K7ITM wrote:
I certainly do NOT accept that the context of this
thread is amateur transmitters--

Granted, the thread drifted away from the subject line
which has little to do with transmitters, but amateur
transmitters are what the entire Maxwell-Bruene
brouhaha is all about.

We already have a special case where a signal generator
plus circulator yields everything we need to know. One
more special case doesn't add much even if it works
which is questionable.

We do not have a valid generalized case that covers
amateur radio transmitters. IMO, that's what the
brouhaha is all about.
--
73, Cecil http://www.w5dxp.com