RadioBanter - Drake R8B tuning prob

RadioBanter (https://www.radiobanter.com/)

- Shortwave (https://www.radiobanter.com/shortwave/)

- - Drake R8B tuning prob (https://www.radiobanter.com/shortwave/77645-drake-r8b-tuning-prob.html)

Drake R8B tuning prob

Hi

My Drake R8B tuning sometimes gets lost when I spin the knob fast.
I'll be going up 7.2, 7.3, 7.4, 7.2 See? I expect this is a pretty
common prob.

Ok so unit is going to go back to Drake for fix and I will tell them to
go thru whole unit and check it out.

Any idea what they will charge me for this?

regards,
Bob

It's the crappy mechanical tuning encoder that the tuning knob
operates. Drake should have stayed with the higher quality optical
encoder like the old R-8 had. This problem is common in the SW-2 also
because it uses the same encoder.

Frank

Sweet price,

I can get one of the technicians at work to fix for me.

regards,
Bob

Drake changed to the mechanical encoder because it was cheaper!

Frank

Digi-Key used to have a Grayhill optical encoder in the 30 dollar range. The
mod should be pretty easy. You just need to connect it to a source of +5V
and probably remove the pullup resistors that are connected to the Up/Down
tune lines.

Pete

wrote in message
oups.com...
Drake changed to the mechanical encoder because it was cheaper!

Frank

Ok thanks everybody for input. I just sent Drake Email to see what
kind of service they offer. I would like whole unit checked out soup
to nuts. I want to make sure running AOK to present config and so
forth. Unit is very nice and I will probably keep, but if I decide to
sell I would like to tell potential owner that factory has recently
blessed unit.

73
Bob
N9NEO

Here is reply from Drake if anybody interested. I wish I could make
100 bucks an hour fixing radios!

regards,
Bob
N9NEO

************************************************** *********************
The service rate is $25.00 per quarter hour. The average repair time
involved is an hour to two hours. We will align and bring the unit
back to the original specifications. The software, Version 12 is
current. Please enclose a cover letter with your name, address,
telephone number, and a brief description of the fault or reason for
its return. We accept Visa, Master Card, American Express, and
Discover Card.
************************************************** *********************

wrote:
Ok thanks everybody for input. I just sent Drake Email to see what
kind of service they offer. I would like whole unit checked out soup
to nuts. I want to make sure running AOK to present config and so
forth. Unit is very nice and I will probably keep, but if I decide to
sell I would like to tell potential owner that factory has recently
blessed unit.

73
Bob
N9NEO

Yes I agree Telamon. A good service bureau is an expensive
proposition. The ones I am familiar with (industrial based) barely
break even after salaries are paid. The important thing here is that
somebody is getting paid a salary. I would think the consumer market
is even worse. I suppose that is why so many mom & pop tv radio shops
are gone now. It's a shame.

73
Bob
N9NEO

1965,brand spanking new wooden cabinet 21 inch screen Zenith tv set.(it
is a heavy tv set too,it is sitting on the floor in my front
bedroom/junkroom right now,long since unused,it still gets a picture
though,but barely) I took that tv set to Wink Radio & TV Repair shop on
Capitol Street more times than I care to remember.(They put some sort of
a tv tube brightner thingy on the back of the tube,I think) Every once
in a while,it got to where I was taking it back for some sort of a
repair job.From that point on,I swore off of buying anything new that
has the Zenith brand name on it.RCA is the Worlds best tv sets,in my
opinion.I am useing a 27 inch screen RCA tv set now for my webtv.I
bought it brand new at a Wal Mart store wayyyyy out on Lakeland Drive in
Jackson on October 15,1999 and it is still working just as good as new
with nearly thirty nine thousand hours of use on it,according to the tv
set's Menu thingy I checked about a week ago.I have owned RCA tv sets
before and never once did I have any problems at all with them compared
to that Zenith tv set other than they just got old and worn out.Me,buy
another new Zenith anything again? It ain't gonna happen,babes,it ain't
Never gonna happen! I am planning on buying a new CRT HDTVtv set next
year from one of Cowboy Maloney's Electric City stores in Jackson and it
will be an RCA.RCA all the way.I am not interested in any other brand
names of tv sets.
cuhulin

I paid about $276.00 for my RCA tv set at a Wal Mart store on October
15,1999.The same model 27 inch screen RCA tv sets nowdays are about
$174.00 at the Wal Mart stores.
cuhulin

Madman Muntz manufactured some Automobiles too.
cuhulin

So,if they charge you two hours of work on the radio and there will be
shipping & handling charges too,it will cost you over
$200.00.Hopefully,they can repair it for you in one quarter hour.
cuhulin

Tony Meloche wrote:

I agree. When I was knee-high (mid fifties) TV repair shops were
swamped with work, and many "8 to 4:30" guys studied nights to learn TV
repair, and made it into a lucrative sideline. The original TV chassis
(save the Muntz, for one) had around 32 tubes on the board besides the
CRT. They were in the shop three, sometimes four times a year as a
matter of course, as they slowly cooked themselves to death. People
accepted it as part of the miracle of "pictures through the air".
Madman Muntz designed a 17 tube chassis (some double duty some cut
corners) and they were very reliable sets - maybe into the shop once or
twice a year (we had one for years).

Craig M is right - Assuming they pass the "infant mortality" stage,
todays electronics last about exactly as long as it takes for people to
*want* a new one - for better features or whatever reason.

Tony

Yes, there were a lot of "Tube changers" out there who called
themselves TV repairmen. At one time there were over 50 so called "TV
shops in Middletown Ohio. Only a few could really troubleshoot a TV set
with real problems, and they were the ones who were in business till a
few years ago. Now, there isn't one shop left in a town of over 50,000
people. In the '70s it cost around 10,000 to equip a van for TV service
calls, unless all you did was pick up the TV and haul it to the shop for
the bench techs to work on. I ran some TV shops in the late '70s and
saw the costs. It was over $100 in taxes and insurance just to open the
doors of a shop that didn't have a mortgage or rent payment. Then you
had to make enough money to pay the wages, buy parts, pay for the phone
and gasoline. Basically, you had to take in about 300 a day to keep the
doors open, and a TV service call was $17.50, for the trip and first
half hour, plus 17.50 per hour after that.

--
?

Michael A. Terrell
Central Florida

My Drake R8B tuning sometimes gets lost when I spin the knob fast.
I'll be going up 7.2, 7.3, 7.4, 7.2 See? I expect this is a pretty
common prob.

Ok so unit is going to go back to Drake for fix and I will tell them to
go thru whole unit and check it out.

Any idea what they will charge me for this?

I finally got around to fixing the encoder problem (erratic tuning) that's
been bothering me for awhile.

Removal of the encoder board from the front panel was fairly
straightforward; just time consuming. The inner and outer panel came apart
surprisingly easy and making the repair somewhat enjoyable---re-assembly was
just as easy.

My first attempt was to unsolder the encoder from the board. However, like
many of you, I finally I bent back the tabs of the encoder with a small
screwdriver to take it apart. Even though I had a replacement encoder it
was difficult to unsolder the part from the board---plated through holes!
It might be that replacement of the entire encoder would be required at some
later date anyway.

As I had mentioned in a previous post, I was interested in learning why the
encoder failed. After removal of the encoder wheel from the body of the
encoder I examined the contact surfaces under stereo microscope (Leica SZ-4)
at 40X magnification. I could plainly see what appeared to be normal wear
patterns in the conductive surfaces that matched the position of the contact
fingers in the mating part.

The contact fingers were examined next. Using similar magnification and
upon carefully rotation of the part, I could plainly see that the contact
points were worn through their silver plating and well into the brass base
metal. The contact surfaces were burnished to a bright, mirror finish.
Furthermore, the first two contact points were clean with a clear grease
residue while the third inner contact (electrical common?) had a dark
brown/black greasy residue about its contact surface.

With the realization that I rarely used the tuning knob I wanted to
understand why the wear on the contact fingers seemed, in my opinion,
excessive. I observed that the third contact finger (electrical common?),
the one with the dark residue, was in continuous electrical contact with the
wheel more so than the other two fingers that rode on the 'spokes' of the
wheel. Furthermore, the surface that the contact was moving against had a
rough surface consisting of striated tooling marks with uniform depth and
spacing that suggested the result of rough polishing or grinding. Close
study of the wear patterns on the wheel clearly revealed hills and valleys
and that the hills were the surfaces that had been worn into the wheel by
that contact finger but had not yet reached the depth of the valleys. It
was this observation that led me to think that the brown/black residue on
this particular contact was an accumulation of silver and brass particulate
from the contact finger and wheel that had oxidized and mixed with the
grease. The rough surface of the wheel was simply acting as an abrasive
surface and was wearing the contact points.

I thought I would reuse the old encoder and see how long it would last after
a bit of maintenance. I cleaned the encoder with electrical solvent cleaner
and with the help of a very fine brush I cleaned the contact fingers as
well. The parts were carefully blown dry then examined under the scope and
were found clean. A small drop of DeoxIT contact cleaner was placed on the
wheel surfaces then worked by pressing the assembly together and rotating
the wheel against the contacts.

There was another problem with the encoder that I need to take care of as
well. Ever since I got this receiver I had been bothered by the viscous,
squishy feel of the tuning knob. While I had the encoder opened I carefully
cleaned it of all grease with electrical cleaner. The designers of the
encoder had used a relatively large quantity to gain the damping action that
had bothered me. On the reverse side of the wheel (shaft end) the grease
was easily removed with a probe and the remainder was readily soluble in the
electrical solvent. However, before re-assembly, I placed a very light film
of fine grease on the shaft. After the front panel was replaced I placed a
small felt washer on the encoder shaft. The knob was positioned against the
felt washer to get the desired feel. Now the knob turns with a dry,
positive, precise, clean feel with no wobble or endplay. Furthermore, I
replaced the R8B knob with that of the R8---the aesthetic enhancement that
the old R8 knob adds to the receiver is remarkable!

While the front panel was detached from the chassis, I also removed all
controls and added a drop of DeoxIT into them and worked it in. The tone
control was beginning to get scratchy and I've had a problem with the volume
control in the past.

In the process of working on the front panel I learned how the readouts are
backlit---just a bunch of green LED's on a circuit board. I have always
been upset by the lime-green color of the display. Drake had been known for
decades for their use of a distinctive blue for illuminating the meter and
dial displays of their older equipment and I liked it very much. I guess
when the receiver was designed there weren't any blue or white LED's and
those that are available now are expensive. I intend to experiment with
blue and white LED's as well as blue filters. The closest filter color I
had on hand to match the Drake blue on my vintage pieces of Drake gear is
the blue tab on 3-ring binder notebook separators or hanging file tabs. I'
ll take a tab to the art supply shop and see if I can match it.

The receiver has been re-assembled and everything is working properly;
tuning is as it should be. It will be interesting to see how long the
repaired encoder lasts. I had the encoder replaced under warranty repair by
Drake twice before.

In summary; apparently the encoder failed as a result of intermittent
electrical contact resulting from dirty contact surfaces. Others have
suggested contact bounce and poor electrical design. My personal opinion,
although based on this one example and comments from others, suggests that
the encoder is poorly designed or not able to take the continuous wear and
tear it experiences in its application as a main tuning control for a radio
receiver. Quite possibly it should be replaced with a part more suited to
the task.

[Note: It's been three years since I cleaned the encoder---there has been no
recurrence of the problem.]

RG

The receiver has been re-assembled and everything is working properly;
tuning is as it should be. It will be interesting to see how long the
repaired encoder lasts. I had the encoder replaced under warranty repair by
Drake twice before.

So this is the third repair of the same component on a radio that costs
over $1,000?? Wow - not exactly confidence inspiring.

In article ,
dxAce wrote:

wrote:

So,if they charge you two hours of work on the radio and there will be
shipping & handling charges too,it will cost you over
$200.00.Hopefully,they can repair it for you in one quarter hour.

Plus, if they hold true to what they used to do, they charge you for a new box
to ship it back to you in.

I never could figure that one out but they always said it was for insurence
purposes.

Probably past fights between various customers and the gorillas at the
"Parcel Delivery" company. Wouldn't take too many $1500 radios
smashed up, and then have the claims adjuster say that they couldn't
tell where is was smashed up, because of the old box, to cause problems
with their reputation. Drake's reputation, I mean.

Mark Zenier
Googleproofaddress(account:mzenier provider:eskimo domain:com)

Some vehicles have little thin flat "wires" in the windshield and rear
windows and mirrors for helping to melt ice and sleet that gets on there
in cold wet weather.Sometimes a break in the wires occurs and then there
is no more electrical contact.Auto parts stores sell repair kits to
repair broken contact areas.The repair kits will also work to repair
worn out electrical contact areas under the push buttons of radios and
many other things too such as remote control units and keyboards,etc.
cuhulin

On 11 Sep 2005 22:44:47 -0700, "RHF"
wrote:

For One and All,
.
First most people today are paying $30-$50 or more a month for
Cable TV with an Annual Cost of $360 to $600 or more a year.
.
So they do not think anything of spending that same amount
$360-$600 for a TV that will last 3, 5 or 7 Years.
.
At and average of 3-5 Hours Daily per Year that is 1100 to
1800 Hours of TV Viewing per Year :
You didn't factor in the billions of dollars of damage done to society
by Zombies who watch 5 hours of TV a day.

I don't ever want to give up my tv.I don't watch junk on my tv.I like
the old,old movies and history and science and discovery and travel
channels.
cuhulin

John S. wrote in message
oups.com...

The receiver has been re-assembled and everything is working properly;
tuning is as it should be. It will be interesting to see how long the
repaired encoder lasts. I had the encoder replaced under warranty
repair by
Drake twice before.

So this is the third repair of the same component on a radio that costs
over $1,000?? Wow - not exactly confidence inspiring.

Yes... Well... The topic (R8B) resulted in hundreds of posts... In my
opinion, the receiver was never developed to its full potential. I've had
mine since January, 1998 and I use it daily---it's on for 10 hours or more.
It needs to be re-aligned; it no longer zero beats WWV dead on like it did
new, the passband offset is centered at 1:00 O'Clock and the notch drifts.
The receiver was never worth what Drake was asking. I think a proper
purchase price would have been around $600 new.

RG

Thanks for all the nice replys to my post.

I am going to send it back to Drake and not whine about the price they
charge me. I realize all of the costs involved to repair sophisticated
gear. My comment about wishing I could make 100 bucks an hour in my
basement was just that. I wish I could make 100 bucks an hour in my
basement fixing radios. I would gladly leave the 9-5 behind me if I
could work on this type of gear all day out of my house.

73
Bob
N9NEO

On Tue, 13 Sep 2005 13:29:24 GMT, David wrote:

On 11 Sep 2005 22:44:47 -0700, "RHF"
wrote:

For One and All,
.
First most people today are paying $30-$50 or more a month for
Cable TV with an Annual Cost of $360 to $600 or more a year.
.
So they do not think anything of spending that same amount
$360-$600 for a TV that will last 3, 5 or 7 Years.
.
At and average of 3-5 Hours Daily per Year that is 1100 to
1800 Hours of TV Viewing per Year :
You didn't factor in the billions of dollars of damage done to society
by Zombies who watch 5 hours of TV a day.

It can happen with radio, too. As an example, I cite dxAce.