Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#10
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
I question the bit about insertion loss 7MHz away being a non-issue
with only a single open stub across the line. If you put an open stub of lossless 50 ohm line a quarter-wave long at 153MHz across the feed line, it puts a short across the line at 153, but it puts 0.26-j3.58 ohms across it at 146MHz. That's a 99% reflection, or SWR close to 200:1 at 146. It's only about a 17dB loss, but that's more loss than I'd want. But if you also put at the same point across the line either a shorted stub or an inductor to resonate that, it will let 146 pass much more easily...the inductance required is only about 4nH, though, so it ends up being a pretty short piece of wire, and a Q of 20 results in almost 3dB loss. Still, that's a lot better than 17dB loss. Also, you can tune a stub by making it very slightly shorter than calculated and adding capacitance to the open end--an air-dielectric 50 ohm stub cut 1cm short, with a 1pF capacitance across the open end, tunes back to 153MHz. A little piston cap lets you tune it right on the offending signal. (You can also make the 146MHz peak tuneable by using a stub a bit _longer_ than 1/4 wave at 146 in place of the inductor, and putting a tuning cap on it too...then it's easy to tweak right in for optimum performance.) These what-if scenarios are easy to simulate in RFSim99, which is freeware. There are lots of variations on the theme, but at very least, it's a quick check of a proposed solution to see if it's really all that good at both getting rid of the offender and passing the desired signal. Be sure to include expected loss resistance to simulate the finite Q of real components. Cheers, Tom |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
FA: Bud LF-601 low pass filter (LAST DAY) | Boatanchors | |||
FS: ROCKWELL COLLINS HF-380 AUDIO LOW PASS FILTER BOARD 646-5802-001 BRAND NEW | Swap | |||
Drake TV-3300 Low Pass Filter | Swap | |||
FS: New Nye Viking low pass filter | Equipment | |||
FS: New Nye Viking low pass filter | Equipment |