Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
There's a fundamental problem in making a scale model of an antenna to
determine loss -- the wire conductivity has to be scaled with frequency. Of course, the wire diameter can be changed from the normally scaled size in order to create the same loss, but then the antenna might behave differently. It's not clear to me how you could get quantitative data from measurements in a styrofoam container. Let's say you put 100 watts into the antenna for five minutes and the temperature rise (of the coil? helical winding? air?) was 10 degrees C. How would you calculate the loss or efficiency from that information? Roy Lewallen, W7EL Jerry Martes wrote: Youve gotten too refined. I mostly know about basic antenna theory and modeling. But building a VHF model of a 40 meter antenna with #12 copper wire wound around a 4 inch mandril might be impractical. But, if the "wonder antenna" is small enough to be enclosed (mostly) in something transparent to the RF but not to the thermal thats generated by any I^2* R losses, wouldnt the temperture rise inside the enclosure give a decent indication of efficiency? If this "wonder antenna" designer claims to be able to shape the radiation pattern with an antenna significantly shorter that a 1/4 wave stub, He really has something. I suspect that the something he has is mental illness. I've been following this info on the RI antenna and have considered it to be so 'snake oilish' that it would never see the light of an auditorium. Your post about attending the lecture made me wonder if anyone asked about *any* simple (approximations) measurements like the styrofoam radome to get some idea of the I^2*R power lost in the antenna. If he has an antenna, and a transmitter and enough room to build a foam igloo it seems that alot of data on efficiency could be obtained. If I had any interest in describing an antenna I'd built, I'd at least use an infared thermometer on the section of the antenna suspected as being the most lossy. Jerry |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Inverted ground plane antenna: compared with normal GP and low dipole. | Antenna | |||
QST Article: An Easy to Build, Dual-Band Collinear Antenna | Antenna | |||
HF Vertical design(s) | Antenna | |||
Poor vertical performance on metal sheet roof - comments? | Antenna |