RadioBanter

RadioBanter (https://www.radiobanter.com/)
-   Shortwave (https://www.radiobanter.com/shortwave/)
-   -   Icom R75 vs. R8B (https://www.radiobanter.com/shortwave/42968-icom-r75-vs-r8b.html)

Margaret von Busenhalter-Butt May 31st 04 04:46 AM

Icom R75 vs. R8B
 
Icom R75 with all the Kiwa mods, including the complete attenuation removal
is roughly equal to Drake R8B in both SW AND MW performance.

True or false?

Please note that this is not an attempt to start a flamefest. Ideally I'd
like to have an opinion from folks who run or have run both machines side by
side.

Cheers,

MvBB



longwave May 31st 04 08:34 AM

Margaret von Busenhalter-Butt wrote:

Icom R75 with all the Kiwa mods, including the complete attenuation removal
is roughly equal to Drake R8B in both SW AND MW performance.

True or false?

Please note that this is not an attempt to start a flamefest. Ideally I'd
like to have an opinion from folks who run or have run both machines side by
side.

Cheers,

MvBB


Roughly true but it still tips the balance in favor of the R8B if you
are a program listener more than a SSB/utility listener.


-----= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =-----
http://www.newsfeeds.com - The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World!
-----== Over 100,000 Newsgroups - 19 Different Servers! =-----

David May 31st 04 03:29 PM

I have both (my R-75 is unmodified). They seem about equal, with
maybe a slight tip to the ICOM for UTE and tough signal DX. The Drake
has the more listener-friendly features for plain old program
listening.

Bottom line: If you can only afford 1 radio and listen to SWBC and MW
a lot, get the Drake. If you lean toward UTE, Digital Modes and tough
signal DX get the ICOM.

On Mon, 31 May 2004 03:34:24 -0400, longwave
wrote:

Margaret von Busenhalter-Butt wrote:

Icom R75 with all the Kiwa mods, including the complete attenuation removal
is roughly equal to Drake R8B in both SW AND MW performance.

True or false?

Please note that this is not an attempt to start a flamefest. Ideally I'd
like to have an opinion from folks who run or have run both machines side by
side.

Cheers,

MvBB


Roughly true but it still tips the balance in favor of the R8B if you
are a program listener more than a SSB/utility listener.


-----= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =-----
http://www.newsfeeds.com - The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World!
-----== Over 100,000 Newsgroups - 19 Different Servers! =-----



starman June 1st 04 06:42 AM

Michael wrote:

I have used both radios. My primary radio is an R-75 with all the kiwa
mods and an external speaker. I also have the DSP unit installed. I prefer
the R-75 for DX'ing. Mostly because I dx most weak signals using ecss
tuning method in ssb and I like using the R-75 much better as a ssb radio.


Can you give us some examples of the weak signal stations you receive on
the R-75 with ECSS? What kind of antenna do you use for these DX
stations?

Thanks


-----= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =-----
http://www.newsfeeds.com - The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World!
-----== Over 100,000 Newsgroups - 19 Different Servers! =-----

matt weber June 2nd 04 02:13 AM

On Mon, 31 May 2004 03:46:46 GMT, "Margaret von Busenhalter-Butt"
wrote:

Icom R75 with all the Kiwa mods, including the complete attenuation removal
is roughly equal to Drake R8B in both SW AND MW performance.

True or false?

Please note that this is not an attempt to start a flamefest. Ideally I'd
like to have an opinion from folks who run or have run both machines side by
side.

Cheers,

MvBB


There is a reason the Drake R8B has near legend in status, and no
amount of tinkering with a lesser receiver will make it equal. However
the difference are not things that most people are every likely to
hear, in the lab they can be measured, they can rarely be heard.


RHF June 2nd 04 02:16 AM

= = = dxAce wrote in message
= = = ...
Margaret von Busenhalter-Butt wrote:

Icom R75 with all the Kiwa mods, including the complete attenuation removal
is roughly equal to Drake R8B in both SW AND MW performance.

True or false?


False.

I have used both radios and have found the R8B to be superior in all respects.

Steve
Holland, MI
Drake R7, R8 and R8B
"I swear by, not at, Drake receivers"©

http://www.iserv.net/~n8kdv/dxpage.htm


DX Ace [N8KDV],

Having 'said' your Say.

What would you say was the 'Best Value for the Money' the
Drake R8B or the Icom IC-R75 for a Shortwave Listener (SWL)
moving up from a 'portable' AM/FM/Shortwave Radio to a Desk
Top LW/MW/Shortwave Receiver.

[ ] Drake R8B

[ ] Icom IC-R75 (R-75) with Kiwa Mods.

One or the 'other' Only Please ~ RHF

..

Llgpt June 2nd 04 02:29 AM

Subject: Icom R75 vs. R8B
From: (RHF)
Date: 6/1/2004 8:16 PM Central Daylight Time
Message-id:

= = = dxAce wrote in message
= = = ...
Margaret von Busenhalter-Butt wrote:

Icom R75 with all the Kiwa mods, including the complete attenuation

removal
is roughly equal to Drake R8B in both SW AND MW performance.

True or false?


False.

I have used both radios and have found the R8B to be superior in all

respects.

Steve
Holland, MI
Drake R7, R8 and R8B
"I swear by, not at, Drake receivers"©

http://www.iserv.net/~n8kdv/dxpage.htm

DX Ace [N8KDV],

Having 'said' your Say.

What would you say was the 'Best Value for the Money' the
Drake R8B or the Icom IC-R75 for a Shortwave Listener (SWL)
moving up from a 'portable' AM/FM/Shortwave Radio to a Desk
Top LW/MW/Shortwave Receiver.

[ ] Drake R8B

[XX ] Icom IC-R75 (R-75) with Kiwa Mods.

One or the 'other' Only Please ~ RHF


Better value, not better receiver.

Les




Telamon June 2nd 04 04:33 AM

In article ,
ocom (Michael Bryant) wrote:

From: dxAce


I have used both radios and have found the R8B to be superior in all
respects.


Could you detail the amount of time you've spent operating an R75? I
suggest you check your previous statements in the archives before
being accused of lying, yet again.


You don't have any radios lying, Trolling creep.

--
Telamon
Ventura, California

starman June 2nd 04 08:00 AM

Michael wrote:

"starman" wrote in message


Can you give us some examples of the weak signal stations you receive on
the R-75 with ECSS? What kind of antenna do you use for these DX
stations?

Thanks


DX'ing weak signals have just as much to do with "conditions" as they do
with the power and distance of the transmitted signal. It may be very easy
to get say...RNZI from my location during times of the day and year when
conditions are good for it, and impossible to pick it up during other times.


I've used ECSS to identify weak carriers too but I was wondering what
you would consider a good DX catch. What have you heard lately that you
would classify as weak DX, given all the "conditions"?


-----= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =-----
http://www.newsfeeds.com - The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World!
-----== Over 100,000 Newsgroups - 19 Different Servers! =-----

dxAce June 2nd 04 11:05 AM



matt weber wrote:

On Mon, 31 May 2004 03:46:46 GMT, "Margaret von Busenhalter-Butt"
wrote:

Icom R75 with all the Kiwa mods, including the complete attenuation removal
is roughly equal to Drake R8B in both SW AND MW performance.

True or false?

Please note that this is not an attempt to start a flamefest. Ideally I'd
like to have an opinion from folks who run or have run both machines side by
side.

Cheers,

MvBB


There is a reason the Drake R8B has near legend in status, and no
amount of tinkering with a lesser receiver will make it equal. However
the difference are not things that most people are every likely to
hear, in the lab they can be measured, they can rarely be heard.


Keep telling yourself that as you operate a 'lesser' receiver!




All times are GMT +1. The time now is 08:58 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
RadioBanter.com