A question is what the consensus is as to which of the above feeds
would be
the better?

Easiest way to find out is to try them. It depends on the path used,
but overall, I'd probably put my money on the "T" vertical setup being
the best. Neither just the ground, or the two radials are gonna be dx
busters, but they will work well enough to get on the air. If you run
it as
a dipole, the ground isn't much of an issue. But as a T vertical, it
is...
MK