22 reviews from owners of the Isotron antennas at URL:
http://www.eham.net/reviews/detail/311

--
Caveat Lector



Someone wrote
Howdy y'all.

I had to finally try one. Got a 40meter Isotron, put it up at about 15'.
It
does work.

Not sure how well, but it sends and hears. Worked a guiy in Cuba from
Awstin, TX and a K6 on CW. Not the greatest reports.

Anybody else tried them?

Just curious. Please no flames. This was idle curiosity.

GeorgeC
W2DB

Hoy!

Thank's for the very interresting link to the isotron reviews. It's nice to
see that citizen's band 's still living on...
Everyone decided to buy one and was pleased by the SWR... but none of them
seemed concerned about radiation patterns and loss (negative gain?), nor by
the classical "how does it work" question.

No they were all happy to kick 50W power in it to make DX with the guy in
the village nearby... DX begins at your door... But never heard about ground
wave propagation.

Nevermind... As far as everybody's happy, it's all good!

73 de F8BOE Olivier ...-.-



"Caveat Lector" a écrit dans le message de news:
RsyKd.3404$5t.454@fed1read07...
22 reviews from owners of the Isotron antennas at URL:
http://www.eham.net/reviews/detail/311

--
Caveat Lector



Someone wrote
Howdy y'all.

I had to finally try one. Got a 40meter Isotron, put it up at about 15'.
It
does work.

Not sure how well, but it sends and hears. Worked a guiy in Cuba from
Awstin, TX and a K6 on CW. Not the greatest reports.

Anybody else tried them?

Just curious. Please no flames. This was idle curiosity.

GeorgeC
W2DB

On Sat, 29 Jan 2005 10:43:25 +0100, "F8BOE"
wrote:

Hoy!

Thank's for the very interresting link to the isotron reviews. It's nice to
see that citizen's band 's still living on...
Everyone decided to buy one and was pleased by the SWR... but none of them
seemed concerned about radiation patterns and loss (negative gain?), nor by
the classical "how does it work" question.

No they were all happy to kick 50W power in it to make DX with the guy in
the village nearby... DX begins at your door... But never heard about ground
wave propagation.

Nevermind... As far as everybody's happy, it's all good!

73 de F8BOE Olivier ...-.-



"Caveat Lector" a écrit dans le message de news:
RsyKd.3404$5t.454@fed1read07...
22 reviews from owners of the Isotron antennas at URL:
http://www.eham.net/reviews/detail/311

--
Caveat Lector



Someone wrote
Howdy y'all.

I had to finally try one. Got a 40meter Isotron, put it up at about 15'.
It
does work.

Not sure how well, but it sends and hears. Worked a guiy in Cuba from
Awstin, TX and a K6 on CW. Not the greatest reports.

Anybody else tried them?

Just curious. Please no flames. This was idle curiosity.

GeorgeC
W2DB





When band conditions are excellent, even a dummy load will work. Most
non-amateurs and many amateurs don't understand this. In some cases
if an antenna works at all, it is great. Anything works better than
nothing. However, those of us who experiment with antennas quickly
learn that the throw of a switch will tell us how much better one
antenna is over another.

To some of us, an economical antenna that doesn't attract attention is
better than a more expensive high gain antenna. To some of us, only
the best performance antenna will suffice. A QRPp station can not
afford to have a high loss antenna where as a QROo station can
overcome the losses with power.


--
Buck
N4PGW

Oh gee all the guy wanted was some opinions which I gave him at
http://www.eham.net/reviews/detail/311

From here he gets all this ranting about CBers and 50 kW
--
Caveat Lector



On Sat, 29 Jan 2005 10:43:25 +0100, "F8BOE"
wrote:

Hoy!

Thank's for the very interresting link to the isotron reviews. It's nice
to
see that citizen's band 's still living on...
Everyone decided to buy one and was pleased by the SWR... but none of them
seemed concerned about radiation patterns and loss (negative gain?), nor
by
the classical "how does it work" question.

No they were all happy to kick 50W power in it to make DX with the guy in
the village nearby... DX begins at your door... But never heard about
ground
wave propagation.

Nevermind... As far as everybody's happy, it's all good!

73 de F8BOE Olivier ...-.-

"Caveat Lector" wrote in message
news:lIOKd.937$1O2.42@fed1read05...
Oh gee all the guy wanted was some opinions which I gave him at
http://www.eham.net/reviews/detail/311

From here he gets all this ranting about CBers and 50 kW
--
Caveat Lector



On Sat, 29 Jan 2005 10:43:25 +0100, "F8BOE"
wrote:

Hoy!

Thank's for the very interresting link to the isotron reviews. It's nice
to
see that citizen's band 's still living on...
Everyone decided to buy one and was pleased by the SWR... but none of
them
seemed concerned about radiation patterns and loss (negative gain?), nor
by
the classical "how does it work" question.

No they were all happy to kick 50W power in it to make DX with the guy
in
the village nearby... DX begins at your door... But never heard about
ground
wave propagation.

Nevermind... As far as everybody's happy, it's all good!

73 de F8BOE Olivier ...-.-




That's similar to "Statistics show Xnprtd products work better! (This study
sponsored by Xnprtd products)".


John

The original poster asked for opinions from those that owned the isotron
antenna -- we gave him that.

Now if he had asked for antenna measurements on an antenna range and
comparisons to other antennas -- that is a different question. And I don't
know where he would have found that answer.

As far as statistics -- fact is 3 out of 10 accidents are caused by drunk
drivers -- thus 7 out of 10 are caused by sober drivers - guess we ought to
get em off the road - huh

--
Caveat Lector



"John Smith" wrote in message
...

"Caveat Lector" wrote in message
news:lIOKd.937$1O2.42@fed1read05...
Oh gee all the guy wanted was some opinions which I gave him at
http://www.eham.net/reviews/detail/311

From here he gets all this ranting about CBers and 50 kW
--
Caveat Lector



On Sat, 29 Jan 2005 10:43:25 +0100, "F8BOE"
wrote:

Hoy!

Thank's for the very interresting link to the isotron reviews. It's nice
to
see that citizen's band 's still living on...
Everyone decided to buy one and was pleased by the SWR... but none of
them
seemed concerned about radiation patterns and loss (negative gain?), nor
by
the classical "how does it work" question.

No they were all happy to kick 50W power in it to make DX with the guy
in
the village nearby... DX begins at your door... But never heard about
ground
wave propagation.

Nevermind... As far as everybody's happy, it's all good!

73 de F8BOE Olivier ...-.-




That's similar to "Statistics show Xnprtd products work better! (This
study sponsored by Xnprtd products)".


John

"Caveat Lector" wrote in message
news:1PVKd.24$bu.4@fed1read06...
The original poster asked for opinions from those that owned the isotron
antenna -- we gave him that.

Now if he had asked for antenna measurements on an antenna range and
comparisons to other antennas -- that is a different question. And I
don't know where he would have found that answer.

As far as statistics -- fact is 3 out of 10 accidents are caused by drunk
drivers -- thus 7 out of 10 are caused by sober drivers - guess we ought
to get em off the road - huh

--
Caveat Lector



Thanks for helping to make my point.

John

Sheesh, you're right. I was just idly curious about the antenna. I know it
isn't the same as 3 elements at 120'. And I did find that it "gets out". But
was wondering what results others had, like how is the 80 or 160 version.
Those bands may be "pushing it" a bit. But maybe not. It certainly had me
grinning, just like when I first built a W5QJR loop years ago and worked JA
on 40 CW with 579, loop next to me, ground floor in house...

But thanks for the additional amusement along the way.

-GeorgeC
W2DB
Awstin, TX

"Caveat Lector" wrote in message
news:1PVKd.24$bu.4@fed1read06...
The original poster asked for opinions from those that owned the isotron
antenna -- we gave him that.

Now if he had asked for antenna measurements on an antenna range and
comparisons to other antennas -- that is a different question. And I don't
know where he would have found that answer.

As far as statistics -- fact is 3 out of 10 accidents are caused by drunk
drivers -- thus 7 out of 10 are caused by sober drivers - guess we ought
to
get em off the road - huh

--
Caveat Lector



"John Smith" wrote in message
...

"Caveat Lector" wrote in message
news:lIOKd.937$1O2.42@fed1read05...
Oh gee all the guy wanted was some opinions which I gave him at
http://www.eham.net/reviews/detail/311

From here he gets all this ranting about CBers and 50 kW
--
Caveat Lector



On Sat, 29 Jan 2005 10:43:25 +0100, "F8BOE"
wrote:

Hoy!

Thank's for the very interresting link to the isotron reviews. It's
nice
to
see that citizen's band 's still living on...
Everyone decided to buy one and was pleased by the SWR... but none of
them
seemed concerned about radiation patterns and loss (negative gain?),
nor
by
the classical "how does it work" question.

No they were all happy to kick 50W power in it to make DX with the guy
in
the village nearby... DX begins at your door... But never heard about
ground
wave propagation.

Nevermind... As far as everybody's happy, it's all good!

73 de F8BOE Olivier ...-.-




That's similar to "Statistics show Xnprtd products work better! (This
study sponsored by Xnprtd products)".


John