Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
Aluminum tubing for vertical antenna
I took scrap pieces of aluminum tubing lying around, not being particularly
careful of sizes as along they fit snugly into adjacent pieces when they were slotted. I used hose clamps. I made it 33ft and 3 inches tall (1/4 wave on 40). It has 32 radials of various lengths for the non-WARC ham bands 40 meters and higher. 16 of them are 34 feet long for 40. SWR on 40 meters is 1.2 to 1 without any adjustment at 7100. The vertical covers the entire band. I use a Palstar AT1500CV transmatch on other bands and run 700 watts when needed. I can work anything I can hear and I work tons of DX. The antenna is very quiet for a vertical. The Palstar has no problem matching this vertical on all bands 40 through 6 meters including WARC though 12 meters is the trickiest. Works much DX on all bands whenever I try Peter I Island, Kiribati, etc., though I use other antennas on bands other than 40 cut appropriately. Cost of the antenna was $0.00. I used scrap tubing, scrap #12 or thicker radial wire, leftover rope for 3 guys at 18 feet, leftover 4BTV base. This antenna has been up for months on a hill at 1100 feet and survived 80 mph plus gusts. "Hank Zoeller" wrote in message ... Hello everyone, I'm contemplating putting up a vertical antenna for HF use. I'm looking at an approximate height of 30 feet or so. I am thinking of using aluminum tubing (0.058" wall) in a 'telescoping' manner. Here are my questions (so far): 1) Diameter. For wind resistance, should I start with something like 1 inch diameter and work down to 3/8 inch? Would the antenna be stronger if I started with 2 inch diameter and worked down to 1-3/8 inch? It would seem to me that the larger diameter might be better able to withstand wind but it would also offer more resistance to wind possibly negating the additional strength. But, I have no experience to draw from. So, fat or slim? 2) I am planning a set of guy ropes at about the 12 foot level, a bit over 1/3 height. Is there a better height for guy ropes? I can put as much concrete in the ground as I like, and a very robust mount system is possible. Is there any way to make an unguyed 30 footer that isn't a tower form factor? Something like making the bottom 12 feet or so from 2 inch diameter, 1/4 inch wall tubing and then light weight tubing from there up to full height? -- 73, Hank |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
Aluminum tubing for vertical antenna
Jozef wrote:
I took scrap pieces of aluminum tubing lying around, not being particularly careful of sizes as along they fit snugly into adjacent pieces when they were slotted. I used hose clamps. I made it 33ft and 3 inches tall (1/4 wave on 40)... The Palstar has no problem matching this vertical on all bands 40 through 6 meters including WARC though 12 meters is the trickiest. That antenna is 5/8 wavelength on ~17.5 MHz. Above 21 MHz, most of the radiation is lost at a high elevation angle. Such an antenna is a poor performer on 15m, 12m, 10m, and 6m. Matching doesn't mean much for a monopole appreciably longer than 5/8 wavelength. -- 73, Cecil http://www.qsl.net/w5dxp |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
Aluminum tubing for vertical antenna
Cecil Moore wrote:
Jozef wrote: I took scrap pieces of aluminum tubing lying around, not being particularly careful of sizes as along they fit snugly into adjacent pieces when they were slotted. I used hose clamps. I made it 33ft and 3 inches tall (1/4 wave on 40)... The Palstar has no problem matching this vertical on all bands 40 through 6 meters including WARC though 12 meters is the trickiest. That antenna is 5/8 wavelength on ~17.5 MHz. Above 21 MHz, most of the radiation is lost at a high elevation angle. Such an antenna is a poor performer on 15m, 12m, 10m, and 6m. Matching doesn't mean much for a monopole appreciably longer than 5/8 wavelength. -- 73, Cecil http://www.qsl.net/w5dxp I have an almost identical vertical with a relay controlled loading coil I switch in for 160 and 80M and a SGC tuner. Works great 160 to 30M. Marginal at 20M and goes to poor from there up. -- Jim Pennino Remove .spam.sux to reply. |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
Aluminum tubing for vertical antenna
I understand that which is why in my original post I said, "Works much DX on
all bands whenever I try Peter I Island, Kiribati, etc., though I use other antennas on bands other than 40 cut appropriately." Perhaps, you missed that? Theory granted, you're also make a case against success. It works. Though as you suggest, with handicaps. "Cecil Moore" wrote in message .com... Jozef wrote: I took scrap pieces of aluminum tubing lying around, not being particularly careful of sizes as along they fit snugly into adjacent pieces when they were slotted. I used hose clamps. I made it 33ft and 3 inches tall (1/4 wave on 40)... The Palstar has no problem matching this vertical on all bands 40 through 6 meters including WARC though 12 meters is the trickiest. That antenna is 5/8 wavelength on ~17.5 MHz. Above 21 MHz, most of the radiation is lost at a high elevation angle. Such an antenna is a poor performer on 15m, 12m, 10m, and 6m. Matching doesn't mean much for a monopole appreciably longer than 5/8 wavelength. -- 73, Cecil http://www.qsl.net/w5dxp |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
Aluminum tubing for vertical antenna
Roy Lewallen wrote:
For about 20 - 25 years I've had four verticals of about 33 foot height in my back yard. They're free standing, no guys. They went through one wind storm with gusts in the 80 mph range, and all other weather, without damage. Each is made of three pieces of telescoping 6061-T6 tubing, 1-1/4, 1-1/8, and 1 inch diameter. [trimmed] Roy, Thank you very much. There's nothing like tapping the experience of others. I'm really happy to hear I can build a freestanding vertical! (But, I'll buy some spare aluminum anyway..) -- 73, Hank |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
Aluminum tubing for vertical antenna
Jozef wrote:
I neglected to provide the following links: http://www.metaphoria.us/hamradio/40monoband.htm for the 40 meter monobander vertical http://www.metaphoria.us/hamradio/4BTV.htm for the base with radials. The radials are now covered by grass that I mow with a hand manual non-powered Scott's push mower. Jozef, What did you use for staples for the radials? Thanks, -- 73, Hank |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
Aluminum tubing for vertical antenna
Hank,
Just wanted to add that you don't need 1/4 inch wall stuff anywhere in a 33 foot vertical. If you have it lying around you could use it, but the extra weight really isn't worth it. Same for reinforcing by thickening the tubing on the inside. A hollow tube 2" in diameter with 0.058" walls is about 3 times stiffer than a SOLID 1" rod. Now, strength and stiffness are two different things, but you're better taking the aluminum and making a fairly thin wall tube of large diameter if you're trying to make a strong, stiff element. For the price of one 12 foot 1/4" wall 2" tube you can buy the whole vertical in 2" 0.058 wall tubing and the next telescoping size for joints. 1/4" wall would be good if you're going to guy it and put a tribander on top! I'd go with Roy's vertical design, in fact. My antenna was a mess of found aluminum, tent poles, etc. Might have even been 7/8" now that I think of it. This means that Roy's bottom section, if 0.058 wall 1.25" diameter 6061 was at LEAST 3 times as stiff as my 7/8" OD 3/4" ID 1/16" wall stuff, and that's assuming I was using a good, stiff grade of aluminum, which I wasn't. Incidentally, Cecil, I think the 12 footers are more expensive because you can UPS ship 6 footers anywhere and can't do that with 12 footers... it may be that it's just cheaper to keep the 6 footers in stock because the market is bigger. Could also be that it's cheaper for TX Towers to get them in .... dunno. It's too bad though, 12 foot continuous sections would be good for this sort of thing. 73, Dan |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
Aluminum tubing for vertical antenna
|
#19
|
|||
|
|||
Aluminum tubing for vertical antenna
"Hank Zoeller" wrote in message ... Hello everyone, I'm contemplating putting up a vertical antenna for HF use. I'm looking at an approximate height of 30 feet or so. I am thinking of using aluminum tubing (0.058" wall) in a 'telescoping' manner. Here are my questions (so far): 1) Diameter. For wind resistance, should I start with something like 1 inch diameter and work down to 3/8 inch? Would the antenna be stronger if I started with 2 inch diameter and worked down to 1-3/8 inch? It would seem to me that the larger diameter might be better able to withstand wind but it would also offer more resistance to wind possibly negating the additional strength. But, I have no experience to draw from. So, fat or slim? 2) I am planning a set of guy ropes at about the 12 foot level, a bit over 1/3 height. Is there a better height for guy ropes? I can put as much concrete in the ground as I like, and a very robust mount system is possible. Is there any way to make an unguyed 30 footer that isn't a tower form factor? Something like making the bottom 12 feet or so from 2 inch diameter, 1/4 inch wall tubing and then light weight tubing from there up to full height? -- 73, Hank http://www.valcom.ca/Guelph/products...b-u_photo.html This is built for navy shipboard use so it may be "scary expensive." These are virtually indestructible. You have to hit one with a crane boom to break it. It is exactly what you described in your last paragraph. This size whip covers 2 - 30 MHz with a tuner. The Navy has used many 35-foot whips over the years. There were five-section versions, but any you found now would probably be too corroded to be of use. |
#20
|
|||
|
|||
Aluminum tubing for vertical antenna
Sal M. Onella wrote:
http://www.valcom.ca/Guelph/products...b-u_photo.html This is built for navy shipboard use so it may be "scary expensive." These are virtually indestructible. You have to hit one with a crane boom to break it. It is exactly what you described in your last paragraph. This size whip covers 2 - 30 MHz with a tuner. The Navy has used many 35-foot whips over the years. There were five-section versions, but any you found now would probably be too corroded to be of use. Actually, I *did* find one of those things! http://www.american-milspec.com/p961.html Alas, it's a bit too tall for my use. I'm thinking of using a 26' whip with a remote coupler (Harris RF-601) for operating from 40 through 15 meters. Or, I might go to a 30' whip for ops on 60 through 18 meters. I haven't made up my mind yet although I'm leaning toward the 26' version. If I go that route I might pick up a commercial, little brother of that massive Navy style whip - the Shakespeare 5300. It's sold as a 28' whip but it's actually 26' as they use the bottom two feet for a mounting sleeve. It's made for shipboard use but is substantially lighter than the Navy 35' whip. It's only 2-3/8" in diameter, for example.. Time is a precious commodity, at the moment, but I still might roll my own from Texas Towers Aluminum. 73, -- HZ |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Bose Wave Radio - What's Your Opinion ? | Shortwave | |||
Idine Ghoreishian -by- Idine Ghoreishian { The SPGC Antenna by RHF } | Shortwave | |||
No CounterPoise - Portable Antenna System | Shortwave | |||
Workman BS-1 Dipole Antenna = Easy Mod to make it a Mini-Windom Antenna ! | Shortwave | |||
LongWire Antenna | Shortwave |