RadioBanter

RadioBanter (https://www.radiobanter.com/)
-   Shortwave (https://www.radiobanter.com/shortwave/)
-   -   r5000 or r71a (https://www.radiobanter.com/shortwave/38508-r5000-r71a.html)

Lars Petterson October 7th 03 07:20 AM

In article ,
LHogan5782 wrote:
where can i get this memory board and what is the price. what do you mean no
battery faults?


One alternative might be
http://www.piexx.com/cgi-bin/piexx.c...=7351684.26389

They also have a UX-14 replica (so that you can steer your radio from
a computer)
http://www.piexx.com/cgi-bin/piexx.c...=7351684.26389

I have not tried these myself, so I do not know if they are good
or not.

/Lars
--
Lars E. Pettersson | Chalmers University of Technology
| Gothenburg, SWEDEN

Andy Bown October 7th 03 07:22 AM

The level of performance of the two receivers is about the same. The
R5000 has better audio, but the Kiwa audio fix for the R71 makes a lot
of difference and isn't difficult to install. The R71 is much more
user friendly in my opinion. The keyboard on the R5000 is horible..

Both are fine receivers

Andy

BDK October 7th 03 11:50 AM

In article ,
says...
The level of performance of the two receivers is about the same. The
R5000 has better audio, but the Kiwa audio fix for the R71 makes a lot
of difference and isn't difficult to install. The R71 is much more
user friendly in my opinion. The keyboard on the R5000 is horible..

Both are fine receivers

Andy


Oh yeah, that keyboard is really annoying, and they tend to get
squirelly whenthey get older too sometimes. I hate the R5000's tuning
knob too, why no finger hole??

BDK

Stephan Grossklass October 7th 03 12:08 PM

Jerry schrieb:

I've always been interested in SW radio as a listener and have decided
to get more serious about it to see just how strong my interest really
is. As a start, I want to get a good used radio, and it seems like the
Kenwood R5000 or the ICOM R71A are very popular.


AFAIK the Icom has rather high distortion in AM, which means it's more a
ham/ute thing (when unmodified at least).
Age related problems: The infamous lithium battery - doesn't seem to be
flat too frequently (yet), but when it does it takes the firmware with
it and you have to get the thing reprogrammed at Icom.

The Kenwood apparently has good audio and is more a program listener
thing, though the keyboard isn't all too appealing with its non-standard
layout. Standard 6 kHz AM filter isn't too bad, but for DX the
replacement YK88A-1 should be chosen.
Age related problems: Tuning knob seizure.

Good replacement crystal filters exist for both. (The respective 2nd IF
is 8.83 MHz for the Kenwood, 9 MHz for the Icom. No, these 80s beasts
don't use 455 kHz as last IF for AM/SSB yet, just as 3rd IF for for FM,
which means good replacement filters virtually have to be crystal ones.
The current IC-R75 uses a 2nd IF of 9.0115 MHz and a 3rd IF of 455 kHz,
and allows using filters on both. The AR7030 also uses cascaded filters,
all on 455 kHz in this case. Drake's R8/A/B uses a 2nd IF on 50 kHz to
implement good coil filters - those in the R7 had a form factor of
around 2, which is very good for this type of filters.)

Stephan
--
Home: http://stephan.win31.de/ | Webm.: http://www.i24.com/
PC#6: i440LX, 2xCel300A, 448 MB, 18 GB, ATI AGP 32 MB, 110W
This is a SCSI-inside, Legacy-plus, TCPA-free computer :)
Reply to newsgroup only. | See home page for working e-mail address.

RHF October 7th 03 05:18 PM

= = = BDK
= = = wrote in message ...
In article ,
says...

Oh yeah, that keyboard is really annoying, and they tend to get
squirelly whenthey get older too sometimes. I hate the R5000's tuning
knob too, why no finger hole??

BDK



BDK,

There is a product "FingerDimple" that is available
- - - to 'improve' the R-5000's Tuning Knob.

Read "Spinner knob for R5000" Meassage #401
- - - on the 'Kenwood R-5000' eGroup on YAHOO !
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/kenwood-r5000/message/401


~ RHF

..

..

J999w October 8th 03 02:46 AM

AFAIK the Icom has rather high distortion in AM, which means it's more a
ham/ute thing (when unmodified at least).


I use my Kiwa audio upgraded R71a 95% on AM and have no trouble. A friend of
mine has a completely stock radio and I could never find fault with it. Depends
on how critical your ears are I guess.


jw
wb9uai

Andy Bown October 8th 03 08:19 AM

I use my Kiwa audio upgraded R71a 95% on AM and have no trouble. A friend of
mine has a completely stock radio and I could never find fault with it. Depends
on how critical your ears are I guess.


jw
wb9uai


Hi

My receiver has the Kiwa audio mod and I have absolutely no complaints
with it. I also replaced the stock wide filter with an LFH2SK 3.7 KHz
filter from Kiwa. Even with a narrow bandwidth such as this, I can get
very acceptable audio quality by turning the passband tuning knob to
either the 10 or 2 o'clock position. It sounds at least as good as my
Kiwa modified (filters and expanded audio upgrade) FRG-100 using the 6
Khz bandwidth. The R71 is a fine receiver and I personally wouldn't
trade it in for anything else.

Cheers

Andy

BDK October 8th 03 05:52 PM

In article , rhf-
says...
= = = BDK
= = = wrote in message ...
In article ,
says...

Oh yeah, that keyboard is really annoying, and they tend to get
squirelly whenthey get older too sometimes. I hate the R5000's tuning
knob too, why no finger hole??

BDK



BDK,

There is a product "FingerDimple" that is available
- - - to 'improve' the R-5000's Tuning Knob.

Read "Spinner knob for R5000" Meassage #401
- - - on the 'Kenwood R-5000' eGroup on YAHOO !
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/kenwood-r5000/message/401


~ RHF

.

.


Yeah, I know, there was a knob for a Yaesu radio that fit perfectly, I
don't remember the model number anymore. I just don't get the Kenwood
amking radio after radio with no finger hole. Just odd to me.

BDK

radiobuff October 13th 03 08:43 PM

Have to agree with Andy there...I wouldn't trade my R71A for anything. I
bought the new R75 and it sits on top of that - I park one and drive the
other. Absolutely fantastic radios in my opinion...both of them

john
kf4anc

"Jerry" wrote in message
...

I've always been interested in SW radio as a listener and have decided
to get more serious about it to see just how strong my interest really
is. As a start, I want to get a good used radio, and it seems like the
Kenwood R5000 or the ICOM R71A are very popular. It looks to me
like the ICOM has more features, such as CW, RTTY, and a superior
notch filter. This makes me believe it is aimed at the more serious
user. Two web sites that review receivers rate the R71A slightly
higher than the R5000. So, I would expect R71A's to be in higher
demand, but it seem to be the opposite. R5000's seem to sell at
higher prices and I see R71A owners wanting to trade for R5000's.
What am I missing? Which would be a better radio for a beginner?
I will probably start out with DX and broadcast, but may want to
grow into other areas. Thanks for any advice.

Jer





Andy Bown October 14th 03 04:44 AM

Hi John

As you have both the R71 and R75, how do you find they compare? DSP
aside, is there much difference in their performance? Have either of
your radios had any mods or options installed?

Cheers and enjoy your radios

Andy


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:01 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
RadioBanter.com