Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
Well here's what I did: I treated it like a peice of coax. I made a
fixture to hold the "feedthru" with semi-rigid coax on one side and a 50 ohm chip resistor on the other. I dropped in a short peice of coax and cal'ed to that. Then checked VSWR, was about 1.00something. Then I took out the coax, dropped in a few feedthrus and got VSWRs about 1.04 - 1.06, which works out to about 53 - 55 ohms or so. How's that sound? |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
|
#13
|
|||
|
|||
Maybe one of the network analyzer experts will jump in at this point --
I'm not one. If I were your client, I certainly wouldn't be satisfied with your methodology. But I'm not your client, so what satisfies me isn't important. Good luck. Roy Lewallen, W7EL wrote: Well here's what I did: I treated it like a peice of coax. I made a fixture to hold the "feedthru" with semi-rigid coax on one side and a 50 ohm chip resistor on the other. I dropped in a short peice of coax and cal'ed to that. Then checked VSWR, was about 1.00something. Then I took out the coax, dropped in a few feedthrus and got VSWRs about 1.04 - 1.06, which works out to about 53 - 55 ohms or so. How's that sound? |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
Could you suggest some way I could do it?
On Wed, 07 Jul 2004 18:29:31 -0700, Roy Lewallen wrote: Maybe one of the network analyzer experts will jump in at this point -- I'm not one. If I were your client, I certainly wouldn't be satisfied with your methodology. But I'm not your client, so what satisfies me isn't important. Good luck. Roy Lewallen, W7EL wrote: Well here's what I did: I treated it like a peice of coax. I made a fixture to hold the "feedthru" with semi-rigid coax on one side and a 50 ohm chip resistor on the other. I dropped in a short peice of coax and cal'ed to that. Then checked VSWR, was about 1.00something. Then I took out the coax, dropped in a few feedthrus and got VSWRs about 1.04 - 1.06, which works out to about 53 - 55 ohms or so. How's that sound? |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
In article , Bill Turner
writes: On 07 Jul 2004 20:39:22 GMT, (Avery Fineman) wrote: No. 10 pFd at 1 GHz has a reactance of 15.9 Ohms. That tosses the VSWR in the bucket if that is part of a "line section." _________________________________________________ ________ A section of coax has both capacitance and inductance. Together, they form the Zo of the line. You are quoting only capacitance while ignoring the inductance. "Ignoring?" No. Spare me a lecture. 10 puffs IS a "small capacitor. You were not talking "inductance." 10 pFd IS a 15.9 Ohm reactance at 1 GHz. That's also a small reactive shunt on this mythical "line section." I grant you, a typical feedthrough capacitor is designed with large capacitance and is used for filtering, but that does not preclude one from being designed to "look" like a piece of coax if the designer wishes. And that was the original question. Sorry, no. The original question concerned testing of what LOOKED LIKE "feedthrough capacitors." The tester was thinking of "treating it like a small section of transmission line." Based on the response of actual testings, such as very low VSWR measured, the gadgets are probably just wire feed- throughs intended for something like passing through a hermetic seal. Those would have very little capacitance and thus would have very little discontinuity...the VSWR would not be raised very much. If those "feedtrhoughs" had really been capacitors, then, in all probability, they would have tested as capacitances on a bridge such as a 1 MHz bridge. A handheld C or L/C meter could have read that on a 1 nFd or 10 nFd scale. Without further ado, based on what was written by the person who has the devices, my opinion is that they are just wire feed- throughs with minimum capacitance and the inductance of a very short piece of straight wire. Those MIGHT work as "line sections" going through a hermetic seal wall of something...but not a very practical way to run a transmission line through that wall. Feed-through CAPACITORS were NEVER rated by "characteristic impedance" (Zo). Not in 1964, not in 2004, not in years between. Wire feedthroughs for sealing-type bulkheads are seldom rated for anything but current carrying capacity and withstanding or flash-over voltage. Those have just conductors going through with minimal capacity to "ground" and minimal inductance straight through. |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
|
#17
|
|||
|
|||
Bill Turner wrote:
But think about this in relation to your statement: We both know of at least one person (and his boss) who wants to know the Zo of a feedthrough capacitor. Do you really think in forty years there has not been ONE OTHER person who might have actually designed such a thing? I've worked with at least ten "engineers" and dozens of bosses who, given a similar bag of feedthroughs containing a slip of paper saying "RPM = 2400 +- 1%", would work for a week designing a test to verify or disprove the spec. -- Spammers are people who are too lazy and cowardly to rob liquor stores, but still want to make money by stealing instead of working. -- Morely Dotes, The Open Sourceror's Apprentice |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
|
#19
|
|||
|
|||
Wes wrote,
Message-id: On Wed, 07 Jul 2004 18:34:15 -0400, wrote: |Well here's what I did: I treated it like a peice of coax. I made a |fixture to hold the "feedthru" with semi-rigid coax on one side and a |50 ohm chip resistor on the other. I dropped in a short peice of coax |and cal'ed to that. Then checked VSWR, was about 1.00something. Then I |took out the coax, dropped in a few feedthrus and got VSWRs about 1.04 |- 1.06, which works out to about 53 - 55 ohms or so. | How's that sound? Like you don't know what you're doing. Your DUT is a two-port device. If you really have a network analyzer, why aren't you using it to measure the device as a two port? Is two port theory even being taught in engineering schools these days? 73, Tom Donaly, KA6RUH |
#20
|
|||
|
|||
They're 50 ohm RF and DC feedthrus. Here's the company:
http://www.shp-seals.com/products_and_Services.htm Click on bulletin 100. Most50 ohm types gave a VSWR of 1.05ish, giving about 53 ( or 47 ) ohms. I also had a few of the DC type that gave a VSWR of 1.4ish, leading to about 25 ohms ( or 75 ohms, could I check the phase to see which?). |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Electrolytic caps question | Equipment | |||
Electrolytic caps question | Boatanchors | |||
Electrolytic caps question | Homebrew | |||
Electrolytic caps question | Equipment | |||
Electrolytic caps question | Homebrew |