| Home |
| Search |
| Today's Posts |
|
#11
|
|||
|
|||
|
KØHB wrote:
wrote "Old Ironsides" is a museum piece. A fully operational museum piece that actually sails every few years, but a museum piece nonetheless. Her main functions are educational and historic, not military. Her "main function" is to serve as the Flagship of the Navy. That's a military function, not a "museum" function. Certainly she also serves as a "history lesson incarnate", but that is not her "main" function. If it were, she'd be property of the National Park Service, not the Department of Defense. Well, Hans, it looks like we have different definitions of "museum piece" and "military function". I'll defer to your definitions because the USS Constitution is, in fact, the Flagship of the US Navy and is fully operational, with a full time crew. She just doesn't sail very often. And to answer the comment of Clown Prince of Spamalot (aka KB9RGZ), many US Navy ships are not intended to "sail into battle" (a quaint phrase, but it reveals your ignorance of military matters). YTB's tugs don't "sail into battle", DSRV's don't "sail into battle", AD's don't "sail into battle", AOE's don't "sail into battle", AS's don't "sail into battle", ATB's don't "sail into battle", ARS's don't "sail into battle", in fact CVA's don't "sail into battle", and no, the USS Constitution will not "sail into battle", but she's stilla fully commissioned ship of the line in the US Navy. Actually, I suppose that a considerable number of ships would intentionally sail *away* from battle, because they're not meant to be combat ships. The USCG Barque Eagle, homeported at the Coast Guard Academy in Connecticutt, is a working training ship, used in training future seagoing officers. Does she go out on search and rescue? Probably not, but I'm sure she teachs some of the elements of SAR. Navigation is a big part of her training mission, and you can bet that includes things like plotting an expanding-squares search pattern, calculating set and drift, and other topics useful in real world SAR operations. Regardless of that, notall USCG ships "go out on search and rescue". Some go out an tend bouys. Some go out and break ice. Some go out on training missions. Etc., etc., etc. Or is her purpose mostly historic and educational? Very little "historic" about the Eagle. Her purpose is a training ship for Coast Guard Midshipmen. That's just as much a "purpose" as SAR. And the main point remains: Sailboats make up far less than 1% of the US military fleet. Nobody is trying to argue that point, are they? Len was. He seems to be unable to deal with analogies. By the same token, CVA's make up a tiny percent of the US military fleet also, as do ARS's, AOE's, DSRV's, LPH's, and a host of other types. Of course. But they're all "power boats", not "sailboats". Doesn't make their mission any less important, or relegate them to "nothing more than museum pieces". Nor is the Constitution's mission unimportant - although some folks don't value history very much... Ding ding, ding ding, ding ding, ding ding. Eight bells and all's well. Did you get EPA? 73 de Jim, N2EY |
| Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
| Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads
|
||||
| Thread | Forum | |||
| Power Industry BPL Reply Comments & Press Release | Antenna | |||
| Power Industry BPL Reply Comments & Press Release | Antenna | |||
| BPL pollution - file reply comments by August 6 | Antenna | |||
| BPL pollution – file reply comments by August 6 | Antenna | |||
| BPL interference - reply comments - YOUR ACTION REQUIRED | Antenna | |||