RadioBanter

RadioBanter (https://www.radiobanter.com/)
-   Antenna (https://www.radiobanter.com/antenna/)
-   -   Disconne Question (https://www.radiobanter.com/antenna/147482-disconne-question.html)

Robert11[_2_] October 24th 09 09:51 PM

Disconne Question
 
Hello,

For a Disconne in the attic (for vhf/uhf), receiving only, do you think a
wet roof from rain would make
a "meaningful" difference in reception ?

Bob



Richard Clark October 24th 09 11:27 PM

Disconne Question
 
No.

73's
Richard Clark, KB7QHC

PH5E October 25th 09 10:18 PM

Disconne Question
 
Robert11 wrote:
Hello,

For a Disconne in the attic (for vhf/uhf), receiving only, do you think a
wet roof from rain would make
a "meaningful" difference in reception ?

Bob



Depends on the type of roof and frequency you're working. If the roof
absorbs (small amounts of) water, or if water can stand on the roof,
then I'd say: Yes. Wet trees can also absorb radio waves better then dry
ones. Don't see why roofs are any different.
HF will suffer most, VHF and UHF will probably not be affected as much.
But I've spoken to a local 2m amateur with indoor antenna who claimed to
notice the difference between wet and dry.

--
RigReference.com - Reference guide for ham radio equipment
http://rigreference.com/

n9zas October 25th 09 11:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PH5E (Post 691765)
Robert11 wrote:
Hello,

For a Disconne in the attic (for vhf/uhf), receiving only, do you think a
wet roof from rain would make
a "meaningful" difference in reception ?

Bob



Depends on the type of roof and frequency you're working. If the roof
absorbs (small amounts of) water, or if water can stand on the roof,
then I'd say: Yes. Wet trees can also absorb radio waves better then dry
ones. Don't see why roofs are any different.
HF will suffer most, VHF and UHF will probably not be affected as much.
But I've spoken to a local 2m amateur with indoor antenna who claimed to
notice the difference between wet and dry.

--
RigReference.com - Reference guide for ham radio equipment
http://rigreference.com/

Other than the noise floor being a little lower when it rains,not really. You'll get varying opinions on this I'm sure,but I notice little if any difference.
N9ZAS

Bill[_4_] October 26th 09 01:39 AM

Disconne Question
 

. Wet trees can also absorb radio waves better then dry
ones.


Trees have vascular systems so are "wet" all the time. Dry trees are
dead trees,

http://www.biology4kids.com/files/pl...lemphloem.html

tom October 26th 09 12:19 PM

Disconne Question
 
Bill wrote:
. Wet trees can also absorb radio waves better then dry
ones.


Trees have vascular systems so are "wet" all the time. Dry trees are
dead trees,

http://www.biology4kids.com/files/pl...lemphloem.html


You must live where it never freezes. The difference between summer
and winter on 2m and up is certainly noticeable and measurable here in
Minnesota.

tom
K0TAR

tom October 26th 09 12:35 PM

Disconne Question
 
Bill wrote:
. Wet trees can also absorb radio waves better then dry
ones.


Trees have vascular systems so are "wet" all the time. Dry trees are
dead trees,

http://www.biology4kids.com/files/pl...lemphloem.html


Oops, forgot to say that water, even with the contaminants of life in
it, doesn't conduct very well when frozen.

tom
K0TAR

Bill[_4_] October 27th 09 02:31 AM

Disconne Question
 
On Oct 26, 8:19*am, tom wrote:
Bill wrote:
. Wet trees can also absorb radio waves better then dry
ones.


Trees have vascular systems so are "wet" all the time. Dry trees are
dead trees,


http://www.biology4kids.com/files/pl...lemphloem.html


You must live where it never freezes.


The original question had to do with rain, did it not? Not ice.

* The difference between summer
and winter on 2m and up is certainly noticeable and measurable here in
Minnesota.

tom
K0TAR


And the difference is attributed to what?




Bill[_4_] October 27th 09 02:34 AM

Disconne Question
 
On Oct 26, 8:35*am, tom wrote:
Bill wrote:
. Wet trees can also absorb radio waves better then dry
ones.


Trees have vascular systems so are "wet" all the time. Dry trees are
dead trees,


http://www.biology4kids.com/files/pl...lemphloem.html


Oops, forgot to say that water, even with the contaminants of life in
it, doesn't conduct very well when frozen.

tom
K0TAR


The original question had to do with interference with radio
reception, not with conduction.


tom October 27th 09 02:40 AM

Disconne Question
 
Bill wrote:
On Oct 26, 8:19 am, tom wrote:
Bill wrote:
. Wet trees can also absorb radio waves better then dry
ones.
Trees have vascular systems so are "wet" all the time. Dry trees are
dead trees,
http://www.biology4kids.com/files/pl...lemphloem.html

You must live where it never freezes.


The original question had to do with rain, did it not? Not ice.


I was responding to "wet" versus "dead".


The difference between summer
and winter on 2m and up is certainly noticeable and measurable here in
Minnesota.



And the difference is attributed to what?


Very very simple physics.

tom
K0TAR


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:20 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
RadioBanter.com