On Wed, 22 Oct 2003 16:21:06 -0500, Neil Down
wrote:

lancer wrote in
:

On Wed, 22 Oct 2003 15:08:42 -0500, Neil Down
wrote:

lancer wrote in
:

It sure does matter an antenna may have a low swr on channel
20(under 1.5) but be resonant on 26.835, and if the recieve antenna
is resonant at or near 26.835 what have you got? Was the recieve
antenna tested?


Explain that dumbass, the same receive antenna was used for all the
tests. The SWR or resonant frequency doesn't matter as long as its
not changed during the tests.

Let me phrase it in a way that your simple mind would understand;

Do you think the receive antenna knew which antenna was transmitting
and some how changed its parameters?





wow thats all you could find wrong with what i said?
Let me educate you assclown, the recieve antenna is resonant on 26.835
antenna "a" has a low swr across the band but is actually resonant on
26.835, rememebr resonance is not lowest swr. Antenna B has a low swr
across the band but is resonant on 27.405, which antenna will the
recieve antenna hear better?

No, now go back and read what you originally wrote, and what Tnom
wrote that you responded too. It doesn't matter what frequency the
receive antenna is resonant at as long as you don't change anything
with the receive antenna during the test. The receive antenna could
care less what frequency the transmit antenna is resonant at.

So you trying to everyone that anytime some changes their tuning on
their antenna, everyone else has to retune their antenna to receive
them properly?



Are you saying a recieve antenna tuned for 49 mhz will give the same
meter reading from a 49 mhz antenna as one tuned for 27 mhz. If that was
true why the different need for recieve antennas just hook up any length
of wire. Now will it be a night and day difference I don't know but here
you have a guy testing antennas trying to eliminate variables, looking at
a meter on a 31" tv. Is that the best you can do is argue this point? why
not tell us how max FS doesnt mean lowest SWR.


Do you have a comprehension problem? Thats not what I said dumbass.
He did eliminate a variable, he used the same receive antenna for all
his tests. It doesn't matter what he used for a receive antenna as
long as he used the same one every time. Are you really that damn
dense?