Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#41
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Feb 14, 2:32*pm, dave wrote:
bpnjensen wrote: Is it safe, then, to assume that a combination of draws that total somewhat less than the lower rating would not put undue stress on the supply? *(FWIW, I'm still thinking the Astron 7/5 amp supply for my ~ 2.5 amp max needs, or if I feel unsure, the Astron 12/9). *Might even throw a muffin fan on the back. Gentlemen, thanks for all your great help! Bruce I run a 12 Watt radio (K3/10), my LDG Z-100 tuner, *and a 45 Watt amp (Tokyo Hy-Power HL45B) on an Astron SS-12. *The thing never even gets warm. That's reasonable I think. You'd need to amass in the neighborhood of 100-120 watts demand before you'd require roughly an ampere of current, and that should be just barely cruising for the SS-12. |
#42
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
bpnjensen wrote:
On Feb 14, 2:32 pm, wrote: bpnjensen wrote: Is it safe, then, to assume that a combination of draws that total somewhat less than the lower rating would not put undue stress on the supply? (FWIW, I'm still thinking the Astron 7/5 amp supply for my ~ 2.5 amp max needs, or if I feel unsure, the Astron 12/9). Might even throw a muffin fan on the back. Gentlemen, thanks for all your great help! Bruce I run a 12 Watt radio (K3/10), my LDG Z-100 tuner, and a 45 Watt amp (Tokyo Hy-Power HL45B) on an Astron SS-12. The thing never even gets warm. That's reasonable I think. You'd need to amass in the neighborhood of 100-120 watts demand before you'd require roughly an ampere of current, and that should be just barely cruising for the SS-12. The radio uses about 3 Amps on transmit. The amplifier about 5. |
#43
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Feb 14, 10:15*am, "D. Peter Maus"
wrote: On 2/14/10 07:11 , Gregg wrote: On Feb 12, 11:29 am, "D. Peter wrote: On 2/12/10 10:13 , bpnjensen wrote: Pyramids are not especially popular with the Amateur Radio crowd: http://www.eham.net/reviews/products/20 So I have noticed! *But the Astrons, in general, have a loyal following. * * I did some research into the Pyramid supplies. As I said earlier, they were not built for continuous service. Apparently, at any load. Shame, too. With modification, they can be a pretty decent supply. * * Apparently Pyramid has been taking design tips for ICOM. * * ![]() Ah Ha then, maybe dear old former friend wasn't lying then about modding them. He was always modding something when I was over at the shop. *He sure wanted them back pretty bad. Tough. :-I * *They're nice supplies. And as you pointed out, you DID work CB off of one for a couple of years without issue. But that was intermittent service, which is what most of these supplies are built for. * *Most any supply will work for most applications. It's continuous draw that does them in. But that's not a surprise. ICOM's, like R71, R7000, R7100 are renowned for running so damned hot that the back panel can be too hot to touch. Even the factory recommends going in periodically and touching up solder joints, checking components for heat damage. * *And ICOM"s not the only one. But that doesn't mean it's not poor design. * *Which CB rig were you running, and what type of antenna did you use?- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - Nothing awe inspiring Peter, it was part of six pieces I ran in my "fun car." 148GTL (old version) with the slider and 50 watt final with the extra channel kit . I have a homebrewed modulator box ( from a firefighter friend) that I coupled with it when it was in the car. The mod box wasn't really a linear ( though some may call it that) it wasn't really to talk further miles wise - - but it really cleared up the voice - almost like a speach processor if that makes sense. Ninety nine percent of the time I would talk on sideband, I really enjoy having the slider because I could tell a buddy to meet me at a specific freq ( he has the same type of radio) - and it would be absolutely crystal clear - crystal. At times I can talk all over the world when the skip rolls, my funnest time was when I spoke to a gentleman in Trinidad West Indies - in his accent he told me "Unit 67 - you're sounding like a local out here." Fun times.:-) I can just imagine getting my ticket and actually legally be able to have a cup of coffee with someone in Guam. I also have the 29LTD Classic - all tricked out. Ha! Antenna wise I have the Antron with the ground plane radials at the bottom. I also have a big yagi antenna up there but it's not quite setup the way I would like it - coax wise and not having a rotor at the present. How can someone not love this entire hobby is beyond me. I just wish the CB Newsgroup wasn't trashed like it is. You're a Ham I would assume Peter? |
#44
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Feb 14, 10:15*am, "D. Peter Maus"
wrote: On 2/14/10 07:11 , Gregg wrote: On Feb 12, 11:29 am, "D. Peter wrote: On 2/12/10 10:13 , bpnjensen wrote: Pyramids are not especially popular with the Amateur Radio crowd: http://www.eham.net/reviews/products/20 So I have noticed! *But the Astrons, in general, have a loyal following. * * I did some research into the Pyramid supplies. As I said earlier, they were not built for continuous service. Apparently, at any load. Shame, too. With modification, they can be a pretty decent supply. * * Apparently Pyramid has been taking design tips for ICOM. * * ![]() Ah Ha then, maybe dear old former friend wasn't lying then about modding them. He was always modding something when I was over at the shop. *He sure wanted them back pretty bad. Tough. :-I * *They're nice supplies. And as you pointed out, you DID work CB off of one for a couple of years without issue. But that was intermittent service, which is what most of these supplies are built for. * *Most any supply will work for most applications. It's continuous draw that does them in. But that's not a surprise. ICOM's, like R71, R7000, R7100 are renowned for running so damned hot that the back panel can be too hot to touch. Even the factory recommends going in periodically and touching up solder joints, checking components for heat damage. * *And ICOM"s not the only one. But that doesn't mean it's not poor design. * *Which CB rig were you running, and what type of antenna did you use?- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - I forgot to answer the last part of your question. In my car I ran the seven and a half foot skipshooter antenna with the black gum drop mount. I had it drilled right through the middle of my trunk and then used the steel whip that was mounted on the side on the rear passenger side for my shortwave antenna. :-) I have a antenna fetish. lowering my head |
#45
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Feb 14, 2:29*pm, "D. Peter Maus"
wrote: On 2/14/10 12:15 , bpnjensen wrote: On Feb 14, 7:15 am, "D. Peter wrote: On 2/14/10 07:11 , Gregg wrote: On Feb 12, 11:29 am, "D. Peter wrote: On 2/12/10 10:13 , bpnjensen wrote: Pyramids are not especially popular with the Amateur Radio crowd: http://www.eham.net/reviews/products/20 So I have noticed! *But the Astrons, in general, have a loyal following. * * *I did some research into the Pyramid supplies. As I said earlier, they were not built for continuous service. Apparently, at any load. Shame, too. With modification, they can be a pretty decent supply. * * *Apparently Pyramid has been taking design tips for ICOM. * * * ![]() Ah Ha then, maybe dear old former friend wasn't lying then about modding them. He was always modding something when I was over at the shop. *He sure wanted them back pretty bad. Tough. :-I * * They're nice supplies. And as you pointed out, you DID work CB off of one for a couple of years without issue. But that was intermittent service, which is what most of these supplies are built for. * * Most any supply will work for most applications. It's continuous draw that does them in. But that's not a surprise. ICOM's, like R71, R7000, R7100 are renowned for running so damned hot that the back panel can be too hot to touch. Even the factory recommends going in periodically and touching up solder joints, checking components for heat damage. * * And ICOM"s not the only one. But that doesn't mean it's not poor design. * * Which CB rig were you running, and what type of antenna did you use? Peter - Shouldn't a 5 amp output supply be fully adequate to support a CB, even SSB, that would require a draw of maybe 2 amp at transmit? * *That's the point....How is that 5 amps measured? If the 5 amps was measured to be steady for, say 5 minutes, that's considered continuous service. In the case of 2 way radio, 'continuous' may be also considered anything that is not 'peak.' * *The point then becomes 'how does the manufacturer define their terms Peak and Continuous?' And how do they measure these services. * *If the power supply is rated at 5 amps continuous, one may safely assume that 2 amp draw will be no problem. HOWEVER, how is that 5 amp service measured? 5 minutes? 10 minutes? Or do they run the supply until the components reach constant temperature and then rate THEN measure the continous output for a week? * *Probably not. * *Most of the time, the supply is built for intermittent service as found in 2 way radio service. Short bursts, a minute or more, of sustained current at rated output. In this case, 5 amps. And the supply does it handily. But the components never reach constant temperature. * *That same power supply may, if run at 2 amps, reach constant temperature, and the components may not survive that temperature if run continously, ongoing. Read the user reviews at eHam of supplies that have burned up resistors, even though used within their defined ratings. * *Consider. You can take a CB radio out of the box, hook it up and converse for an entire 1500 mile trip without difficult. The components are taking the full rated output--peak and continuous--of the transmission for the entire trip. In bursts of conversation, sometimes a minute, two minutes at a time. * *But that's intermittent service. Tape that key down and let it transmit indefinitely. It will fail. And pretty quickly. The components were rated sufficiently for peak current during voice peaks, and continous current during a conversational segment, but not for continous broadcast. Neither the power input regulators, not the finals will take a full load indefinitely. Even though current can be many times average. Even though the power throughput never exceeds rating. * *The radio used for conversation will be trouble free for years. Used as a broadcast device, it will fail quickly. * *Pirates like to use Ham rigs for their broadcasts. These have to be modified for the duration of a broadcast to meet the extremes of continous ongoing service. Even rigs built with conservatively rated, quality components will not be able to meet the demand of continous ongoing service. Though the same rigs will be in use all day, every day for 2 way conversation without issue. * *It all depends on HOW the power supply ratings are determined. Very few are tested with continous ongoing service in mind. Because that's not what they're purchased for. * *So, that 5 amp rating may be illusory. And though 2 amps may seem logically assumed to be a safe, and troublefree, output for a 5 amp supply, if the components were selected with intermittent service in mind, they may find that 2 amps takes them more slowly to constant temperature, but they do reach constant temperature, where they sit and cook until they fail because they're not sufficiently cooled. And because the supply is built with intermittent service in mind, component cooling is less of a priority, and not a design consideration beyond the minimums. * *That's why when selecting a power supply, current ratings are usually meaningless unless you know how they were determined. Assumptions may be made, but you have to know what assumptions the manufacturer was making as well when the device was designed. * *Read the eHam reviews of some of these supplies. Failure after a short time at current draws well within the performance curve. It is true, the Icoms run hot - specifically with the R75, it is likely the power brick, which supplies almost 50% more voltage to the unit that it requires (near 18 volts). * *The regulator, and the load draw down of the supply, itself, brings down that voltage. The heat is generated by the regulator, but generates so much heat that nearby resistors burn because they can't cool themselves. * *The voltage input to the regulator is higher than the operating voltage at the output of the regulator so that there is something to actually regulate. It's this extra power that's dissipated as heat by the regulator. If there's a voltage sag due to peak draw, or lower input voltage, there's some play for the regulator to work with. * *And the brick, itself is a 'just enough' supply...providing sufficient current for the operation of the radio, with a modest reserve so when all functions are active, and volume is high, audio peaks don't draw more than the radio can access, and modulate the supply rail. *But the very load of the radio itself will draw down the voltage of the brick in operation. * *Measure the voltage of the brick open circuit. 18 v. Now measure the voltage output while the radio is in operation....the voltage will be lower. Closer to 14. This PS is designed with this occurence in mind, and it's normal. A bigger supply with a 12-13.8 voltage input to your radio will provide the same current as the brick, and the radio will get just as hot.- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - Great post Peter, I printed that out to save it.:-) |
#46
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Feb 14, 3:10*pm, bpnjensen wrote:
On Feb 14, 11:29*am, "D. Peter Maus" wrote: On 2/14/10 12:15 , bpnjensen wrote: On Feb 14, 7:15 am, "D. Peter wrote: On 2/14/10 07:11 , Gregg wrote: On Feb 12, 11:29 am, "D. Peter wrote: On 2/12/10 10:13 , bpnjensen wrote: Pyramids are not especially popular with the Amateur Radio crowd: http://www.eham.net/reviews/products/20 So I have noticed! *But the Astrons, in general, have a loyal following. * * *I did some research into the Pyramid supplies. As I said earlier, they were not built for continuous service. Apparently, at any load. Shame, too. With modification, they can be a pretty decent supply. * * *Apparently Pyramid has been taking design tips for ICOM.. * * * ![]() Ah Ha then, maybe dear old former friend wasn't lying then about modding them. He was always modding something when I was over at the shop. *He sure wanted them back pretty bad. Tough. :-I * * They're nice supplies. And as you pointed out, you DID work CB off of one for a couple of years without issue. But that was intermittent service, which is what most of these supplies are built for. * * Most any supply will work for most applications. It's continuous draw that does them in. But that's not a surprise. ICOM's, like R71, R7000, R7100 are renowned for running so damned hot that the back panel can be too hot to touch. Even the factory recommends going in periodically and touching up solder joints, checking components for heat damage. * * And ICOM"s not the only one. But that doesn't mean it's not poor design. * * Which CB rig were you running, and what type of antenna did you use? Peter - Shouldn't a 5 amp output supply be fully adequate to support a CB, even SSB, that would require a draw of maybe 2 amp at transmit? * *That's the point....How is that 5 amps measured? If the 5 amps was measured to be steady for, say 5 minutes, that's considered continuous service. In the case of 2 way radio, 'continuous' may be also considered anything that is not 'peak.' * *The point then becomes 'how does the manufacturer define their terms Peak and Continuous?' And how do they measure these services. * *If the power supply is rated at 5 amps continuous, one may safely assume that 2 amp draw will be no problem. HOWEVER, how is that 5 amp service measured? 5 minutes? 10 minutes? Or do they run the supply until the components reach constant temperature and then rate THEN measure the continous output for a week? * *Probably not. * *Most of the time, the supply is built for intermittent service as found in 2 way radio service. Short bursts, a minute or more, of sustained current at rated output. In this case, 5 amps. And the supply does it handily. But the components never reach constant temperature. * *That same power supply may, if run at 2 amps, reach constant temperature, and the components may not survive that temperature if run continously, ongoing. Read the user reviews at eHam of supplies that have burned up resistors, even though used within their defined ratings. * *Consider. You can take a CB radio out of the box, hook it up and converse for an entire 1500 mile trip without difficult. The components are taking the full rated output--peak and continuous--of the transmission for the entire trip. In bursts of conversation, sometimes a minute, two minutes at a time. * *But that's intermittent service. Tape that key down and let it transmit indefinitely. It will fail. And pretty quickly. The components were rated sufficiently for peak current during voice peaks, and continous current during a conversational segment, but not for continous broadcast. Neither the power input regulators, not the finals will take a full load indefinitely. Even though current can be many times average. Even though the power throughput never exceeds rating. * *The radio used for conversation will be trouble free for years. Used as a broadcast device, it will fail quickly. * *Pirates like to use Ham rigs for their broadcasts. These have to be modified for the duration of a broadcast to meet the extremes of continous ongoing service. Even rigs built with conservatively rated, quality components will not be able to meet the demand of continous ongoing service. Though the same rigs will be in use all day, every day for 2 way conversation without issue. * *It all depends on HOW the power supply ratings are determined. Very few are tested with continous ongoing service in mind. Because that's not what they're purchased for. * *So, that 5 amp rating may be illusory. And though 2 amps may seem logically assumed to be a safe, and troublefree, output for a 5 amp supply, if the components were selected with intermittent service in mind, they may find that 2 amps takes them more slowly to constant temperature, but they do reach constant temperature, where they sit and cook until they fail because they're not sufficiently cooled. And because the supply is built with intermittent service in mind, component cooling is less of a priority, and not a design consideration beyond the minimums. * *That's why when selecting a power supply, current ratings are usually meaningless unless you know how they were determined. Assumptions may be made, but you have to know what assumptions the manufacturer was making as well when the device was designed. * *Read the eHam reviews of some of these supplies. Failure after a short time at current draws well within the performance curve. On the Astron supplies, near as I can tell, the high rating (the amp value implicitly included in the model number) is the 50% duty value, which I assume is what it can more or less safely handle if you switch evenly between a high draw (such as during transmit) and a lower value during receive. *The lower value Astron lists, which is typically about 20-25% below the top value, is what the company claims is the continuous amount it can safely provide continually. Is it safe, then, to assume that a combination of draws that total somewhat less than the lower rating would not put undue stress on the supply? *(FWIW, I'm still thinking the Astron 7/5 amp supply for my ~ 2.5 amp max needs, or if I feel unsure, the Astron 12/9). *Might even throw a muffin fan on the back. Gentlemen, thanks for all your great help! Bruce- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - I have to ask you post - - what is a "muffin fan"? Is it external or internal?feeling like a big old dumbey |
#47
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Feb 15, 12:41*am, Bob Dobbs wrote:
Gregg wrote: I just wish the CB Newsgroup wasn't trashed like it is. Just ignore all the homophobic flames and post as if you're the only person there. -- Operator Bob Echo Charlie 42 I should take your advice Bob. I do - from time to time go over there and lurk and it seems like there are no threads about CB/Antennas, there used to be some pretty informative (at least for IMO) threads. |
#48
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Feb 14, 5:32*pm, dave wrote:
bpnjensen wrote: Is it safe, then, to assume that a combination of draws that total somewhat less than the lower rating would not put undue stress on the supply? *(FWIW, I'm still thinking the Astron 7/5 amp supply for my ~ 2.5 amp max needs, or if I feel unsure, the Astron 12/9). *Might even throw a muffin fan on the back. Gentlemen, thanks for all your great help! Bruce I run a 12 Watt radio (K3/10), my LDG Z-100 tuner, *and a 45 Watt amp (Tokyo Hy-Power HL45B) on an Astron SS-12. *The thing never even gets warm. From Astron website I conclude: SS-XX series are switching power supplies. Great for heavy loads, usually stay cool,but... not perfect enough for me. They generate RF,even the better ones. The ones that were designed for the so-called 'TEMPEST' program probably exist, somewhere. Receivers designed with TEMPEST requirement must be around as well. Somewhere. Otherwise,there is no readily available substitute for a regulated linear power supply. This was recognized long time ago. |
#49
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() |
#50
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Feb 14, 9:52*pm, Gregg wrote:
On Feb 14, 3:10*pm, bpnjensen wrote: On Feb 14, 11:29*am, "D. Peter Maus" wrote: On 2/14/10 12:15 , bpnjensen wrote: On Feb 14, 7:15 am, "D. Peter wrote: On 2/14/10 07:11 , Gregg wrote: On Feb 12, 11:29 am, "D. Peter wrote: On 2/12/10 10:13 , bpnjensen wrote: Pyramids are not especially popular with the Amateur Radio crowd: http://www.eham.net/reviews/products/20 So I have noticed! *But the Astrons, in general, have a loyal following. * * *I did some research into the Pyramid supplies. As I said earlier, they were not built for continuous service. Apparently, at any load. Shame, too. With modification, they can be a pretty decent supply. * * *Apparently Pyramid has been taking design tips for ICOM. * * * ![]() Ah Ha then, maybe dear old former friend wasn't lying then about modding them. He was always modding something when I was over at the shop. *He sure wanted them back pretty bad. Tough. :-I * * They're nice supplies. And as you pointed out, you DID work CB off of one for a couple of years without issue. But that was intermittent service, which is what most of these supplies are built for. * * Most any supply will work for most applications. It's continuous draw that does them in. But that's not a surprise. ICOM's, like R71, R7000, R7100 are renowned for running so damned hot that the back panel can be too hot to touch. Even the factory recommends going in periodically and touching up solder joints, checking components for heat damage. * * And ICOM"s not the only one. But that doesn't mean it's not poor design. * * Which CB rig were you running, and what type of antenna did you use? Peter - Shouldn't a 5 amp output supply be fully adequate to support a CB, even SSB, that would require a draw of maybe 2 amp at transmit? * *That's the point....How is that 5 amps measured? If the 5 amps was measured to be steady for, say 5 minutes, that's considered continuous service. In the case of 2 way radio, 'continuous' may be also considered anything that is not 'peak.' * *The point then becomes 'how does the manufacturer define their terms Peak and Continuous?' And how do they measure these services. * *If the power supply is rated at 5 amps continuous, one may safely assume that 2 amp draw will be no problem. HOWEVER, how is that 5 amp service measured? 5 minutes? 10 minutes? Or do they run the supply until the components reach constant temperature and then rate THEN measure the continous output for a week? * *Probably not. * *Most of the time, the supply is built for intermittent service as found in 2 way radio service. Short bursts, a minute or more, of sustained current at rated output. In this case, 5 amps. And the supply does it handily. But the components never reach constant temperature. * *That same power supply may, if run at 2 amps, reach constant temperature, and the components may not survive that temperature if run continously, ongoing. Read the user reviews at eHam of supplies that have burned up resistors, even though used within their defined ratings. * *Consider. You can take a CB radio out of the box, hook it up and converse for an entire 1500 mile trip without difficult. The components are taking the full rated output--peak and continuous--of the transmission for the entire trip. In bursts of conversation, sometimes a minute, two minutes at a time. * *But that's intermittent service. Tape that key down and let it transmit indefinitely. It will fail. And pretty quickly. The components were rated sufficiently for peak current during voice peaks, and continous current during a conversational segment, but not for continous broadcast. Neither the power input regulators, not the finals will take a full load indefinitely. Even though current can be many times average. Even though the power throughput never exceeds rating. * *The radio used for conversation will be trouble free for years.. Used as a broadcast device, it will fail quickly. * *Pirates like to use Ham rigs for their broadcasts. These have to be modified for the duration of a broadcast to meet the extremes of continous ongoing service. Even rigs built with conservatively rated, quality components will not be able to meet the demand of continous ongoing service. Though the same rigs will be in use all day, every day for 2 way conversation without issue. * *It all depends on HOW the power supply ratings are determined. Very few are tested with continous ongoing service in mind. Because that's not what they're purchased for. * *So, that 5 amp rating may be illusory. And though 2 amps may seem logically assumed to be a safe, and troublefree, output for a 5 amp supply, if the components were selected with intermittent service in mind, they may find that 2 amps takes them more slowly to constant temperature, but they do reach constant temperature, where they sit and cook until they fail because they're not sufficiently cooled. And because the supply is built with intermittent service in mind, component cooling is less of a priority, and not a design consideration beyond the minimums. * *That's why when selecting a power supply, current ratings are usually meaningless unless you know how they were determined. Assumptions may be made, but you have to know what assumptions the manufacturer was making as well when the device was designed. * *Read the eHam reviews of some of these supplies. Failure after a short time at current draws well within the performance curve. On the Astron supplies, near as I can tell, the high rating (the amp value implicitly included in the model number) is the 50% duty value, which I assume is what it can more or less safely handle if you switch evenly between a high draw (such as during transmit) and a lower value during receive. *The lower value Astron lists, which is typically about 20-25% below the top value, is what the company claims is the continuous amount it can safely provide continually. Is it safe, then, to assume that a combination of draws that total somewhat less than the lower rating would not put undue stress on the supply? *(FWIW, I'm still thinking the Astron 7/5 amp supply for my ~ 2.5 amp max needs, or if I feel unsure, the Astron 12/9). *Might even throw a muffin fan on the back. Gentlemen, thanks for all your great help! Bruce- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - I have to ask you post - - what is a "muffin fan"? Is it external or internal?feeling like a big old dumbey Just a little fan, about 7cm x 7cm +/-, usually about 12v or so, used normally for cooling PCs but good for other small cooling tasks as well. RS has them for $15 if you need one in a hurry, but they can be had many places on- and off-line for (much) less. If you got one, you'd probably just fasten it over the heat sink on the back. |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
FA linear power supply with toroid power xformer | Equipment | |||
Wtb: hp-23 power supply | Swap | |||
WTB: HV POWER SUPPLY | Swap | |||
Astron RS-20A Power Supply Great Condition - used to power a VHF radio | Swap | |||
Need help w/ Power Supply | Swap |