Hi All

With these being about equal in price and having a laptop to drive the
Ten Tec what would be the choice here.

I am a novice but both look very good after a few days research, I do
love both.

I need you help to decide based I think more on pure technical merit
than anything. Which scores higher in your opinions?

thanks

Paul Birke PEng (EE)

paul v birke wrote:
Hi All

With these being about equal in price and having a laptop to drive the
Ten Tec what would be the choice here.

I am a novice but both look very good after a few days research, I do
love both.

I need you help to decide based I think more on pure technical merit
than anything. Which scores higher in your opinions?

thanks

Paul Birke PEng (EE)



If you want to use it as a portable, I'd go for the 909. If you want to
use it mostly in one location, I'd go for the ten tec.

Otherwise, I've seen some mixed reviews on the radio labs version of the
909, and I don't recall seeing anything but positive reviews of the 320.

Dear Mark

Should I be considering one or two more machines in this mix.

I really like the WiNRADiO WR-G303e standalone usb machine but it is
slightly out of my price range (and could bring the wife descending
upon me--presently flying under the radar,)

thanks

Paul


Mark S. Holden wrote:
paul v birke wrote:
Hi All

With these being about equal in price and having a laptop to drive the
Ten Tec what would be the choice here.

I am a novice but both look very good after a few days research, I do
love both.

I need you help to decide based I think more on pure technical merit
than anything. Which scores higher in your opinions?

thanks

Paul Birke PEng (EE)



If you want to use it as a portable, I'd go for the 909. If you want to
use it mostly in one location, I'd go for the ten tec.

Otherwise, I've seen some mixed reviews on the radio labs version of the
909, and I don't recall seeing anything but positive reviews of the 320.

wrote:
Dear Mark

Should I be considering one or two more machines in this mix.

I really like the WiNRADiO WR-G303e standalone usb machine but it is
slightly out of my price range (and could bring the wife descending
upon me--presently flying under the radar,)

thanks

Paul



I've heard generally good things about the winradios, but have no
personal experience with them.

I think an external winradio (the USB one you mentioned)would make lots
more sense than an internal one though, as odds are the radio will still
be a fine performer long after whatever card standards we're using now
are impossible to find on new computers.

I advise researching the heck out of purchases and buying whatever you
really want even if it means waiting a couple weeks or months to fit it
in the budget. In the long run, you'll end up with nicer stuff, and
save money.

At least with USB, when the next thing comes along, you could probably
buy a converter. With an internal card, once the standard is dumped,
you are forced to maintain an older PC to use the card.. [Plenty of
people had to dump ISA GPIB cards and buy expensive PCI cards. I'm not
sure how long PCI will last since the new PCs use PCIE. ] On that
alone, I would get the USB radio if you really want to go the black box
route.

I use my gear at home and in the field, so computer controlled radios
are not high on my list. Notebook computers draw too much power for
field use, plus they generate noise.

Mark S. Holden wrote:
wrote:
Dear Mark

Should I be considering one or two more machines in this mix.

I really like the WiNRADiO WR-G303e standalone usb machine but it is
slightly out of my price range (and could bring the wife descending
upon me--presently flying under the radar,)

thanks

Paul



I've heard generally good things about the winradios, but have no
personal experience with them.

I think an external winradio (the USB one you mentioned)would make lots
more sense than an internal one though, as odds are the radio will still
be a fine performer long after whatever card standards we're using now
are impossible to find on new computers.

I advise researching the heck out of purchases and buying whatever you
really want even if it means waiting a couple weeks or months to fit it
in the budget. In the long run, you'll end up with nicer stuff, and
save money.

my thinking also that the internal card is a bad buy

what is the purpose of the converter, I used to know at one time
more frequency bands I guess tuned by the basic 100 kHz to 30 MHZ
winradio box

btw the box is quite small and more than cute, looks well shielded

P

Mark S. Holden wrote:
paul v birke wrote:
Hi All

With these being about equal in price and having a laptop to drive the
Ten Tec what would be the choice here.

I am a novice but both look very good after a few days research, I do
love both.

I


Otherwise, I've seen some mixed reviews on the radio labs version of the
909, and I don't recall seeing anything but positive reviews of the 320.

Review of the radiolabs mods.. Very Positive !!


http://www.radiointel.com/review-sangeansuper909.htm

Another review of the RadioLabs Super 909.

http://www.monitoringtimes.com/html/mtsuper909.pdf

junius

Dear Junius et al

Thanks for all the inputs so far from everyone!!

This particular review is good because it shows that the money spent on
the S909 for sensivitivity is not there. That is the fundamental
question: Are the mods worth the $ for basic 909 == S909 ??!!

Again, my leanings are for the 320D. I likely will not make a decision
for a week.

BTW I will not buy two radios for sure!!

Moreover, I am still wondering what to mortgage to consider the
winradio option as well.
what a beautiful piece of engineering it is. as well as the 320D and
909 basic.

Paul



junius wrote:
Another review of the RadioLabs Super 909.

http://www.monitoringtimes.com/html/mtsuper909.pdf

junius

On Fri, 16 Dec 2005 07:37:20 -0500, paul v birke
wrote:

Hi All

With these being about equal in price and having a laptop to drive the
Ten Tec what would be the choice here.

I am a novice but both look very good after a few days research, I do
love both.

I need you help to decide based I think more on pure technical merit
than anything. Which scores higher in your opinions?

thanks

Paul Birke PEng (EE)


Just purchased a RX320D...hands down the best of the 2. YMMV.

SYSYPHUS' SISTER
Remove all inhibitions to reply