Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
BPL strikes another win ...
Christopher Cox wrote:
gwatts wrote: Christopher Cox wrote: John Smith I wrote: ... Now the internet challenges code tapping amateurs ... This has nothing to do with the Internet or code tapping amateurs. It has to do with some intellectually devoid engineers challenging the reality of the Nyquist rate and placing a device on the only radio frequencys that can be naturally propagated through out the planet. No, I think the engineers are saying 'It can be done, but it will interfere...' and the bean counters look at the 'but it will interfere...' part as the obstacle to overcome (buy off). Engineers don't call the shots, the lawyers and accountants do. If you want someone or something to blame, blame the 'any profit is good' mind set of the greed heads and the politicians who obey their big campaign contributors. I apologize for specifying "Engineers" in my previous post, it was not intentional. 'Engineer' has become a generic term. It's easy to understand why many different professions tend to be referred to as 'engineers,' it has a ring of technical competence to it, for now, and that's why it's co-opted so often. It is frustrating when fact is trumped by the use of relentless verbiage. Or by relentless, willful ignorance, like that on the part of the FCC when it comes to BPL (and a few other services...sigh). The FCC has become another heavily politicized entity run by party hacks endeavoring to abrogate the rights of the little people in favor of the almighty, short-term bottom line. Don't get me wrong, I think profits are good, but not at any cost and certainly not at the expense of future generations, expenses economic, social, environmental... Sigh, Galen, W8LNA |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
BPL strikes another win ...
Christopher Cox wrote:
... This has nothing to do with the Internet or code tapping amateurs. It has to do with some intellectually devoid engineers challenging the reality of the Nyquist rate and placing a device on the only radio frequencys that can be naturally propagated through out the planet. This group will be beaming porn wirelessly throughout the world, what an accomplishment. They should feel proud! Chris The old failed logic recycled one more time; go keep track of who had licenses before code was dropped ... eat your lotus blossoms--it always worked before ... JS |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
BPL strikes another win ...
gwatts wrote:
... No, I think the engineers are saying 'It can be done, but it will interfere...' and the bean counters look at the 'but it will interfere...' part as the obstacle to overcome (buy off). Engineers don't call the shots, the lawyers and accountants do. If you want someone or something to blame, blame the 'any profit is good' mind set of the greed heads and the politicians who obey their big campaign contributors. I think you got it all wrong ... Thinking people decided amateur radio could be left as it is, a good ole boys club of cranky old men communicating at a few WPM ... or, be used to assist millions in high speed data exchange ... the jet plane challenges the horse drawn cart. JS |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
BPL strikes another win ...
|
#15
|
|||
|
|||
BPL strikes another win ...
Jay in the Mojave wrote:
... Jay in the Mojave From all I have seen, nothing is modified, a tap is made and BPL installed. The power grid stands as before ... however, the system I looked at was almost entirely underground to businesses and homes. JS |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
BPL strikes another win ...
Jay in the Mojave wrote:
John Smith I wrote: http://www.redherring.com/Home/22562 JS Hello John and all: One of the things that I haven't seen covered about BPL, is the installation and maintenance costs involved, in a power grid system. We all know that when a system is modified for something that it wasn't designed for that problems will surface. I'll bet money that the power grid system modification and maintenance may be have a significant cost. That was not totally covered, or audited. We've all heard the nightmare stories and seen the enforcement actions taken against Power companies that can't be bothered to fix a broken insulator, bad ground wire, noisy transformer, or whatever that is causing havoc to hams nearby. If they do put in BPL, it will be their very own customers who complain to them. Then they have less of a choice, assuming they want to keep their BPL customers. And they still have to run the fiber. Why don't they just try selling fiber access? Somewhere somehow we got a popular misconception that there is some sort of magic box at the power generating station that supplies internet access to the world. It ain't so. - 73 de Mike KB3EIA - |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
BPL strikes another win ...
Christopher Cox wrote:
John Smith I wrote: Geoffrey S. Mendelson wrote: ... It was "your" choice, Google and their BPL, or Ham radio. Which did you decide? Geoff. When the sword challenged the rock, the sword won. When the gun challenged the sword, the gun won. When the automobile challenged the horse, the auto won. When the washing machine challenged the washboard, the machine won. When tubes challenged the spark-gap xmitter, the tube won. When penicillin challenged herbs, penicillin won. When the birth control pill challenged the condom, the pill won. Now the internet challenges code tapping amateurs ... Regards, JS This has nothing to do with the Internet or code tapping amateurs. It has to do with some intellectually devoid engineers challenging the reality of the Nyquist rate and placing a device on the only radio frequencys that can be naturally propagated through out the planet. It is a political process more than an engineering one. The idea that you "just" plug into the wall socket for your internet is almost irresistible to people who don't actually know how things actually work. Very few things "just" work. This group will be beaming porn wirelessly throughout the world, what an accomplishment. They should feel proud! Oh, BPL will fail, either through pure technical flopping, or the marketplace moving on. None of the arguments for it hold water. My favorite is the argument that it will provide internet service for people in remote areas where they can't get service now. Presumably they don't have service because there isn't any fiber nearby, where other BB providers pick up their signals, and distribute them. All they have to do is run the fiber to these underserved areas. (we all do know that BPL is a last mile delivery service don't we?) Of course that means there will be fiber in the area, so the other providers can come in and beat the pants off of BPL in terms of speed and reliability. - 73 de Mike KB3EIA - |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
BPL strikes another win ...
|
#19
|
|||
|
|||
BPL strikes another win ...
John Smith I wrote:
Christopher Cox wrote: ... This has nothing to do with the Internet or code tapping amateurs. It has to do with some intellectually devoid engineers challenging the reality of the Nyquist rate and placing a device on the only radio frequencys that can be naturally propagated through out the planet. This group will be beaming porn wirelessly throughout the world, what an accomplishment. They should feel proud! Chris The old failed logic recycled one more time; go keep track of who had licenses before code was dropped ... eat your lotus blossoms--it always worked before ... The idea that BPL cam about in order to punish Hams who like Morse code is a new one. - 73 de Mike KB3EIa - |
#20
|
|||
|
|||
BPL strikes another win ...
Michael Coslo wrote:
... The idea that BPL cam about in order to punish Hams who like Morse code is a new one. - 73 de Mike KB3EIa - Now, there is the mindset which got us here in the first place, don't you get it? Hams are just NOT important enough to justify punishment, they simply are holding onto a fraction of the public airwaves which can be placed to much better use ... get real. JS |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Elmer strikes again | Radio Photos | |||
Question About US Strikes In Somalia | CB | |||
Tri-Faced Robesin Strikes Out Again | Policy | |||
Roger strikes again | General | |||
The Uncle strikes again! | CB |