ARRL, a dying organization, whose officials will grab all
the money they can before ARRL finally goes belly up.

ARRL loves suckers who keep mailing in membership
dues to a do nothing orgainization to line the pockets of
ARRL officials.

ARRL, an organization that screws ham operators at
every turn, if it means putting another dime in the pocket
of ARRL officials.


Send your dues in suckers!


_________________________________________________ ________

The quality of trolling on this newsgroup is getting worse every day.
What can be done to improve it? Troll schools? Troll certification?
Troll Elmers? What????


I agree. It's way too easy to become a troll these days. Back in the
old days, you had to learn DOS commands first. None of this
point-and-click crap that's so easy even a child could do it, you had
to learn how to type, you had to learn about filenames and extensions,
you had to learn how to use a keyboard. Today's trolls are spoiled
because all they have to do is click their little mouse. Windows is
going to be the end of trolling as we know it, mark my words. They
ought to bring back DOS. That's what separated the real McCoys from
the wanna-be's back in the good old days - DOS.

Besides, what happens in an emergency? Your computer crashes and
Windows won't boot, you need to know DOS in order to get in there and
fix it. These trolls of today don't know squat about DOS, and when
they end up trashing their Windows they have to haul their computer
off to a club meeting to get a REAL troll to fix it. DOS works when
nothing else will work, that's why they should never have gotten rid
of it. Windows just made the Apple and Commodore riffraff from years
ago think they are real computer users. Bring back DOS and let 'em all
go back to their Commode Door 64 where they belong.

73 de John, KC2HMZ, Tonawanda, NY

Disclaimer: Any apparent similarity to the code/no-code argument is
pure coincidence and is completely unintentional.


John Kasupski September 7th 04 06:53 PM

On Mon, 6 Sep 2004 20:51:37 -0400, "KWM442X" wrote:

Send in your dues Sucker!


Already taken care of. I'm sure we can safely assume that your annual
dues to the United States CB Association have been paid in full?

John Kasupski, Tonawanda, New York
Amateur Radio (KC2HMZ), SWL/Scanner Monitoring (KNY2VS)
Member of ARES/RACES, ARATS, WUN, ARRL WNY PIO
http://www.qsl.net/kc2fng
E-Mails Ignored, Please Post Replies In This Newsgroup


John Kasupski September 7th 04 06:53 PM

On Mon, 6 Sep 2004 20:51:37 -0400, "KWM442X" wrote:

Send in your dues Sucker!


Already taken care of. I'm sure we can safely assume that your annual
dues to the United States CB Association have been paid in full?

John Kasupski, Tonawanda, New York
Amateur Radio (KC2HMZ), SWL/Scanner Monitoring (KNY2VS)
Member of ARES/RACES, ARATS, WUN, ARRL WNY PIO
http://www.qsl.net/kc2fng
E-Mails Ignored, Please Post Replies In This Newsgroup


Mike Coslo September 7th 04 09:33 PM

KWM442X wrote:

Send in your dues Sucker!


Smart as you are, you should be able to come up with something better.


Mike Coslo September 7th 04 09:33 PM

KWM442X wrote:

Send in your dues Sucker!


Smart as you are, you should be able to come up with something better.


Mike Coslo September 7th 04 10:17 PM

Understood!

KWM442X wrote:
Send in your dues Sucker!



"Mike Coslo" wrote in message
...

KWM442X wrote:


Send in your dues Sucker!


Smart as you are, you should be able to come up with something better.






Mike Coslo September 7th 04 10:17 PM

Understood!

KWM442X wrote:
Send in your dues Sucker!



"Mike Coslo" wrote in message
...

KWM442X wrote:


Send in your dues Sucker!


Smart as you are, you should be able to come up with something better.






[email protected] September 8th 04 12:12 AM

On Tue, 7 Sep 2004 16:07:27 -0400, "KWM442X" wrote:


Buy a new brain, sucker -- obviously the one you have is
capable of remembering only one snotty retort.


Send in your dues Sucker!



"John Kasupski" wrote in message
.. .
On Mon, 6 Sep 2004 20:51:37 -0400, "KWM442X" wrote:

Send in your dues Sucker!


Already taken care of. I'm sure we can safely assume that your annual
dues to the United States CB Association have been paid in full?

John Kasupski, Tonawanda, New York
Amateur Radio (KC2HMZ), SWL/Scanner Monitoring (KNY2VS)
Member of ARES/RACES, ARATS, WUN, ARRL WNY PIO
http://www.qsl.net/kc2fng
E-Mails Ignored, Please Post Replies In This Newsgroup




[email protected] September 8th 04 12:12 AM

On Tue, 7 Sep 2004 16:07:27 -0400, "KWM442X" wrote:


Buy a new brain, sucker -- obviously the one you have is
capable of remembering only one snotty retort.


Send in your dues Sucker!



"John Kasupski" wrote in message
.. .
On Mon, 6 Sep 2004 20:51:37 -0400, "KWM442X" wrote:

Send in your dues Sucker!


Already taken care of. I'm sure we can safely assume that your annual
dues to the United States CB Association have been paid in full?

John Kasupski, Tonawanda, New York
Amateur Radio (KC2HMZ), SWL/Scanner Monitoring (KNY2VS)
Member of ARES/RACES, ARATS, WUN, ARRL WNY PIO
http://www.qsl.net/kc2fng
E-Mails Ignored, Please Post Replies In This Newsgroup




John Kasupski September 8th 04 10:33 AM

On Tue, 07 Sep 2004 23:12:42 GMT, wrote:

On Tue, 7 Sep 2004 16:07:27 -0400, "KWM442X" wrote:


Buy a new brain, sucker -- obviously the one you have is
capable of remembering only one snotty retort.


I doubt if he remembers it, he probably has to cut and paste it.



John Kasupski September 8th 04 10:33 AM

On Tue, 07 Sep 2004 23:12:42 GMT, wrote:

On Tue, 7 Sep 2004 16:07:27 -0400, "KWM442X" wrote:


Buy a new brain, sucker -- obviously the one you have is
capable of remembering only one snotty retort.


I doubt if he remembers it, he probably has to cut and paste it.



Vernacular? That's a derby! September 8th 04 12:14 PM


"Bill Turner" wrote in message
...

The quality of trolling on this newsgroup is getting worse every day.
What can be done to improve it? Troll schools? Troll certification?
Troll Elmers? What????


I say we re-activate the 14.313 kook wars of year's past.
Perhaps even parts of 75 Meters as well. Ratchet up the QRM
and goofyness on the HF bands, that will no doubt draw-off
much of the mayhem from off of the NG's. Just be sure to
not use your callsign and RH will not bother you.


Vernacular? That's a derby! September 8th 04 12:14 PM


"Bill Turner" wrote in message
...

The quality of trolling on this newsgroup is getting worse every day.
What can be done to improve it? Troll schools? Troll certification?
Troll Elmers? What????


I say we re-activate the 14.313 kook wars of year's past.
Perhaps even parts of 75 Meters as well. Ratchet up the QRM
and goofyness on the HF bands, that will no doubt draw-off
much of the mayhem from off of the NG's. Just be sure to
not use your callsign and RH will not bother you.


AB2RC September 8th 04 02:46 PM

On 2004-09-07, John Kasupski wrote:

I agree. It's way too easy to become a troll these days. Back in the
old days, you had to learn DOS commands first. None of this


DOS -- Ha, back in the good old days you had to know UNIX, and needed to
modify the sourcecode for your neswreader before it would even compile on
your system.

Besides, what happens in an emergency? Your computer crashes and
Windows won't boot, you need to know DOS in order to get in there and



crash, won't boot -- what's that all about? I run Linux, havnt had a os
crash since May 1999, when I switched.


Disclaimer: Any apparent similarity to the code/no-code argument is
pure coincidence and is completely unintentional.


hi hi....




--
Alex / AB2RC

AB2RC September 8th 04 02:46 PM

On 2004-09-07, John Kasupski wrote:

I agree. It's way too easy to become a troll these days. Back in the
old days, you had to learn DOS commands first. None of this


DOS -- Ha, back in the good old days you had to know UNIX, and needed to
modify the sourcecode for your neswreader before it would even compile on
your system.

Besides, what happens in an emergency? Your computer crashes and
Windows won't boot, you need to know DOS in order to get in there and



crash, won't boot -- what's that all about? I run Linux, havnt had a os
crash since May 1999, when I switched.


Disclaimer: Any apparent similarity to the code/no-code argument is
pure coincidence and is completely unintentional.


hi hi....




--
Alex / AB2RC

m$ September 8th 04 03:38 PM

Email: g3nyy @despammed.com
"I don't use Linux. I prefer to use an OS supported by a large multi-
national vendor, with a good office suite, excellent network/internet
software and decent hardware support."

....because I like to support monopolists and pay a lot of money - and I
am proud of it

m$ September 8th 04 03:38 PM

Email: g3nyy @despammed.com
"I don't use Linux. I prefer to use an OS supported by a large multi-
national vendor, with a good office suite, excellent network/internet
software and decent hardware support."

....because I like to support monopolists and pay a lot of money - and I
am proud of it

Peter Lemken September 8th 04 04:42 PM

Walt Davidson wrote:

"I don't use Linux. I prefer to use an OS supported by a large multi-
national vendor, with a good office suite, excellent network/internet
software and decent hardware support."


So you run a business? Otherwise this kind of reasoning is rather pitiful
for someone using the computer as a hobby.

Hams used to be on the forefront of technology, these days they are mere
consumers.

Linux ist the best way to *understand* computers, use them as a tool for ham
radio operation, get your hands dirty with source code, look under the hood,
argue with developpers and do things that no commercial software company is
willing to give to them.

And yet all hams do is cry "Windows, Windows, Windows" and they are proud if
their system doesn't crash for one year, instead of making it crash so hard
that people can make it better. Windows is a security nighmare, it's a usability
nightmare and it's money thrown at a company that doesn't care about its
customers. Instead, they try to do whatever is possible to keep a monopoly,
force inferior standards upon the unwashed masses and keep you locked into a
proprietary system that you have no control over it. And you are glad to pay
for it.

Great attitude, Walt.

Go back a couple of years, say like 30 years, and think about that: Some
Kenwood guy comes to your doorstep and hands you a brandnew TS 820 and tells
you: Here is that rig, it's free and you can do with it what you want. Here
is all the technical details, all the manuals, the complete documentation,
together with a free support line to the guys who built it.

We value your input, because we realize that it's not perfect, but we want
to make it as perfect as possible and to do that we need your input. Please
use it, abuse it, use all modes, fiddle with the dials, send us your ideas
for improvement and we will definitely consider them and we do that we will
tell you what it is that we did with your suggestions. And when the new
TS930 is ready, we will send it to your doorstep, free of charge and will
thank you for your valuable assistance in making a better product.

*That* is what Linux is about.

It's not about the "better" system, it's about a system that let's you
participate in a technical revolution that has changed the world.

Peter Lemken
Berlin

PS: If you want to see what Open Source can do to your favorite hobby, take
a look at Elecraft's K2. They do what I described above and the result is an
outstanding piece of equipment, because they value input from their
customers. Their documentation is as good as it gets.

PS2: The line about "excellent network/internet software" is about the best
joke I've ever heard.

--
Life is not a journey to the grave with the intention of arriving safely in
a pretty and well-preserved body, but rather to skid in broadside, thoroughly
used up, totally worn out and loudly proclaiming, 'Wow, what a ride!'

Peter Lemken September 8th 04 04:42 PM

Walt Davidson wrote:

"I don't use Linux. I prefer to use an OS supported by a large multi-
national vendor, with a good office suite, excellent network/internet
software and decent hardware support."


So you run a business? Otherwise this kind of reasoning is rather pitiful
for someone using the computer as a hobby.

Hams used to be on the forefront of technology, these days they are mere
consumers.

Linux ist the best way to *understand* computers, use them as a tool for ham
radio operation, get your hands dirty with source code, look under the hood,
argue with developpers and do things that no commercial software company is
willing to give to them.

And yet all hams do is cry "Windows, Windows, Windows" and they are proud if
their system doesn't crash for one year, instead of making it crash so hard
that people can make it better. Windows is a security nighmare, it's a usability
nightmare and it's money thrown at a company that doesn't care about its
customers. Instead, they try to do whatever is possible to keep a monopoly,
force inferior standards upon the unwashed masses and keep you locked into a
proprietary system that you have no control over it. And you are glad to pay
for it.

Great attitude, Walt.

Go back a couple of years, say like 30 years, and think about that: Some
Kenwood guy comes to your doorstep and hands you a brandnew TS 820 and tells
you: Here is that rig, it's free and you can do with it what you want. Here
is all the technical details, all the manuals, the complete documentation,
together with a free support line to the guys who built it.

We value your input, because we realize that it's not perfect, but we want
to make it as perfect as possible and to do that we need your input. Please
use it, abuse it, use all modes, fiddle with the dials, send us your ideas
for improvement and we will definitely consider them and we do that we will
tell you what it is that we did with your suggestions. And when the new
TS930 is ready, we will send it to your doorstep, free of charge and will
thank you for your valuable assistance in making a better product.

*That* is what Linux is about.

It's not about the "better" system, it's about a system that let's you
participate in a technical revolution that has changed the world.

Peter Lemken
Berlin

PS: If you want to see what Open Source can do to your favorite hobby, take
a look at Elecraft's K2. They do what I described above and the result is an
outstanding piece of equipment, because they value input from their
customers. Their documentation is as good as it gets.

PS2: The line about "excellent network/internet software" is about the best
joke I've ever heard.

--
Life is not a journey to the grave with the intention of arriving safely in
a pretty and well-preserved body, but rather to skid in broadside, thoroughly
used up, totally worn out and loudly proclaiming, 'Wow, what a ride!'

Peter Lemken September 8th 04 05:31 PM

Walt Davidson wrote:
On 8 Sep 2004 15:42:06 GMT, (Peter Lemken)
wrote:

Hams used to be on the forefront of technology, these days they are mere
consumers.


I am a radio ham. Not a computer software engineer.


I am a radio ham. Not a computer software engineer.

Do you use your computer for ham radio?

PS: If you want to see what Open Source can do to your favorite hobby, take
a look at Elecraft's K2. They do what I described above and the result is an
outstanding piece of equipment, because they value input from their
customers. Their documentation is as good as it gets.


What does this have to do with Linux vs Windows?


It seems you have never heard of the term Open Source Software and what
makes it so fundamentally different from proprietary sofware. Sad.

Take a look how Elecraft develops its products, how they treat their
customers, value their input and improve their product by taking community
feedback into account.

Compare to Icom.

PS2:


Play Station 2?


Runs with Linux, yes.

The line about "excellent network/internet software" is about the best
joke I've ever heard.


No joke.


Oh. Just cluelessness then.

Peter Lemken
DF5JT
Berlin

--
Life is not a journey to the grave with the intention of arriving safely in
a pretty and well-preserved body, but rather to skid in broadside, thoroughly
used up, totally worn out and loudly proclaiming, 'Wow, what a ride!'

Peter Lemken September 8th 04 05:31 PM

Walt Davidson wrote:
On 8 Sep 2004 15:42:06 GMT, (Peter Lemken)
wrote:

Hams used to be on the forefront of technology, these days they are mere
consumers.


I am a radio ham. Not a computer software engineer.


I am a radio ham. Not a computer software engineer.

Do you use your computer for ham radio?

PS: If you want to see what Open Source can do to your favorite hobby, take
a look at Elecraft's K2. They do what I described above and the result is an
outstanding piece of equipment, because they value input from their
customers. Their documentation is as good as it gets.


What does this have to do with Linux vs Windows?


It seems you have never heard of the term Open Source Software and what
makes it so fundamentally different from proprietary sofware. Sad.

Take a look how Elecraft develops its products, how they treat their
customers, value their input and improve their product by taking community
feedback into account.

Compare to Icom.

PS2:


Play Station 2?


Runs with Linux, yes.

The line about "excellent network/internet software" is about the best
joke I've ever heard.


No joke.


Oh. Just cluelessness then.

Peter Lemken
DF5JT
Berlin

--
Life is not a journey to the grave with the intention of arriving safely in
a pretty and well-preserved body, but rather to skid in broadside, thoroughly
used up, totally worn out and loudly proclaiming, 'Wow, what a ride!'

AB2RC September 8th 04 06:20 PM

On 2004-09-08, Peter Lemken wrote:

Go back a couple of years, say like 30 years, and think about that: Some
Kenwood guy comes to your doorstep and hands you a brandnew TS 820 and tells
you: Here is that rig, it's free and you can do with it what you want. Here
is all the technical details, all the manuals, the complete documentation,
together with a free support line to the guys who built it.

We value your input, because we realize that it's not perfect, but we want
to make it as perfect as possible and to do that we need your input. Please
use it, abuse it, use all modes, fiddle with the dials, send us your ideas
for improvement and we will definitely consider them and we do that we will
tell you what it is that we did with your suggestions. And when the new
TS930 is ready, we will send it to your doorstep, free of charge and will
thank you for your valuable assistance in making a better product.

*That* is what Linux is about.



This is the best comparison (ham radio/linux) that I have ever read, but you
forgot to add a few things, they include all of the tools and spare parts
that you need to make as many of the new radios that you want.




It's not about the "better" system, it's about a system that let's you
participate in a technical revolution that has changed the world.



I prefer:

"It's not about the 'better' system, but about making the system better"


--
Alex / AB2RC

AB2RC September 8th 04 06:20 PM

On 2004-09-08, Peter Lemken wrote:

Go back a couple of years, say like 30 years, and think about that: Some
Kenwood guy comes to your doorstep and hands you a brandnew TS 820 and tells
you: Here is that rig, it's free and you can do with it what you want. Here
is all the technical details, all the manuals, the complete documentation,
together with a free support line to the guys who built it.

We value your input, because we realize that it's not perfect, but we want
to make it as perfect as possible and to do that we need your input. Please
use it, abuse it, use all modes, fiddle with the dials, send us your ideas
for improvement and we will definitely consider them and we do that we will
tell you what it is that we did with your suggestions. And when the new
TS930 is ready, we will send it to your doorstep, free of charge and will
thank you for your valuable assistance in making a better product.

*That* is what Linux is about.



This is the best comparison (ham radio/linux) that I have ever read, but you
forgot to add a few things, they include all of the tools and spare parts
that you need to make as many of the new radios that you want.




It's not about the "better" system, it's about a system that let's you
participate in a technical revolution that has changed the world.



I prefer:

"It's not about the 'better' system, but about making the system better"


--
Alex / AB2RC

AB2RC September 8th 04 06:23 PM

On 2004-09-08, Walt Davidson wrote:

I am a radio ham. Not a computer software engineer.


I happen to be both, and so are several of the linux kernel developers.


--
Alex / AB2RC

AB2RC September 8th 04 06:23 PM

On 2004-09-08, Walt Davidson wrote:

I am a radio ham. Not a computer software engineer.


I happen to be both, and so are several of the linux kernel developers.


--
Alex / AB2RC

Peter Lemken September 8th 04 10:40 PM

Walt Davidson wrote:
On 8 Sep 2004 16:31:44 GMT, (Peter Lemken)
wrote:

Oh. Just cluelessness then.


The arrogance of the Germans. Anyone who disagrees with them must be
"clueless".


Has it ever occurred to you that you might actually *be* clueless?

Praising "Microsoft's excellent internet/networking software" is a good
indicator that you are; Internet Explorer, Outlook Express and the MS
"Firewall" being cases in point.

We can take this to alt.flame or alt.bash.the.germans if you like; it's up
to you, but do me a favor, don't try to sell me a Lincoln President as the
perfect QSK rig.

It'd be beneath you.

Peter Lemken
DF5JT
Berlin

--
Life is not a journey to the grave with the intention of arriving safely in
a pretty and well-preserved body, but rather to skid in broadside, thoroughly
used up, totally worn out and loudly proclaiming, 'Wow, what a ride!'

Peter Lemken September 8th 04 10:40 PM

Walt Davidson wrote:
On 8 Sep 2004 16:31:44 GMT, (Peter Lemken)
wrote:

Oh. Just cluelessness then.


The arrogance of the Germans. Anyone who disagrees with them must be
"clueless".


Has it ever occurred to you that you might actually *be* clueless?

Praising "Microsoft's excellent internet/networking software" is a good
indicator that you are; Internet Explorer, Outlook Express and the MS
"Firewall" being cases in point.

We can take this to alt.flame or alt.bash.the.germans if you like; it's up
to you, but do me a favor, don't try to sell me a Lincoln President as the
perfect QSK rig.

It'd be beneath you.

Peter Lemken
DF5JT
Berlin

--
Life is not a journey to the grave with the intention of arriving safely in
a pretty and well-preserved body, but rather to skid in broadside, thoroughly
used up, totally worn out and loudly proclaiming, 'Wow, what a ride!'

AA September 9th 04 01:34 AM

Email: g3nyy @despammed.com
"I don't use Linux. I prefer to use an OS supported by a large multi-
national vendor, with a good office suite, excellent network/internet
software and decent hardware support."


Ah! So you use a Mac!

Heh....
A
"...if one tolerates bad manners, they grow worse. I must find the oaf who did
this thing, explain to him his offense, give him a chance to apologise, then
kill him." (R.A. Heinlein, "The Cat Who Walks Through Walls")

AA September 9th 04 01:34 AM

Email: g3nyy @despammed.com
"I don't use Linux. I prefer to use an OS supported by a large multi-
national vendor, with a good office suite, excellent network/internet
software and decent hardware support."


Ah! So you use a Mac!

Heh....
A
"...if one tolerates bad manners, they grow worse. I must find the oaf who did
this thing, explain to him his offense, give him a chance to apologise, then
kill him." (R.A. Heinlein, "The Cat Who Walks Through Walls")

[email protected] September 9th 04 05:36 AM

On 8 Sep 2004 21:40:27 GMT, (Peter Lemken)
wrote:

We can take this to alt.flame or alt.bash.the.germans if you like; it's up
to you, but do me a favor, don't try to sell me a Lincoln President as the
perfect QSK rig.


Or you could take it to alt.who.gives.a.**** too, that might work.

WTF does Linux vs. Windows have to do with Dee-X or the ARRL?

73, Jim KH2D


[email protected] September 9th 04 05:36 AM

On 8 Sep 2004 21:40:27 GMT, (Peter Lemken)
wrote:

We can take this to alt.flame or alt.bash.the.germans if you like; it's up
to you, but do me a favor, don't try to sell me a Lincoln President as the
perfect QSK rig.


Or you could take it to alt.who.gives.a.**** too, that might work.

WTF does Linux vs. Windows have to do with Dee-X or the ARRL?

73, Jim KH2D


Peter Lemken September 9th 04 09:30 AM

Walt Davidson wrote:

CB forever!


Absolutely right, Bill. I have been down exactly the same road.

Of course the ham advocates will simply tell us that we are "too
stupid" or "too technically inept" to get their so-called HF-Dxing
stuff working properly.

It's a form of snobbery.


Sounds right.

Peter Lemken
DF5JT
Berlin

--
Life is not a journey to the grave with the intention of arriving safely in
a pretty and well-preserved body, but rather to skid in broadside, thoroughly
used up, totally worn out and loudly proclaiming, 'Wow, what a ride!'

Peter Lemken September 9th 04 09:30 AM

Walt Davidson wrote:

CB forever!


Absolutely right, Bill. I have been down exactly the same road.

Of course the ham advocates will simply tell us that we are "too
stupid" or "too technically inept" to get their so-called HF-Dxing
stuff working properly.

It's a form of snobbery.


Sounds right.

Peter Lemken
DF5JT
Berlin

--
Life is not a journey to the grave with the intention of arriving safely in
a pretty and well-preserved body, but rather to skid in broadside, thoroughly
used up, totally worn out and loudly proclaiming, 'Wow, what a ride!'


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 07:09 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
RadioBanter.com