"Thomas Heger" wrote in message
...
Am 26.10.2011 00:48, schrieb SaPeIsMa:

"Thomas Heger" wrote in message
...
Am 21.10.2011 15:46, schrieb SaPeIsMa:



But there are more similarities: e.g. Jews and Muslims have
circumcision (what is a rare fact otherwise), do not eat pig and
practise (or practised) stoning (what is an extremely cruel and brutal
punishment).


OH wow
A bunch of desert people have the same health practices, which therefore
makes their religions similar.

No, I mean they are the same people. The religions are different of
course. But since they are the same people, these religious originate from
the same roots.


That's about as meaningful as claiming that fruits and vegetables are from
the same soil
An Oxymoron


A more recent example would be Catholics and Protestants. Both have the
same roots in Christianity, but they fought bitter and long lasting wars.
Germany was almost completely destroyed and depopulated through this, even
if they were all Christians.


The Catholic-Protestant wars were primarily power, politics and
geo-political control
Religion was just the justification.


Some thousand years ago, there was a religion in the area, were is now
Jerusalem. This religion was ancestor to all following religions from the
same roots. From this believe these religions have developed into their
current different forms. The roots have to be the same, since the
religions are in parts identical: use the same metaphors, stories,
characters and even locations.


You write a lot, but the useful content is really in short supply.



Circumcision is only one example or cultural identity of the people
addressed. It is - of course - not a 'healthy habit', but a (pseudo-)
religious practise.


Actually circumcision IS a healthy habit.
In an area where water is in short supply, it's far easier to avoid
infection of the penile glans by removing the foreskin.
It's also noted that removing the foreskin also reduces the incidence of
transmitted diseases as well



It's a bad thing - btw - because it changes the appearance of the human
body, that is intended to be as perfect as it is and not as humans want it
to be.


LOL
Tell us about the perfection of the appendix, which an kill you if it gets
inflamed and the ONLY way to avoid being killed by an inflamed appendix is
to excise it.



Christianity and Judaism share in total the bibles first part.

Christianity is 'modified Judaism' (through prophet) as Islam is.
Since 'modification' is a heretic crime, worth death penalty, these
religions hate each other since ancient times (for no apparent reason).


DOH ! again

Jesus was NO "prophet"
He was, according to the Christians, the Messiah predicted in the Old
Testament and also the Son of God

Islam says Jesus was a prophet. Jews do not mention him (since Judaism was
created earlier). Islam was created later, hence could mention him.
But the bible is ABOUT Jesus, not written by him. A prophet is someone,
who manages to write things down and tell that to the people. Apparently
Mohamed was a prophet (but I have only limited knowledge about Islam)

Muhammad, on the other hand was no prophet at all, he was a minor war
lord who wanted to extend his power by upgrading himself to a religious
prophet

I have no idea, from what sources prophets are chosen, but 'little
warlord' would not exclude him from such a position.


When the Christians rejected him, he started his own cult, a big part of
which is to kill just about anyone both inside and outside of his cult.
The COMPLETE ANTITHESIS of Christianity..

Actually the Christians killed a few people, too. They really love to
kill: Muslims, Indians, Africans, each other ...


YOU need to read up on history and do a body count
Compared to the Muslims, the only group that has killed a larger number of
people are the Communists.