Howdy Hank,

I've been designing switch mode magnetics for about
thirty years now. The more I learn the less I know.
It's true that the principles are well known but the
implementation is a morass of compromises. At the
power level many of my designs operate at, second
and third order effects can suddenly become serious
and unexpected design complications. Some people
enjoy puzzles. I guess that's why I like designing
this sort of stuff.

I've worked on a lot of weird stuff, big cap charging
supplies, pulse compressors, very high voltage or high
current, and tiny stuff with extremely low noise outputs.
But I don't have much experience with line frequency
magnetics beyond EMI filters. As you say there's
not much call for it now. But unfettered by
all the weak components the big iron can support
amazing overloads, so I think there's still a place
for it. At least for now. The cost of steel and
copper (and the transportation costs) for such heavy
beasts is certainly making them increasingly less
attractive.

Lately I've been working on equipment in the 10KW-60KW
output range switching at 75KHz range. The whole system
weighs much less than just the line frequency transformer
that would be required alone.

The only big iron guys I know are now retired or dead.
And the companies I've dealt with that make that stuff
tend to have very little engineering staff, not much new
going on, (other than some efficiency improvements from
amorphous cores) they just crank out the product in cook
book fashion. I think nuances of it may soon be a lost.


73


"Henry Kolesnik" wrote in
:

Hey Grump
A transformer is one of the simplest electrical machines and pretty well
understood in the classical design but when some of the parameters are
changed we don't have much experience or investigation and probably
wont. Hot swappable rectifier modules have made transformer based
rectifiers uneconomical kinda like carburetors and fuel injection. If
you have the time, check with some of the old time designers of
transformer rectifiers. Let me now what you find out. I had some notes
but those are long gone.
Hank