gareth wrote:
Relying on someone's NEC program to number crunch to
produce the answer 42 is not the same as understanding
what is going on as an aid to didactification of novices.

Except that antenna analysis is much more complex than a single number.

NEC is the PERFECT learning tool for antennas as one can almose instantly
see the three dimensional pattern, the gain, the losses, the complex
impedance, etc.

I hardly think doing a huge number of complex calculations by hand is
more informative than letting a computer do the calculations.

The goal is to learn how an antenna works, not develop proficiency in
manual 3 dimensional calculus.

Of course you do have a dog in this race as NEC easily shows much of
what you say is utter, arm waving, nonsense.



--
Jim Pennino

wrote in message
...

Of course you do have a dog in this race as NEC easily shows much of
what you say is utter, arm waving, nonsense.

May I commend to you, early, the mature and civil approach to international
debate which will come when you grow up?

gareth wrote:
wrote in message
...

Of course you do have a dog in this race as NEC easily shows much of
what you say is utter, arm waving, nonsense.

May I commend to you, early, the mature and civil approach to international
debate which will come when you grow up?

May I commend to you that you suck it up and admit much of what you have
said so far is utter, arm waving, nonsense?

If you have equations and numbers to show otherwise...




--
Jim Pennino

wrote in message
...
wrote in message
...

Of course you do have a dog in this race as NEC easily shows much of
what you say is utter, arm waving, nonsense.
May I commend to you that you suck it up and admit much of what you have
said so far is utter, arm waving, nonsense?
If you have equations and numbers to show otherwise...

May I commend to you, early, the mature and civil approach to international
debate which will come when you grow up?

gareth wrote:
wrote in message
...
wrote in message
...

Of course you do have a dog in this race as NEC easily shows much of
what you say is utter, arm waving, nonsense.
May I commend to you that you suck it up and admit much of what you have
said so far is utter, arm waving, nonsense?
If you have equations and numbers to show otherwise...

May I commend to you, early, the mature and civil approach to international
debate which will come when you grow up?

Still absolutely nothing to say about the utility of NEC as a learning
tool?

Still trying to change the subject to how offended you are that your
arm waving nonsense was pointed out?



--
Jim Pennino

wrote in message
...
gareth wrote:
wrote in message
...
wrote in message
...

Of course you do have a dog in this race as NEC easily shows much of
what you say is utter, arm waving, nonsense.
May I commend to you that you suck it up and admit much of what you have
said so far is utter, arm waving, nonsense?
If you have equations and numbers to show otherwise...
May I commend to you, early, the mature and civil approach to
international
debate which will come when you grow up?
Still absolutely nothing to say about the utility of NEC as a learning
tool?
Still trying to change the subject to how offended you are that your
arm waving nonsense was pointed out?

Stupid boy

gareth wrote:
wrote in message
...
gareth wrote:
wrote in message
...
wrote in message
...

Of course you do have a dog in this race as NEC easily shows much of
what you say is utter, arm waving, nonsense.
May I commend to you that you suck it up and admit much of what you have
said so far is utter, arm waving, nonsense?
If you have equations and numbers to show otherwise...
May I commend to you, early, the mature and civil approach to
international
debate which will come when you grow up?
Still absolutely nothing to say about the utility of NEC as a learning
tool?
Still trying to change the subject to how offended you are that your
arm waving nonsense was pointed out?

Stupid boy

Gas bag old man.


--
Jim Pennino

gareth wrote:
wrote in message
...
gareth wrote:
wrote in message
...
wrote in message
...

Of course you do have a dog in this race as NEC easily shows much of
what you say is utter, arm waving, nonsense.
May I commend to you that you suck it up and admit much of what you have
said so far is utter, arm waving, nonsense?
If you have equations and numbers to show otherwise...
May I commend to you, early, the mature and civil approach to
international
debate which will come when you grow up?
Still absolutely nothing to say about the utility of NEC as a learning
tool?
Still trying to change the subject to how offended you are that your
arm waving nonsense was pointed out?

Stupid boy

Still absolutely nothing to say about the utility of NEC as a learning
tool, Colonel Blimp?



--
Jim Pennino

gareth wrote:
wrote in message
...

Of course you do have a dog in this race as NEC easily shows much of
what you say is utter, arm waving, nonsense.

May I commend to you, early, the mature and civil approach to international
debate which will come when you grow up?

I notice you have absolutely nothing to say about the utility of NEC
as a learngin tool...


--
Jim Pennino