About Us

Michael Coslo · **July 23, 2007 ARS License Numbers**

wrote:

Now suppose RBB had included things like a slice of CW-only space for
the CW ops, a slice of no-data space for the 'phone ops, and a slice
of "all modes" space for everybody. The result might have been very
different.

The big mistake ARRL (and CTT, and many others) make is that they
don't really know how popular their proposals are *before* submitting
them to FCC.

Whatever is the point of *any* amateur radio group submitting a Part
97 proposal that generates 70, 80, 90% negative comments? All that
does is annoy FCC, IMHO.

The way I see it is that indeed the proposal was a big mistake. The
folks who were all about the robot stations effectively took over the
process, and hoped to push things through with their agenda intact.

This is not an unusual thing. Many different groups see their own
interests as paramount to the "big picture" in Ham radio (though it
isn't exclusive to the ARS) I've sat through lectures from Emergency
Operation fans on how amateur radio MUST change to acommodate their
particular view. Pro contesters/anti contesters, the different folks
involved all have a vision of what the service needs to be.

In the case of the RBB, the big picture was circumvented, and the result
was predictable and hams did their job. Some people look at it as a
failure. I look at as a shining success. A bad idea was beat down.

Of course, after being chased around the bands by some of those stations
while trying to enjoy some psk31, I suppose that would be natural on my
part. ;^)

- 73 de Mike KB3EIA -

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version	Search this Thread: Advanced Search
Display Modes
Switch to Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Threaded Mode

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
June 24, 2007 ARS License Numbers	[email protected]	Moderated	5	June 30th 07 06:08 PM
May 22, 2007 ARS License Numbers	[email protected]	Moderated	7	May 26th 07 03:34 PM
April 22, 2007 ARS License Numbers	[email protected]	Moderated	0	April 25th 07 01:54 PM
March 9 2007 License Numbers	[email protected]	Moderated	32	April 3rd 07 07:47 PM
March 22, 2007 License Numbers	[email protected]	Moderated	0	March 24th 07 02:04 AM

Menu

About Us