RadioBanter

RadioBanter (https://www.radiobanter.com/)
-   Shortwave (https://www.radiobanter.com/shortwave/)
-   -   Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution (https://www.radiobanter.com/shortwave/154338-re-compact-fluorescent-light-bulbs-proceed-caution.html)

John Smith September 23rd 10 06:00 AM

Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution
 
On 9/22/2010 4:39 PM, bpnjensen wrote:
On Sep 22, 3:45 pm, "Chas. wrote:
Average citizens cannot be trusted with economic decisions that
require balancing immediate costs and long-term benefits, according to
environmentalists.

[...]

•CFL manufacturers claim that a 13-watt CFL emits the same amount of
light as a 60-watt incandescent, but it doesn't seem to work that way
in the real world. I've been in CFL-lit hotel rooms where I need a
flashlight to read my dog-eared copy of The Road to Serfdom.

•Warm-up time: it takes up to 5 minutes for a CFL to reach full
strength, which may be related to the point above (why CFLs seem less
bright). My friend has installed them in a hallway where illumination
is needed only for the thirty seconds it takes to navigate the
staircase. Not ideal when Grandma visits and can't see the skateboard
on the stairs.

•Few CFLs last for their advertised lifetimes of five years or more.
Many people report replacing them after one year, making those return
on investment numbers a bit less rosy. Using them in ceiling fixtures,
on dimmers or timers, and for less than fifteen minutes per use reduce
their life.

•CFLs contain mercury and should be returned to a hazardous waste
center for disposal. Studies assume a 25% recycling rate, with the
rest going into landfills. (The Westinghouse website recommends
recycling only when disposing of "a large quantity" of fluorescent
tubes and doesn't mention how to dispose of their CFLs.) According to
a 2008 Yale study, burning coal to supply electricity to incandescent
bulbs emits more mercury per bulb than a CFL contains, but regions
that rely on cleaner fuels like natural gas experience greater mercury
contamination with the introduction of CFLs. Why would
environmentalists advocate to bring a toxic product into every home?

•Cleaning up a broken CFL doesn't require a haz-mat team, but you have
to take significant precautions to avoid mercury contamination of
living areas.

•Manufacturing CFLs is labor-intensive. No CFLs are made with
expensive U.S. labor; most are made in China, where hundreds of
factory workers in CFL plants have been hospitalized for mercury
poisoning. The last major light bulb factory in the U.S., a GE plant
in Winchester, VA, closed earlier this month.

•CFLs require six times as much energy to manufacture as incandescent
bulbs, not to mention -- if you're concerned about such things -- the
carbon footprint of shipping them from China.

•CFLs appear to cause migraines and epileptic seizures in a small
number of people. Other health risks are being studied.

•CFLs work poorly in cold temperatures -- as a wintertime front porch
light, for example. In cold climates, the heat of incandescent bulbs
is a useful -- if inefficient -- byproduct.

•CFLs degrade the quality of the electric current (so-called "dirty
electricity" with uneven sine waves) on a circuit into which they are
plugged, causing problems for other electronic devices and possible
health hazards to humans.

[...]

(complete story with references)http://www.americanthinker.com/2010/...ent_light_bulb...


Not my experience.


Whole family uses CFLs, most friends do to ... none of this seems more
than BS ...

Regards,
JS


RHF September 23rd 10 10:30 AM

Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution
 
On Sep 22, 10:00*pm, John Smith wrote:
On 9/22/2010 4:39 PM, bpnjensen wrote:



On Sep 22, 3:45 pm, "Chas. *wrote:
Average citizens cannot be trusted with economic decisions that
require balancing immediate costs and long-term benefits, according to
environmentalists.


[...]


•CFL manufacturers claim that a 13-watt CFL emits the same amount of
light as a 60-watt incandescent, but it doesn't seem to work that way
in the real world. I've been in CFL-lit hotel rooms where I need a
flashlight to read my dog-eared copy of The Road to Serfdom.


•Warm-up time: it takes up to 5 minutes for a CFL to reach full
strength, which may be related to the point above (why CFLs seem less
bright). My friend has installed them in a hallway where illumination
is needed only for the thirty seconds it takes to navigate the
staircase. Not ideal when Grandma visits and can't see the skateboard
on the stairs.


•Few CFLs last for their advertised lifetimes of five years or more.
Many people report replacing them after one year, making those return
on investment numbers a bit less rosy. Using them in ceiling fixtures,
on dimmers or timers, and for less than fifteen minutes per use reduce
their life.


•CFLs contain mercury and should be returned to a hazardous waste
center for disposal. Studies assume a 25% recycling rate, with the
rest going into landfills. (The Westinghouse website recommends
recycling only when disposing of "a large quantity" of fluorescent
tubes and doesn't mention how to dispose of their CFLs.) According to
a 2008 Yale study, burning coal to supply electricity to incandescent
bulbs emits more mercury per bulb than a CFL contains, but regions
that rely on cleaner fuels like natural gas experience greater mercury
contamination with the introduction of CFLs. Why would
environmentalists advocate to bring a toxic product into every home?


•Cleaning up a broken CFL doesn't require a haz-mat team, but you have
to take significant precautions to avoid mercury contamination of
living areas.


•Manufacturing CFLs is labor-intensive. No CFLs are made with
expensive U.S. labor; most are made in China, where hundreds of
factory workers in CFL plants have been hospitalized for mercury
poisoning. The last major light bulb factory in the U.S., a GE plant
in Winchester, VA, closed earlier this month.


•CFLs require six times as much energy to manufacture as incandescent
bulbs, not to mention -- if you're concerned about such things -- the
carbon footprint of shipping them from China.


•CFLs appear to cause migraines and epileptic seizures in a small
number of people. Other health risks are being studied.


•CFLs work poorly in cold temperatures -- as a wintertime front porch
light, for example. In cold climates, the heat of incandescent bulbs
is a useful -- if inefficient -- byproduct.


•CFLs degrade the quality of the electric current (so-called "dirty
electricity" with uneven sine waves) on a circuit into which they are
plugged, causing problems for other electronic devices and possible
health hazards to humans.


[...]


(complete story with references)http://www.americanthinker.com/2010/...ent_light_bulb...


Not my experience.


Whole family uses CFLs, most friends do to ... none of this seems more
than BS ...

Regards,
JS


JS you got any family with the initials "BS" ? ;;-}}

John Smith September 23rd 10 03:24 PM

Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution
 
On 9/23/2010 2:30 AM, RHF wrote:

...
JS you got any family with the initials "BS" ? ;;-}}


I live in California, it is always warm enough for lightbulbs to work.
grin

Regards,
JS

[email protected] September 23rd 10 03:36 PM

Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution
 
In 1966, the temperature in Corinth,Mississippi got down to nineteen
degrees below zero.I bet those Incandescent Light Bulbs felt good for
hand warmers.
cuhulin


Sid9[_2_] September 23rd 10 03:37 PM

Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution
 

"John Smith" wrote in message
...
On 9/23/2010 2:30 AM, RHF wrote:

...
JS you got any family with the initials "BS" ? ;;-}}


I live in California, it is always warm enough for lightbulbs to work.
grin

Regards,
JS

..
..
The yellowish-orange light that incandescent lamps give off is similar to
the color of the light candles emit.

There's no reason that we should stick to that puny sickly color.

CFL lamps can do a good job of emulating daylight.

Regarding energy. When I had incandescent lamps in our high hats I could
warm the room by simply turning the lights on.

This was an indicator of how much extra energy (and money) I needed to waste
during air-conditioning season.

No more. I had these for years. I would never go back.



John Smith September 23rd 10 04:48 PM

Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution
 
On 9/23/2010 7:37 AM, Sid9 wrote:

...
.
The yellowish-orange light that incandescent lamps give off is similar
to the color of the light candles emit.

There's no reason that we should stick to that puny sickly color.

CFL lamps can do a good job of emulating daylight.

Regarding energy. When I had incandescent lamps in our high hats I could
warm the room by simply turning the lights on.

This was an indicator of how much extra energy (and money) I needed to
waste during air-conditioning season.

No more. I had these for years. I would never go back.



You want "Daylight" bulbs, 6500K ... revel are better than most CFLs,
but still lack the brightness and whiteness of Daylight ... normal "warm
white" or "cool white" are little better than incandescent ...

Regards,
JS

Beam Me Up Scotty[_3_] September 23rd 10 05:17 PM

Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution
 
On 9/23/2010 10:37 AM, Sid9 wrote:

"John Smith" wrote in message
...
On 9/23/2010 2:30 AM, RHF wrote:

...
JS you got any family with the initials "BS" ? ;;-}}


I live in California, it is always warm enough for lightbulbs to work.
grin

Regards,
JS

.
.
The yellowish-orange light that incandescent lamps give off is similar
to the color of the light candles emit.

There's no reason that we should stick to that puny sickly color.

CFL lamps can do a good job of emulating daylight.


Choice is a nice thing.....


Regarding energy. When I had incandescent lamps in our high hats I could
warm the room by simply turning the lights on.

This was an indicator of how much extra energy (and money) I needed to
waste during air-conditioning season.

No more. I had these for years. I would never go back.




jane[_2_] September 23rd 10 06:55 PM

Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution
 
On Sep 23, 9:24*am, John Smith wrote:
On 9/23/2010 2:30 AM, RHF wrote:

...
JS you got any family with the initials "BS" ? ;;-}}


I live in California, it is always warm enough for lightbulbs to work.
grin

Regards,
JS


I use a combination of old fashioned and new fashioned CFLs.

As already mentioned, it makes no sense to use CFLs in a hallway or
stairway where the light is only on for less than a minute.

It also makes no sense to use CFLs in decorative bathroom lights or
ANY light where the fixture points down like an upside down tulip or a
ceiling canister light. The upside down tulip or canister builds up
heat which will kill a capacitor in the CFL.

I also discovered a very interesting problem with CFLs and pets. The
old fashioned fluorescent bulbs use a magnetic ballast that operates
at 60hz and the flicker would drive some people crazy. The new CFLs
operate at 20,000 hz and this " drive em crazy" problem has gone away.
HOWEVER, the 20,000hz of the CFLs emit a 20,000hz sound that dogs and
cats can hear and it drives THEM crazy.

In an experiment, a CFL was put in a single room where a dog would
frequently lay. When the CFL was installed, the dog wouldn't go in
that particular room any more.

Jane.

http://www.science20.com/science_amp...ur_pets_insane

bpnjensen September 23rd 10 07:00 PM

Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution
 
On Sep 23, 10:55*am, jane wrote:
On Sep 23, 9:24*am, John Smith wrote:

On 9/23/2010 2:30 AM, RHF wrote:


...
JS you got any family with the initials "BS" ? ;;-}}


I live in California, it is always warm enough for lightbulbs to work.
grin


Regards,
JS


I use a combination of old fashioned and new fashioned CFLs.

As already mentioned, it makes no sense to use CFLs in a hallway or
stairway where the light is only on for less than a minute.

It also makes no sense to use CFLs in decorative bathroom lights or
ANY light where the fixture points down like an upside down tulip or a
ceiling canister light. *The upside down tulip or canister builds up
heat which will kill a capacitor in the CFL.

I also discovered a very interesting problem with CFLs and pets. *The
old fashioned fluorescent bulbs use a magnetic ballast that operates
at 60hz and the flicker would drive some people crazy. *The new CFLs
operate at 20,000 hz and this " drive em crazy" problem has gone away.
HOWEVER, the 20,000hz of the CFLs emit a 20,000hz sound that dogs and
cats can hear and it drives THEM crazy.

In an experiment, a CFL was put in a single room where a dog would
frequently lay. *When the CFL was installed, the dog wouldn't go in
that particular room any more.

Jane.

http://www.science20.com/science_amp...lbs_save_plane...


My cats seem to have no response to our CFLs.

jane[_2_] September 23rd 10 07:13 PM

Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution
 
On Sep 23, 1:00*pm, bpnjensen wrote:
On Sep 23, 10:55*am, jane wrote:





On Sep 23, 9:24*am, John Smith wrote:


On 9/23/2010 2:30 AM, RHF wrote:


...
JS you got any family with the initials "BS" ? ;;-}}


I live in California, it is always warm enough for lightbulbs to work..
grin


Regards,
JS


I use a combination of old fashioned and new fashioned CFLs.


As already mentioned, it makes no sense to use CFLs in a hallway or
stairway where the light is only on for less than a minute.


It also makes no sense to use CFLs in decorative bathroom lights or
ANY light where the fixture points down like an upside down tulip or a
ceiling canister light. *The upside down tulip or canister builds up
heat which will kill a capacitor in the CFL.


I also discovered a very interesting problem with CFLs and pets. *The
old fashioned fluorescent bulbs use a magnetic ballast that operates
at 60hz and the flicker would drive some people crazy. *The new CFLs
operate at 20,000 hz and this " drive em crazy" problem has gone away.
HOWEVER, the 20,000hz of the CFLs emit a 20,000hz sound that dogs and
cats can hear and it drives THEM crazy.


In an experiment, a CFL was put in a single room where a dog would
frequently lay. *When the CFL was installed, the dog wouldn't go in
that particular room any more.


Jane.


http://www.science20.com/science_amp...lbs_save_plane...


My cats seem to have no response to our CFLs.- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -



How do you know?

Try the experiment where you use incadescent bulbs in all of your
rooms and put a CFL in his/her favorite sleeping place.


[email protected] September 23rd 10 07:19 PM

Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution
 
Looka here, while ago, JT said he bought one of those new so-called
efficient clothes washing machines, the kind that doesn't use much
water.He said his wife complains that new washing machine doesn't get
clothes as clean as their old Sears Kenmore washing machine did.JT said
he is looking for a good old Sears Kenmore washing machine.
cuhulin


[email protected] September 23rd 10 07:26 PM

Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution
 
So, if I put a 20,000hz bulb in my front porch light, that will drive
those dogs out there crazy? I Want That!

What kind of range do those 20,000hz bulbs have? Will that 20,000hz bulb
affect my doggy? I always keep my doggy in my house.What name brand and
model are those 20,000hz bulbs?
cuhulin


Sid9[_2_] September 23rd 10 10:29 PM

Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution
 

"Dennis M" wrote in message
...
In article
, jane
wrote:

HOWEVER, the 20,000hz of the CFLs emit a 20,000hz sound that dogs and
cats can hear and it drives THEM crazy.


Thanks for the info, I'd love to drive some of my irresponsible neighbors'
dogs and cats who gallivant around on my property crazy (maybe it even
works as good as the overpriced "animal repellers" you see advertised on
TV).

..
..
..
Don't worry about jane.
jane is detached from the 21st century.
jane uses incandescent lamps and an outdoor TV antenna.
She has no clue about CNN, FOX, MSNBC, C-Span1, 2, and 3
jane thinks Herbert Hoover, Richard Nixon, St Reagan, and the bushes are
great American heroes

I never saw a cat or dog affected by CFL lamps.


[email protected] September 23rd 10 11:36 PM

Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution
 
Jane just might be right.Next time I go to the store, I am going to look
for one of them thar 20,000hz bulbs, while I am loading up on and
hoarding some more General Electric 60 Watt Incandescent Light Bulbs,
Real Light Bulbs.It it affects my little couch buddy doggy though, I
will not use that bulb anymore.
cuhulin


[email protected] September 24th 10 02:53 PM

Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution
 
Doggy freaks out everytime I open a new bag of cookies.
WOO WOO WOOF!
Then she runs and gets one of her rubber squeaky doggy toys and thrashes
it around.One of them looks like a bone, she parks it by my foot, I kick
it with my foot, she jumps up and catches it and thrashes it around.
cuhulin


dave September 24th 10 03:07 PM

Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution
 
bpnjensen wrote:


My cats seem to have no response to our CFLs.


I have a cat that freaks when I dig into a bag of crushed ice, because
of the high-pitched crackling. She has no such reaction when I fire up
the CFLs. I have 5 [ea] 25 Watt deliciously warm CFLs in my studio, 4
of which are base up in old school white surface mount fixtures, fed by
zip cord and Scotchloks.

dave September 24th 10 03:10 PM

Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution
 
wrote:
Looka here, while ago, JT said he bought one of those new so-called
efficient clothes washing machines, the kind that doesn't use much
water.He said his wife complains that new washing machine doesn't get
clothes as clean as their old Sears Kenmore washing machine did.JT said
he is looking for a good old Sears Kenmore washing machine.
cuhulin


So frontloaders are the CFLs of washing machines? Got it.

RHF September 24th 10 09:27 PM

Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution
 
On Sep 23, 7:37*am, "Sid9" wrote:
"John Smith" wrote in message

... On 9/23/2010 2:30 AM, RHF wrote:

...
JS you got any family with the initials "BS" ? ;;-}}


I live in California, it is always warm enough for lightbulbs to work.
grin


Regards,
JS


.
.
The yellowish-orange light that incandescent lamps give off is similar to
the color of the light candles emit.

There's no reason that we should stick to that puny sickly color.


- CFL lamps can do a good job of emulating daylight.

Yes they do... and Full Spectrum DayLight CFLs
Can Be Very Good for Your Health too . . .

Sunlight's Long Legacy of Restoring and Healing*
http://products.mercola.com/light-bulbs/
* Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seasona...ctive_disorder

RHF September 24th 10 09:30 PM

Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution
 
On Sep 23, 8:48*am, John Smith wrote:
On 9/23/2010 7:37 AM, Sid9 wrote:



...
.
The yellowish-orange light that incandescent lamps give off is similar
to the color of the light candles emit.


There's no reason that we should stick to that puny sickly color.


CFL lamps can do a good job of emulating daylight.


Regarding energy. When I had incandescent lamps in our high hats I could
warm the room by simply turning the lights on.


This was an indicator of how much extra energy (and money) I needed to
waste during air-conditioning season.


No more. I had these for years. I would never go back.


- You want "Daylight" bulbs, 6500K ...
- revel are better than most CFLs,
- but still lack the brightness and whiteness of Daylight
- ... normal "warm white" or "cool white" are little better
- than incandescent ...
-
- Regards,
- JS

Yes 6500K DayLight CFL Bulbs are very good.

The Full Spectrum CFL Bulbs are even better
and can be Very Good for Your Health too . . .

Sunlight's Long Legacy of Restoring and Healing*
http://products.mercola.com/light-bulbs/
* Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seasona...ctive_disorder

dave September 25th 10 01:51 PM

Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution
 
John Smith wrote:
On 9/24/2010 7:07 AM, dave wrote:
bpnjensen wrote:


My cats seem to have no response to our CFLs.


I have a cat that freaks when I dig into a bag of crushed ice, because
of the high-pitched crackling. She has no such reaction when I fire up
the CFLs. I have 5 [ea] 25 Watt deliciously warm CFLs in my studio, 4 of
which are base up in old school white surface mount fixtures, fed by zip
cord and Scotchloks.


I once had a vision like that, but I think it was just the dope ...

Regards,
JS


That's what I was going for when I built the room.

John Smith September 26th 10 12:36 AM

Compact Fluorescent Light Bulbs: Proceed with Caution
 
On 9/25/2010 5:51 AM, dave wrote:

...
I once had a vision like that, but I think it was just the dope ...

Regards,
JS


That's what I was going for when I built the room.


Well, you succeeded! Great.

Most here will recognize that you are a dope ... so, apparently, the
room worked! Nice job!

Regards,
JS


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:22 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
RadioBanter.com