Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#22
|
|||
|
|||
Dish reflector
On Apr 10, 6:00*pm, "Dale Parfitt" wrote:
*That antenna was when I used an old parabolic satellite dish which was unsuitable. Scanning past antenna papers point to the use of a cone shape similar to a horn of 2 metres diameter produces better results. The antenna needs a longer mast so at the moment I can't compare F/R. Either way, with the radiator within the reflector envelope it is difficult to understand what creates a rearward lobe regardles of scale or frequency of use with respect to receive. At the moment I see nothing that points away from the Rutherford particle experiments with foil .ie penetration when at right angles , deflection at other angles. As usual Art you are avoiding answering the questions and choose to confuse the issues with you own preconceived ideas and terminology. The fact that the feed is totally within the "reflector envelope" tells you or us nothing about sidelobes and edge taper. I really don't think you want answers, but I'll try once mo 1. What frequency 2. What is the dish diameter 3. What is the dish focal length to diameter ratio (F/D) Dale W4OP I am not avoiding questions, just those that appear irrelevant, but here goes Anything to make you happy, this should be interesting how you use these answers with respect to the posted question 1 160 metres upto 2 metres, tunable 2 2 metres 3 Doesn't have a focal length, it is an end fed ( series connection) helix antenna. At least to the best of my knowledge which is why I posed the question Hopefully we will all stay on subject and not get side tracked. I will leave it to others to respond to Richard when they determine what he is talking about. |
#23
|
|||
|
|||
Dish reflector
On Fri, 10 Apr 2009 16:49:31 -0700 (PDT), Art Unwin
wrote: 1. What frequency 2. What is the dish diameter 3. What is the dish focal length to diameter ratio (F/D) I am not avoiding questions, just those that appear irrelevant, 20 postings to get to the point (not unanticipated, however) which Art calls "irrelevant." As for those answers? 1 160 metres upto 2 metres, tunable 2 2 metres Hence the wholesale disregard for first principles in size vs. wavelength. Elementary analysis need not go any further when failure is so obviously designed in. 3 Doesn't have a focal length, it is an end fed ( series connection) helix antenna. -Well, maybe not obvious to everyone.- But why don't we chalk this design up to S U C C E S S and call it a thread? If this bier gets anymore wreaths tossed onto it, it will kill the pallbearers. 73's Richard Clark, KB7QHC |
#24
|
|||
|
|||
Dish reflector
"Art Unwin" wrote: -drivel snip- In a way I knew that Richard would pile up his postings of olde english prose in the shape of riddles that provide nothing, But one has to get used to him and his pals kb9....and others who smear this group with a foul smell as they are wired very differently from the rest of us. Art-let me point out the obvious.... unless your license has expired, then you ARE a kb9!!!!! Have a nice weekend, glad to see you back posting on the NG. Things were dull without you. Mike W5CHR Memphis |
#25
|
|||
|
|||
Dish reflector
On Apr 10, 7:19*pm, Richard Clark wrote:
On Fri, 10 Apr 2009 16:49:31 -0700 (PDT), Art Unwin wrote: 1. What frequency 2. What is the dish diameter 3. What is the dish focal length to diameter ratio (F/D) I am not avoiding questions, just those that appear irrelevant, 20 postings to get to the point (not unanticipated, however) which Art calls "irrelevant." As for those answers? 1 160 metres upto 2 metres, tunable 2 2 metres Hence the wholesale disregard for first principles in size vs. wavelength. *Elementary analysis need not go any further when failure is so obviously designed in. * 3 Doesn't have a focal length, it is an end fed ( series connection) helix antenna. -Well, maybe not obvious to everyone.- But why don't we chalk this design up to S U C C E S S and call it a thread? *If this bier gets anymore wreaths tossed onto it, it will kill the pallbearers. 73's Richard Clark, KB7QHC The posting is about dishes not antennas. I have not read about a dish that does not emit signals to the rear. Now I have built one and find to my surprize that it does accept signals from the rear ! All very simple, the radiator is resting at the bottom of a cone and the top of the radiator does not stick out beyond the reflector. Since you do not know what you are talking about and intent is to disrupt this thread why on earth are you muttering about nothing at length? Simple question has been posed and obviously you do not know the answers that antenna engineering knowledge would provide as you are not an engineer but a actor or actress by day and by night. My question remains unanswered after all these posts.How do signals arrive or depart from the rear of a dish or horn? We all know that you don't know the answer but there are qualified engineers in this group who possibly doand willing to share. |
#26
|
|||
|
|||
Dish reflector
The posting is about dishes not antennas. I have not read about a dish
that does not emit signals to the rear. Now I have built one and find to my surprize that it does accept signals from the rear ! All very simple, the radiator is resting at the bottom of a cone and the top of the radiator does not stick out beyond the reflector. Since you do not know what you are talking about and intent is to disrupt this thread why on earth are you muttering about nothing at length? Simple question has been posed and obviously you do not know the answers that antenna engineering knowledge would provide as you are not an engineer but a actor or actress by day and by night. My question remains unanswered after all these posts.How do signals arrive or depart from the rear of a dish or horn? We all know that you don't know the answer but there are qualified engineers in this group who possibly doand willing to share. Your antenna has nothing to do with dish antennas, bu rather plane reflectors (of which yours is way too small as Richard pointed out). I know we cannot change your opinion or teach you anything- so I am out of here. Dale W4OP |
#27
|
|||
|
|||
Dish reflector
Art Unwin wrote:
The posting is about dishes not antennas. I have not read about a dish that does not emit signals to the rear. Now I have built one and find to my surprize that it does accept signals from the rear ! All very simple, the radiator is resting at the bottom of a cone and the top of the radiator does not stick out beyond the reflector. Since you do not Well, to start with Art, a cone reflector doesn't meet the definition of a dish antenna. I'm sorry, but they just aren't the same thing. I surprizzzed you missed the difference. tom K0TAR |
#28
|
|||
|
|||
Dish reflector
Tom Ring wrote:
Art Unwin wrote: snip tom K0TAR Jimmie I just couldn't resist, just this once. tom K0TAR |
#29
|
|||
|
|||
Dish reflector
On Apr 10, 7:38*pm, "Mike Lucas" wrote:
"Art Unwin" wrote: -drivel snip- *In a way I knew that Richard would pile up his postings of olde english prose in the shape of riddles that provide nothing, But one has to get used to him and his pals kb9....and others who smear this group with a foul smell as they are wired very differently from the rest of us. Art-let me point out the obvious.... unless your license has expired, then you ARE a kb9!!!!! Have a nice weekend, glad to see you back posting on the NG. Things were dull without you. Mike W5CHR Memphis Oh, I have just popped in and saw Richard up to to his old tricks with Cecil. I don't really expect a satisfactory answer. All on this group denied it was possible to expand Gaussian law of statics to the laws of Maxwell so there is nobody with a real feel with respect to radiation, and of course it shows! Same goes for the nature of Richard no matter how he tries to hide things. The KB9 station and his foul mouth friends are what I was referring to and is why they are pleading for a moderator for this newsgroup. Not really the type I wish to associate with. When the group deviate from the question at hand is when I leave as they all eventually do. Within the next few hours they will want to ask questions about you know what to cover their ignorance and Richard will come prancing in again with his long leg mesh underware acting out a shakespere scene . A few years on a ship tends to change how you look at life so that he walks in the snow with his foot prints in a straight line so that the torso wobbles and then there is the way that he acts and speak. My question is still there and regardles of the number of postings made I doubt that it will be answered. This newsgroup becomes dull when radio goes out the window and personal attacks begin so one really gets what he wishes for when they hang around. |
#30
|
|||
|
|||
Dish reflector
On Apr 10, 8:13*pm, "Dale Parfitt" wrote:
*The posting is about dishes not antennas. I have not read about a dish that does not emit signals to the rear. Now I have built one and find to my surprize that it does accept signals from the rear ! All very simple, the radiator is resting at the bottom of a cone and the top of the radiator does not stick out beyond the reflector. Since you do not know what you are talking about and intent is to disrupt this thread why on earth are you muttering about nothing at length? Simple question has been posed and obviously you do not know the answers that antenna engineering knowledge would provide as you are not an engineer but a actor or actress by day and by night. *My question remains unanswered after all these posts.How do signals arrive or depart from the rear of a dish or horn? We all know that you don't know the answer but there are qualified engineers in this group who possibly doand willing to share. Your antenna has nothing to do with dish antennas, bu rather plane reflectors (of which yours is way too small as Richard pointed out). I know we cannot change your opinion or teach you anything- so I am out of here. Dale W4OP Dale, my response above was with respect to Richard not you, but I did know you would run eventually. Study the math of Maxwell and Gauss before you decide to take up teaching. |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Dish Network "500" dish with two LNBs | Homebrew | |||
Kenwood reflector | General | |||
Vet. with a reflector | Antenna | |||
Reflector for Hammarlund | Boatanchors | |||
Reflector for Hammarlund | Boatanchors |