RadioBanter

RadioBanter (https://www.radiobanter.com/)
-   Equipment (https://www.radiobanter.com/equipment/)
-   -   Am I the only one that does'nt like LCD screen ham radios? (https://www.radiobanter.com/equipment/67574-am-i-only-one-doesnt-like-lcd-screen-ham-radios.html)

Odd Ball March 24th 05 03:35 PM

Am I the only one that does'nt like LCD screen ham radios?
 


I just finished looking at the Tentec Orion, and I thought it was
ugly. I did not care for the Icom computer screen radios, or the
Kenwood orange LCD screen radios either. I want real knobs to turn,
real buttons to push, and a real analog meter to look at.
I sit in front of a computer all day at work. I don't want to look
at another computer screen when I get home and turn on my ham radio.
Am I the only one that thinks a radio should look like a radio, and
not an over sized Palm Pilot with a mic jack and a coax connector?

-OB


Dick March 24th 05 03:57 PM

On Thu, 24 Mar 2005 15:35:45 GMT, (Odd Ball)
wrote:



I just finished looking at the Tentec Orion, and I thought it was
ugly. I did not care for the Icom computer screen radios, or the
Kenwood orange LCD screen radios either. I want real knobs to turn,
real buttons to push, and a real analog meter to look at.
I sit in front of a computer all day at work. I don't want to look
at another computer screen when I get home and turn on my ham radio.
Am I the only one that thinks a radio should look like a radio, and
not an over sized Palm Pilot with a mic jack and a coax connector?

-OB


Fortunately, there are plenty of radios available to meet your
criteria. Should be able to pick up a Johnson Viking II and a
Hallicrafters SX-100 on Ebay. Lots of knobs and real meters.

Dick - W6CCD

Michael A. Terrell March 24th 05 04:02 PM

Odd Ball wrote:

I just finished looking at the Tentec Orion, and I thought it was
ugly. I did not care for the Icom computer screen radios, or the
Kenwood orange LCD screen radios either. I want real knobs to turn,
real buttons to push, and a real analog meter to look at.
I sit in front of a computer all day at work. I don't want to look
at another computer screen when I get home and turn on my ham radio.
Am I the only one that thinks a radio should look like a radio, and
not an over sized Palm Pilot with a mic jack and a coax connector?

-OB


If I'm going to run a piece of equipment from a computer I'd rather
do it from a real computer and not even see the other parts of the
system.

I worked on a $80,000 telemetry receiving system that ran under
Embedded Windows NT. A real pain in the ass to install the software and
set the radios up on the production floor.
--
?

Michael A. Terrell
Central Florida

Buck March 24th 05 04:35 PM

On Thu, 24 Mar 2005 15:35:45 GMT, (Odd Ball)
wrote:



I just finished looking at the Tentec Orion, and I thought it was
ugly. I did not care for the Icom computer screen radios, or the
Kenwood orange LCD screen radios either. I want real knobs to turn,
real buttons to push, and a real analog meter to look at.
I sit in front of a computer all day at work. I don't want to look
at another computer screen when I get home and turn on my ham radio.
Am I the only one that thinks a radio should look like a radio, and
not an over sized Palm Pilot with a mic jack and a coax connector?

-OB



I don't mind the computer displays, but I don't like having to follow
a menu several levels deep to set the controls I should be able to set
with the knobs. On the Icom 706, my biggest gripe is not being able
to set the display light level without having to turn off the rig
twice.

On the 706, i would much rather the Initial Set menu only set defaults
that will reset when I turn the rig off, but allow all the options be
available while the rig is turned on, if I want to change them.
Occasionally, I want to turn up the display light for a short while.
It makes no sense to me that I have to turn the rig off to turn the
light up so I can read the dial.


--
73 for now
Buck
N4PGW

Allodoxaphobia March 24th 05 04:53 PM

On Thu, 24 Mar 2005 16:02:54 GMT, Michael A. Terrell wrote:
Odd Ball wrote:

I just finished looking at the Tentec Orion, and I thought it was
ugly. I did not care for the Icom computer screen radios, or the
Kenwood orange LCD screen radios either. I want real knobs to turn,
real buttons to push, and a real analog meter to look at.
I sit in front of a computer all day at work. I don't want to look
at another computer screen when I get home and turn on my ham radio.
Am I the only one that thinks a radio should look like a radio, and
not an over sized Palm Pilot with a mic jack and a coax connector?


If I'm going to run a piece of equipment from a computer I'd rather
do it from a real computer and not even see the other parts of the
system.


The highway patrol is gonna frown on that 17" monitor up on the dashboard.

HI!HI!

73
Jonesy
--
| Marvin L Jones | jonz | W3DHJ | linux
| Gunnison, Colorado | @ | Jonesy | OS/2 __
| 7,703' -- 2,345m | config.com | DM68mn SK

Michael A. Terrell March 24th 05 08:16 PM

Allodoxaphobia wrote:

On Thu, 24 Mar 2005 16:02:54 GMT, Michael A. Terrell wrote:

If I'm going to run a piece of equipment from a computer I'd rather
do it from a real computer and not even see the other parts of the
system.


The highway patrol is gonna frown on that 17" monitor up on the dashboard.

HI!HI!

73
Jonesy



Who has time to operate mobile when there are so many retired crazies
on the road around here? :(

--
?

Michael A. Terrell
Central Florida

John Franklin March 25th 05 02:44 AM

Get a Collins KWM-2....................... THEY have meters and
knobs..........and TUBES TOO!

"Michael A. Terrell" wrote in message
...
Allodoxaphobia wrote:

On Thu, 24 Mar 2005 16:02:54 GMT, Michael A. Terrell wrote:

If I'm going to run a piece of equipment from a computer I'd rather
do it from a real computer and not even see the other parts of the
system.


The highway patrol is gonna frown on that 17" monitor up on the
dashboard.

HI!HI!

73
Jonesy



Who has time to operate mobile when there are so many retired crazies
on the road around here? :(

--
?

Michael A. Terrell
Central Florida




Michael A. Terrell March 25th 05 04:39 AM

John Franklin wrote:

Get a Collins KWM-2....................... THEY have meters and
knobs..........and TUBES TOO!



No thanks, the last transmitter I took care of was a 130 KW Comark
UHF TV transmitter with the antenna on a 1749 foot tower and it had a 5
MW ERP from Orange City, Florida. I prefer working on high end
receivers and their design problems but I had to leave the business due
to health problems. This was my last project:
http://www.l-3com.com/te/PDF/Microdyne/RCB-2000.pdf I worked as an
engineering tech to help move it from hand built prototypes to the
production floor.
It sold for about $80,000 when I left Microdyne.


--
?

Michael A. Terrell
Central Florida

Buck March 25th 05 05:49 AM


Curious;
Where would you want the dimmer control to be located on your ideal 706?
If you say as another layer to some menu function, well, that's where it
is now, and even the unit powers down during the process, the eeprom is
non-volatile so nothing is lost, or is it the slight pop you hear in the
speaker when powering down?
Like I say, just curious, I like mine a lot, but it's still new, and
maybe time will jade my fondness. g


I would like it to be in the menus while in operation. I know it
would add depth to the menu, but i find it ridiculous that I have to
turn the rig off when I want a brightener display or not. I usually
leave it on dim but there are times I prefer the display light off and
then on when I want to use it. and back off again. However, i
recently ran across a situation where I wanted to brighten it for a
short while. If I am in QSO, I don't want to turn the rig off and on
again. I can't hear very well with the receiver turned off.


--
73 for now
Buck
N4PGW

Buck March 25th 05 05:49 AM


Curious;
Where would you want the dimmer control to be located on your ideal 706?
If you say as another layer to some menu function, well, that's where it
is now, and even the unit powers down during the process, the eeprom is
non-volatile so nothing is lost, or is it the slight pop you hear in the
speaker when powering down?
Like I say, just curious, I like mine a lot, but it's still new, and
maybe time will jade my fondness. g



PS I have the MK II, not G version.

--
73 for now
Buck
N4PGW

John Harlow March 25th 05 02:27 PM

The highway patrol is gonna frown on that 17" monitor up on the
dashboard.


....if they notice it over the monitor on their OWN dashboard.



John Franklin March 25th 05 02:41 PM

I worked in broadcasting too...........got tired of the heat from the big
jugs in the xmitter. He said he didn't like LCD...........would he prefer
LEDS that consume MORE current? I always liked the Collins r-390A recvr,
good box.

John

"Michael A. Terrell" wrote in message
...

No thanks, the last transmitter I took care of was a 130 KW Comark
UHF TV transmitter with the antenna on a 1749 foot tower and it had a 5
MW ERP from Orange City, Florida. I prefer working on high end
receivers and their design problems but I had to leave the business due
to health problems. This was my last project:
http://www.l-3com.com/te/PDF/Microdyne/RCB-2000.pdf I worked as an
engineering tech to help move it from hand built prototypes to the
production floor.
It sold for about $80,000 when I left Microdyne.


--
?

Michael A. Terrell
Central Florida




Michael A. Terrell March 25th 05 06:37 PM

John Franklin wrote:

I worked in broadcasting too...........got tired of the heat from the big
jugs in the xmitter. He said he didn't like LCD...........would he prefer
LEDS that consume MORE current? I always liked the Collins r-390A recvr,
good box.

John



I worked around a 5 MW ERP TV station, No heat problems working on
the 130 KW Comark transmitter but it was a royal pain to flush the
cooling system and refill the antifreeze every year. Truck loads of
distilled bottled water in five gallon bottles because the well water at
the site was so hard. We used a cleaner called Tyglos (sp) to remove
any scaling from the plumbing but we had to keep it out of the three 65
KW Klystrons. We had to drain the system, disconnect the tubes and
bypass them then flush the system. I bought some fiberglass duct board
to put around the heat exchanger and used a "Salamander" heater to bring
the system up to normal temperature so the cleaner would work.

I have a National NC-183R on the bench right now to rebuild. Its a
better radio than either of the Radio Shack DX-300 or DX-375 radios but
I can't use it when the power lines are down after a hurricane. So, I
keep the DX-375 and a Sony SRF-49 around for the hurricane season.

--
?

Michael A. Terrell
Central Florida

John Franklin March 25th 05 06:42 PM

That's why my wife and I left Florida, last years 4 hurricanes were more
that too much!

"Michael A. Terrell" wrote in message
...
John Franklin wrote:

I have a National NC-183R on the bench right now to rebuild. Its a
better radio than either of the Radio Shack DX-300 or DX-375 radios but
I can't use it when the power lines are down after a hurricane. So, I
keep the DX-375 and a Sony SRF-49 around for the hurricane season.

--
?

Michael A. Terrell
Central Florida




Michael A. Terrell March 25th 05 09:37 PM

John Franklin wrote:

That's why my wife and I left Florida, last years 4 hurricanes were more
that too much!

"Michael A. Terrell" wrote in message
...
John Franklin wrote:

I have a National NC-183R on the bench right now to rebuild. Its a
better radio than either of the Radio Shack DX-300 or DX-375 radios but
I can't use it when the power lines are down after a hurricane. So, I
keep the DX-375 and a Sony SRF-49 around for the hurricane season.

--
?

Michael A. Terrell
Central Florida



I'm old, sick and on disability so I'd rather take my chances than go
through the stress of moving again. I'm here till I die.

--
?

Michael A. Terrell
Central Florida

Butch March 26th 05 12:45 AM

Here, here or hear, hear (never did know the right spelling for that)
but, hear,here...I too am too old and disabled to move from this
precious gulf coast, BUT, I won't have a green, or blue, or damn near
red LCD on any rig/receiver in my house when I'm found dead in it.

Butch said that

Michael A. Terrell wrote:
John Franklin wrote:

That's why my wife and I left Florida, last years 4 hurricanes were more
that too much!

"Michael A. Terrell" wrote in message
...

John Franklin wrote:

I have a National NC-183R on the bench right now to rebuild. Its a
better radio than either of the Radio Shack DX-300 or DX-375 radios but
I can't use it when the power lines are down after a hurricane. So, I
keep the DX-375 and a Sony SRF-49 around for the hurricane season.

--
?

Michael A. Terrell
Central Florida




I'm old, sick and on disability so I'd rather take my chances than go
through the stress of moving again. I'm here till I die.


KU4YP March 26th 05 02:55 AM

no,

you are not alone. LCD displays and seemingly endless sub menus have
kept me from purchasing newer gear.

the most hi tech piece of gear in the shack here is a kenwood ts-940
and a ts-711-a. other than that, it has tubes in it. one rig i regret
selling is the kenwood ts-830. simplicity at it's finest. it's all on
the front panel.

i have listened several times on 75 meters to people "tuning" the
modern rigs. mostly, the yeasu ft-1000 whatever series. it must be my
poor ears because i can not tell that much of a difference on ssb from
the newer stuff to the older. kenwoods have always had great ssb audio.
but if i am in the mood to listen to great audio, i tune in the 80 meter
AM crowd and listen to them on my hammarlund receiver.

everyone's millage varies, i suppose. i had a chance to purchase a icom
756 pro for what i thought was a reasonable price. when i began
researching the rig, i found that not only were the lcd screens prone to
failure, you could not get replacement screens for them. too much of a
crap shoot for me with people wanting 800 +/- for them.

i have several friends with lcd screen rigs. between the screen and the
menus, i'd rather keep what i have.

best 73 mike ku4yp

Bob Miller March 27th 05 02:23 AM

On Thu, 24 Mar 2005 15:35:45 GMT, (Odd Ball)
wrote:



I just finished looking at the Tentec Orion, and I thought it was
ugly. I did not care for the Icom computer screen radios, or the
Kenwood orange LCD screen radios either. I want real knobs to turn,
real buttons to push, and a real analog meter to look at.
I sit in front of a computer all day at work. I don't want to look
at another computer screen when I get home and turn on my ham radio.
Am I the only one that thinks a radio should look like a radio, and
not an over sized Palm Pilot with a mic jack and a coax connector?

-OB


That's fine, do you want to pay twice as much for a radio? Knobs,
buttons, switches, potentiometers, analog meters, gear- or
string-driven frequency readouts, huge faceplates of finely sculptured
aluminum, etecetera, all cost boucoup money.

On the other hand, a few function switches, encoders and software
devices with an LCD readout is a lot cheaper.

An alternative is to buy old stuff off Ebay -- of course, you'll need
to know how to work on radios if you go that route...

Bob
k5qwg




Joe S. March 27th 05 02:34 AM

Am I the only one who still likes radios with tubes and dial strings? And
rectifiers that glow blue? And big ol' transformers that keep your coffee
warm?

--

-----
Joe S.



"Odd Ball" wrote in message
...


I just finished looking at the Tentec Orion, and I thought it was
ugly. I did not care for the Icom computer screen radios, or the
Kenwood orange LCD screen radios either. I want real knobs to turn,
real buttons to push, and a real analog meter to look at.
I sit in front of a computer all day at work. I don't want to look
at another computer screen when I get home and turn on my ham radio.
Am I the only one that thinks a radio should look like a radio, and
not an over sized Palm Pilot with a mic jack and a coax connector?

-OB




Ed March 27th 05 04:30 AM



Am I the only one who still likes radios with tubes and dial strings?
And rectifiers that glow blue? And big ol' transformers that keep
your coffee warm?


I get all nostalgic over those, too, but I really don't miss burnt
fingers and the threat of sudden death while working around them, anymore.

:^)


Ed


SR March 27th 05 10:16 PM

And the neophyte asked...

Blue glow? I thought all vacuum tubes glowed orange at best. What's
happening to cause the tube to run so hot?

SR

"Joe S." wrote in message
...
Am I the only one who still likes radios with tubes and dial strings? And
rectifiers that glow blue? And big ol' transformers that keep your coffee
warm?

--

-----
Joe S.




nitespark March 27th 05 11:30 PM

Some of the old rectifiers had a blue glow to them.

SR wrote:
And the neophyte asked...

Blue glow? I thought all vacuum tubes glowed orange at best. What's
happening to cause the tube to run so hot?

SR

"Joe S." wrote in message
...

Am I the only one who still likes radios with tubes and dial strings? And
rectifiers that glow blue? And big ol' transformers that keep your coffee
warm?

--

-----
Joe S.





--
I have never met a liberal street cop.

Joe S. March 28th 05 02:49 AM


"nitespark" wrote in message
news:StG1e.67555$7z6.58474@lakeread04...
Some of the old rectifiers had a blue glow to them.


And they flickered as you talked because the current load on the power
supply changed with the modulation -- sort of like an aurora display right
there on the floor. On the floor because the power supply was too damn
heavy to sit on the desk.

Modulation is a whole 'nother thread.



SR wrote:
And the neophyte asked...

Blue glow? I thought all vacuum tubes glowed orange at best. What's
happening to cause the tube to run so hot?

SR

"Joe S." wrote in message
...

Am I the only one who still likes radios with tubes and dial strings?

And
rectifiers that glow blue? And big ol' transformers that keep your

coffee
warm?

--

-----
Joe S.





--
I have never met a liberal street cop.




Bruce Fletcher March 28th 05 10:17 AM

nitespark wrote:
Some of the old rectifiers had a blue glow to them.


Mercury arc rectifiers? A bit large for domestic use!
--
Bruce Fletcher
Stronsay, Orkney UK
www.stronsay.co.uk/claremont

Mr Fed UP March 28th 05 04:30 PM

BTW they have a news group rec.radio.amateur.boatanchors just for the "ol
ways" folks.
Good luck sparky




All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:58 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
RadioBanter.com