"james" wrote...

I just don't like the implication that all sinusiods are
unchanged by amplification,

I neither stated or implied that they are "all sinusiods
are unchanged". You have clearly assumed that from a
simple statement.

Let's be clear about what I stated, which is what several well
qualified people have also stated in their books... that the
waveform is unchanged by amplification.

That is the position of the named engineers, lecturers and heads,
and I am not about to call them stupid by saying it is not as they
state in their books.

Before arguing further, that these people are all wrong and
their employers really should have given you the job, please
look at my other replies. Maybe it will clear up why you
believe these people wrong.


again it is a minor point.

For a minor point, you certainly are willing to spend time
claiming the authors to be "wrong" or "incorrect".
Not something I would do on a "minor point", and without
some damn good references or better qualifications than
all those authors.


Regards,
Peter.
http://www.citizensband.radiouk.com/